which was the earliest wg14 proposal for first class arrays
- User
which was the earliest wg14 proposal for first class arrays
Assistant
The earliest WG14 proposal specifically targeting "arrays as first class objects"—meaning arrays with value semantics such as assignment, return from functions, and more regular type behavior—was WG14 N391/X3J11 94-076, titled "Arrays as first class objects" and authored by Frank Farance. This proposal was published after the main run of the NCEG (Numerical C Extension Group) and is referenced as a foundational document in later discussions about array semantics in C[1].
Later proposals, such as WG21 P1997 (referenced in both WG14 and WG21 discussions), build upon these earlier ideas, aiming to relax restrictions on array copy semantics, enable array assignment, and allow arrays to be returned from functions—steps toward making arrays first-class citizens in the language[2][5]. However, the N391 proposal by Farance is the earliest known formal WG14 document on this topic[1].
Summary Table
Proposal Title Author Date/Context Key Idea WG14 N391/X3J11 94-076 Arrays as first class objects Frank Farance Post-NCEG, pre-C99 (1994) Arrays with value semantics (assignment, return, etc.) WG21 P1997 Relaxing Restrictions on Arrays Stier & Stasiowski 2021 (C/C++ compatibility) Array assignment, return, regularization Thus, WG14 N391/X3J11 94-076 by Frank Farance is the earliest known WG14 proposal for first class arrays[1].
- User
why did it fall through
Assistant
The proposal to make arrays first-class objects in C (such as allowing assignment, return by value, and more regular type behavior) fell through primarily due to the C standards committee's longstanding philosophy of codifying only "common existing practice" and maintaining the traditional spirit and simplicity of C[14][16]. Several key reasons contributed to its rejection:
- Lack of Existing Practice: The committee's charter emphasized standardizing features already widely implemented and used in existing C dialects. At the time, first-class arrays were not a common feature in C compilers or programming practice, making such a fundamental change outside the committee's mandate[14][16].
- Portability and Compatibility Concerns: Introducing first-class arrays would have required significant changes to the C object and type model, potentially breaking existing code and reducing portability across different compilers and platforms. The committee was cautious about changes that could quietly alter the semantics of valid programs or disrupt the established ecosystem[14][16].
- Complexity and Implementation Burden: Allowing arrays as first-class objects would have added complexity to the language specification and to compiler implementations. The committee aimed to keep C simple and efficient, and was wary of features that could complicate the language or its implementations without clear, widespread demand[14][16].
- Preservation of the "Spirit of C": The committee prioritized preserving the traditional, low-level, and predictable nature of C. Features that introduced higher-level abstractions or behaviors seen as "un-C-like" were generally viewed with skepticism unless there was overwhelming practical justification[14][16].
These principles are documented in the C Rationale documents, which explain that proposals not reflecting common practice, or those that would significantly alter the language's character or portability, were typically rejected or deferred[14][16].
In summary, the first-class array proposal fell through because it was seen as too radical a departure from established C practice, posed risks to portability and simplicity, and did not align with the committee's conservative approach to language evolution[14][16].
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.