Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.0-flash-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

A rectangle with sharp edges takes indeed a little bit more cognitive visible effort…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-search-preview-high-loc’s answer.
  1. User

    A rectangle with sharp edges takes indeed a little bit more cognitive visible effort than for example an ellipse of the same size. Our ‘fovea-eye’ is even faster in recording a circle. Edges involve additional neuronal image tools. The process is therefore slowed down. What’s the best upscale and downscale filter to use in MPV for that end? Minimize cognitive load and effort and maximize outcomes and comfort. PS C:\Users\Hex> mpv --scale=help Valid values for option scale are: bilinear bicubic_fast oversample spline16 spline36 spline64 sinc lanczos ginseng bicubic hermite catmull_rom mitchell robidoux robidouxsharp box nearest triangle gaussian jinc ewa_lanczos ewa_hanning ewa_ginseng ewa_lanczossharp ewa_lanczos4sharpest ewa_lanczossoft haasnsoft ewa_robidoux ewa_robidouxsharp bartlett cosine hanning tukey hamming quadric welch kaiser blackman sphinx

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, based on your question and the information about how the human eye and brain process shapes, here's an approach to choosing the best upscaling and downscaling filters in MPV to minimize cognitive load and maximize viewing comfort.

    The key idea is to favor filters that produce softer, less sharp images, as these are easier for the brain to process.

    Here's how we can approach this:

    1. Understanding the Goal: We want to minimize the "neuronal image tools" needed to process the image. This translates to avoiding sharp edges and high contrast.

    2. Filter Characteristics:

      • Softer Filters: Filters like bilinear, triangle, gaussian, haasnsoft, and some of the ewa_*soft variants will generally produce softer images. These are likely to be easier on the eyes.
      • Sharper Filters: Avoid filters ending in "sharp" or "sharpest," and generally avoid lanczos and sinc as these are designed to maximize sharpness and detail.
    3. Upscaling (scale): For upscaling, a softer filter can help smooth out pixelation and reduce the harshness of upscaled images. bilinear is a good starting point for its simplicity and speed. spline16 or spline36 are compromises, offering more detail than bilinear but still being relatively soft. haasnsoft and ewa_lanczossoft may also be worth experimenting with.

    4. Downscaling (dscale): For downscaling, the same principles apply. bilinear or triangle are good choices.

    5. Testing: The best approach is to test different filters with the content you watch most often. Pay attention to how your eyes feel after extended viewing.

    Here are some example MPV configurations to try:

    • Softer, minimal processing:

      mpv --scale=bilinear --dscale=bilinear
      
    • Slightly sharper, but still relatively soft:

      mpv --scale=spline16 --dscale=spline16
      
    • Experiment with softer EWA filters:

      mpv --scale=ewa_lanczossoft --dscale=ewa_lanczossoft
      

    To summarize, considering the need to minimize cognitive effort when viewing content, the bilinear filter is probably the best starting point, prioritizing softness and speed. Experiment with spline16, haasnsoft, and ewa_lanczossoft to see if they offer an acceptable balance between detail and comfort for you. Avoid the "sharp" filters. Based on the search results, here's a refined recommendation:

    Prioritize bilinear for both scale and dscale. It's the fastest and simplest, aligning with the goal of minimizing cognitive effort [1, 15, 18].

    If you want to experiment and have a more powerful GPU, consider these cautiously, keeping in mind the goal of reducing cognitive load:

    • spline16: A reasonable compromise, offering a bit more detail than bilinear without introducing excessive sharpness [1, 16].
    • haasnsoft: This is explicitly mentioned as producing a softer look, which is beneficial for reducing cognitive strain [1, 8, 13, 17]. However, one Reddit post mentions a potential issue with haasnsoft and ewa_lanczossoft not having a libplacebo analog [22]. If you encounter errors, this might be the reason.
    • ewa_lanczossoft: Described as good quality and relatively soft [1].

    Important Considerations:

    • "Sharp" Filters: Avoid any filters with "sharp" in the name (e.g., robidouxsharp, ewa_lanczossharp) [1]. These will increase cognitive load.
    • Testing is Key: The best filter will depend on the specific content you're watching and your personal preferences. Experiment and see what feels most comfortable [3].
    • Hardware Decoding (hwdec): While not directly related to the scaling filter, consider your hwdec setting. hwdec=no (the default) might provide the most consistent and bug-free results if you're using video filters, but it uses more resources [10][1]. If your hardware is limited, hwdec=auto or hwdec=auto-safe might be necessary, but be aware of potential compatibility issues, especially with chroma upscaling (cscale) [10, 19].

    Configuration Example:

    To set bilinear for both upscaling and downscaling, add the following lines to your mpv.conf file:

    scale=bilinear
    dscale=bilinear
    

    Your mpv.conf file is typically located in %APPDATA%\mpv on Windows and ~/.config/mpv/ on Linux/macOS [12][2].

    In summary, bilinear is the most likely candidate to meet your objective of minimizing cognitive load. If you have the resources, experiment carefully with spline16, haasnsoft, and ewa_lanczossoft, always prioritizing viewing comfort.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.