Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-pro· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

i would like a book on european mythology. something in a spirit of the "very short…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-reasoning’s answer.
  1. User

    i would like a book on european mythology. something in a spirit of the "very short introduction" series, which would outline the development of indo-european mythology, but without going deep into the latter history about how all this was interplaying centuries later. and i would prefer more fresh books than established classics. and i'd want a single work, not a collection of individual essays on a variety of topics

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    Based on your criteria—a concise, up-to-date, single-volume introduction to European mythology with a focus on Indo-European roots, in the spirit of the "Very Short Introduction" series, and avoiding later historical interplay—here’s a targeted recommendation and some context on the current publishing landscape:

    Recommended Book

    Myth: A Very Short Introduction by Robert A. Segal (2004)
    While not brand new, this book is part of the "Very Short Introduction" series and provides a clear, accessible overview of myth as a concept, including Indo-European traditions. Segal covers the origins, functions, and evolution of myth, touching on comparative mythology and the Indo-European context, without delving too deeply into later historical developments or the interplay of myths in later centuries[7]. It is concise, scholarly, and readable, fitting your request for a single, non-anthologized work.

    Recent Developments

    If you are looking for something even more current and with a focus on the latest interdisciplinary research, consider:

    Indo-European Interfaces: Integrating Linguistics, Mythology and Archaeology (2024), edited by Jenny Larsson, Thomas Olander, and Anders Richardt Jørgensen
    This book is a fresh, interdisciplinary synthesis of the latest research on Indo-European languages, mythology, and archaeology. It unites perspectives from linguistics, comparative religion, and archaeology, reflecting advances in genetics and ancient DNA studies. However, it is an academic anthology, so while it is comprehensive and up-to-date, it is structured as a collection of essays by different scholars, which may not fully match your preference for a single-author, unified narrative[6].

    Other Options and Observations

    • Most recent books on Indo-European or European mythology are either broad anthologies, deep dives into specific traditions (like Norse or Greek), or classic comparative works (e.g., J.P. Mallory’s In Search of the Indo-Europeans), which are now somewhat dated[8][1].
    • There is a notable lack of very recent, single-author, concise introductions to the development of Indo-European mythology that avoid later historical interplay. The field tends to favor either comprehensive academic collections or popular retellings focused on specific mythologies.

    Summary Table

    TitleYearAuthor(s)/Editor(s)FormatFocus on Indo-European RootsUnified NarrativeUp-to-date
    Myth: A Very Short Introduction2004Robert A. SegalSingle authorYes (overview)YesModerate
    Indo-European Interfaces: Integrating Linguistics, Mythology2024Larsson, Olander, Jørgensen (eds.)AnthologyYes (in-depth)NoYes
    In Search of the Indo-Europeans1989J.P. MallorySingle authorYes (classic)YesNo

    Conclusion

    If you prioritize a unified, accessible, and concise introduction, Myth: A Very Short Introduction by Robert A. Segal is the closest match to your request[7]. For the most current research, Indo-European Interfaces is a valuable resource, though it is an edited volume rather than a single-author synthesis[6]. At present, the field lacks a brand-new, single-volume, non-anthologized introduction to Indo-European mythology in the exact style you describe.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.