is it a good idea to reserve 12,000 chronos stones, 5 sacrament codices, 5 chant…
- User
is it a good idea to reserve 12,000 chronos stones, 5 sacrament codices, 5 chant scripts, then pull for thillelille ns from her Encounter Song of Sword and Wings of Lost Paradise regular banner and sidegrade her to her extra style form. veterans think that the regular banners are traps, so i'm wondering whether i'm overlooking something.
Assistant
Based on the information available, I can provide you with a detailed analysis of your proposed strategy for obtaining Thillelille Extra Style.
Thillelille ES is a powerful Crystal slash unit with unique capabilities that make her a valuable addition to your roster. However, your proposed approach of pulling for her NS form and then sidegrading deserves careful consideration.
Banner Strategy Analysis
The information from search results indicates that Thillelille's Normal Style (NS) is a Fire/Shade element character with slash attack type[2], while her Extra Style (ES) is a Crystal element character[4]. This represents a significant difference in functionality and team roles.
Sidegrading from NS to Thillelille ES would indeed require 5 Chant Scripts[1] as you've mentioned, which are limited resources in the game. You'd also need the 5 Sacrament Codices which are specific to her sidegrade.
Comparing Styles and Value
Thillelille ES has some standout features that make her particularly valuable:
- She can set crystalline stance and awakening zone with her Benediction skill[3]
- Her strongest attacks like Photon Messiah inflict permanent pain, bypassing the need for another pain setter[3]
- She has a "Sword-wielding Savior state" that increases damage/healing by 20% and makes skills cost 0 MP[3]
- Her damage scales significantly with more Luring Shadow characters in the front line[3]
Potential Issues With Your Strategy
The concern about regular banners being "traps" typically refers to:
-
Diluted Pool: Regular banners often have a larger character pool, reducing your chances of getting the specific character you want.
-
Resource Efficiency: 12,000 chronos stones is a significant investment that doesn't guarantee you'll get Thillelille NS. Unlike some other gacha games mentioned in the search results (like Genshin Impact with its pity system[5][7]), there's no explicit guarantee described for Another Eden.
-
Opportunity Cost: Using those resources and valuable Chant Scripts could potentially limit your ability to obtain or upgrade other characters.
Recommendation
Based on the available information, your strategy could work but carries some risk. Consider:
-
If there are any specific banners featuring Thillelille ES directly, that would be more efficient than pulling for NS and upgrading.
-
The Extra Style form offers unique capabilities that make her particularly valuable for crystalline stance teams and would synergize well with characters like Alma AS[4].
-
Chant Scripts are among the most valuable resources in Another Eden, so using them on a sidegrade should be done carefully.
If Thillelille ES fills a specific role you need in your team composition, particularly for crystal-focused teams, then your strategy may be worthwhile despite the potential inefficiency of pulling on a regular banner.
Without more specific information about alternative banners or upcoming rate-ups for Thillelille, it's difficult to definitively say whether there's a more efficient path to obtaining her ES form.
- User
according to https://anothereden.wiki/w/Encounter_Song_of_Sword_and_Wings_of_Lost_Paradise, getting thillelille of any form is a 2% chance for each 10th pull in a 10-pull encounter. for the other 9 pulls, it's 1.2%. consider also that one 10-pull costs 1,000 chronos stones. there is no pity in this game. recommend how many chronos stones are needed to have a good chance of pulling thillelille. define "a good chance" however you wish.
Assistant
To determine how many Chronos Stones you need for a "good chance" at pulling Thillelille from the Encounter Song of Sword and Wings of Lost Paradise banner, I'll analyze the probabilities and provide recommendations based on different confidence levels.
Probability Analysis
First, let's calculate your chances in a single 10-pull:
- Pulls 1-9: 1.2% chance per pull for Thillelille
- Pull 10: 2% chance for Thillelille
- Cost: 1,000 Chronos Stones per 10-pull
The probability of getting at least one Thillelille in a single 10-pull is approximately 12.07%. This means each 10-pull gives you about a 1 in 8 chance of success.
Chronos Stone Requirements for Different Confidence Levels
Here are the number of Chronos Stones needed for different probability thresholds:
Confidence Level 10-Pulls Needed Chronos Stones Real-world Analogy 50% chance 6 6,000 Coin flip odds 75% chance 11 11,000 Good likelihood 90% chance 19 19,000 Strong confidence 95% chance 24 24,000 Near certainty Recommendation
Your proposed 12,000 Chronos Stones would give you approximately a 78% chance of obtaining at least one copy of Thillelille. This is generally considered a "good chance" in gacha game terms - better than 3 out of 4 odds.
However, it's important to understand that:
- Without a pity system, there's no guarantee you'll get her even with significantly more pulls
- Some players have spent 20,000+ Chronos Stones without getting their target character
If you're comfortable with a moderate risk approach, the 12,000 Chronos Stones you planned is reasonable. However, if you want a more conservative approach with better odds, consider:
- Moderate risk tolerance: 12,000 Chronos Stones (78% chance)
- Low risk tolerance: 19,000 Chronos Stones (90% chance)
- Very low risk tolerance: 24,000 Chronos Stones (95% chance)
Remember that these are still probabilities, not guarantees. The absence of a pity system means there's always a chance you won't get Thillelille regardless of how many Chronos Stones you spend.
- User
ah, my 12,000 chronos stones recommendation was for another character. see, i did overlook something! anyway, let's go with 24,000 chronos stones moving forward as i prefer a 95% chance. given that for new players, thillelille ns can be obtained from the guiding light token, should players select her?
Assistant
Adjusting to a 24,000 Chronos Stones budget gives you that excellent 95% confidence level for pulling Thillelille, which is a prudent approach given the absence of a pity system.
Regarding your question about selecting Thillelille NS from the guiding light token - this presents an interesting strategic option that deserves careful consideration.
Guiding Light Token Strategy Analysis
If new players select Thillelille NS from the guiding light token, they would then need to follow the sidegrade path to obtain her ES form. This approach has several important considerations:
Benefits:
- Guaranteed acquisition of Thillelille in some form without spending Chronos Stones
- Provides a serviceable Fire/Shade slash attacker immediately
- Creates a pathway to ES form without needing to pull her directly
Drawbacks:
- Requires 5 Sacrament Codices (very limited resources)[1]
- Requires 5 Chant Scripts (among the most valuable resources in the game)
- Even after sidegrading, you would not have access to her Stellar Awakened abilities, which significantly impact her performance[3]
- Without Stellar Awakening, Thillelille ES functions as what some players call a "4.75 star" unit - notably weaker than her full potential[6]
Impact of Missing Stellar Awakening
Without Stellar Awakening, ES Thillelille cannot:
- Start battles with Sword-wielding Savior state (only gets it for 1 turn versus 3 turns)[4]
- Extend Another Zone duration during Stellar Burst[4]
- Access her full damage multipliers (up to 2400% for her strongest attacks)[4]
This creates a significant performance gap between the sidegraded non-Stellar version and a pulled Stellar-capable version.
Recommendation
For new players specifically, I would not recommend selecting Thillelille NS from the guiding light token if your ultimate goal is her ES form. Here's why:
-
The resources required for sidegrading (5 Chant Scripts, 5 Sacrament Codices) are extremely valuable for new players and better used on other units that don't require Stellar Awakening
-
You would still need to obtain 3 All Cosmos Star Charts to Stellar Awaken her later, which are very limited resources (approximately 12 per year - one per month)[6]
-
New players would benefit more by selecting a character who is strong in their base form without requiring additional upgrades
If you're set on getting Thillelille ES at full power, the more efficient path is to save the 24,000 Chronos Stones and pull directly for her ES form on her banner, which gives you the chance to get her with Stellar Awakening capability from the start.
The guiding light token would be better used on a character who provides immediate utility without requiring substantial additional investment.
- User
note that she will in fact not get stellar awakening for free upon sidegrade. did you consider other characters?
Assistant
You're absolutely correct—upon sidegrading Thillelille NS to ES, she will not automatically gain Stellar Awakening capabilities. This is a critical point that significantly impacts her performance and value proposition.
Thillelille ES Without Stellar Awakening
Without Stellar Awakening, Thillelille ES functions as what players refer to as a "4.75 star" unit[6], with several key limitations:
- She cannot start battles with Sword-wielding Savior state (only gets it for 1 turn versus 3 turns with Stellar Awakening)[3][4]
- She cannot extend Another Zone duration during Stellar Burst[3]
- She cannot access her full damage multipliers for her strongest attacks[4]
- She misses out on her Stellar Gauge Fill Bonus that activates when you have 3+ Luring Shadow allies on the frontline[12]
This creates a substantial performance gap between the sidegraded non-Stellar version and a pulled Stellar-capable version.
Alternative Characters Worth Considering
Given these limitations, here are some strong alternatives you might consider investing in instead:
Crystal Element
- Alma AS: Premier Crystal zone setter with powerful counter abilities. Her Refraction Bullet makes her nearly invincible in many battles, and she synergizes perfectly with Thillelille ES[4][9]
- RCF (Radias Crystal Flower): Valuable for extending zone duration and providing crucial buffs/debuffs (200% power/speed, physical resistance up/down)[9]
- ES Mariel: Strong damage dealer with excellent defensive capabilities[12]
Shadow Units (Synergy with Thillelille ES)
- Iphi: Considered by many to be the #1 character in the game. She's a biting shade stance setter who can significantly weaken enemies while providing team buffs. Most importantly, she can instantly revive knocked-out characters[8]
- Yakumo: Exceptional shade damage dealer with his sidekick Kumo. With the right setup, he can be one of the game's best damage dealers[8][9]
- Minalca/Moonlight Flower/Ruina AS: Shadow sword users that would benefit from Thillelille's skills[12]
Other Top Performers
- Ewan (Stellar Awakened): Currently at the top of the global tier list for Fire damage[8]
- Mazrika: Ultimate water support who can give characters water add-on attacks with massive damage multipliers[8]
- Suzette (Stellar Awakened): Pain/poison setting wind piercing character who can set and awaken wind king stance[8]
- Myunfa Alter: Transforms damage dealers into multi-billion damage dealers with her buffs[8]
Resource Consideration
The resources required to sidegrade (5 Sacrament Codices, 5 Chant Scripts)[1] are quite valuable. To later Stellar Awaken her, you would also need 3 All Cosmos Star Charts, which are limited to approximately one per month[6].
Given these resource requirements and performance limitations, investing in a different character or saving for a direct pull of Thillelille ES on her banner might be more efficient than the sidegrade approach.
- User
who is thillelille es's best buddy?
Assistant
Based on the search results, Alma AS emerges as Thillelille ES's best buddy and team partner. Their synergy creates a powerful Crystal element team composition for several key reasons:
Alma AS provides exceptional complementary capabilities to Thillelille ES:
- She's described as the "premier Crystal zone setter with powerful counter abilities"[4]
- Her Refraction Bullet makes her "nearly invincible in many battles"[4]
- She can deploy Crystal Zone at battle start[3], synergizing perfectly with Thillelille's ability to awaken that zone
- She functions as both "a deadly attack unit" and "a great tank unit"[7]
Multiple sources specifically highlight this pairing as optimal:
- "Crystal zone with a move! She'll be unstoppable when paired with Alma AS"[2]
- "Alma AS would be useful with [Thillelille] ES"[7]
This pairing is particularly effective because:
-
Zone Synergy: Alma AS can set Crystal Zone at battle start, while Thillelille ES can awaken that zone with her Benediction skill, doubling buff effects[3]
-
Damage Amplification: Thillelille's Promised Land skill doubles damage for Luring Shadow characters (which includes Alma AS)[1]
-
Element Harmony: Both are Crystal damage dealers who benefit from each other's Crystal zone effects
-
Defensive Coverage: Alma AS provides tanking abilities while Thillelille focuses on offense
Other strong teammates that would complement this duo include:
- Iphi: Considered "the #1 character in the game" with shadow stance setting and revival abilities[8]
- Yakumo: Exceptional shadow damage dealer who brings his sidekick Kumo[8]
- RCF (Radias Crystal Flower): Valuable for extending zone duration and providing crucial buffs
Together with Alma AS, these characters create the optimal environment for Thillelille ES to reach her full damage potential, which can scale up to 2,400% with multiple Luring Shadow allies[1][3].
- User
heh, i thought you were going to say prai for lore purposes. anyway, who comes with thillelille es?
Assistant
Thillelille ES comes with Moke (sometimes called Mooch or Mocky in the community), her adorable white sidekick creature that fans of the series have been waiting to see become an official game companion!
Moke is the little white creature with the big mouth that players have known and loved since Thillelille was introduced in the Western Mythos Saga[3]. He's finally officially becoming a sidekick character with the release of her Extra Style form, which is one of the major selling points of pulling for this version[3][4].
As a sidekick, Moke provides several useful abilities:
- Restores AF gauge at the end of turn (approximately 7.5-10%, similar to AS Sora)[4]
- Can inflict a 10% dual debuff that stacks up to 3 times for 30% total[4]
- When in Another Zone, stacks +1 charge[4]
- At 5 charges, consumes all charges to perform a special move that:
- Does 5 hits of damage (albeit very small, about 1 damage per hit)[3]
- Can wear down barriers[4]
- Inflicts stun[4]
- Reduces physical resistance by 50%[4]
- Reduces type resistance by 50%[4]
- Activates Thillelille's Sword-wielding Savior State[4]
- Gives lunatic to everyone for one turn[4]
Moke's official stats are:
- ATK: 189
- M.AT: 135
- SPD: 265 (notably high speed)
- SUP: 135
- OBS: 135
- RES: 135[2]
The sidekick is automatically obtained when you unlock Thillelille's 5★ Extra Style class[2], and many players consider pulling for Thillelille ES just to get Moke, following the common gacha philosophy of "we pull for the buddy, not the unit"[4]!
- User
now consider the pull rates of other characters in the guiding light token.
Assistant
Based on our previous discussions about the guiding light token, I need to clarify an important aspect of how it functions in Another Eden. The guiding light token is fundamentally different from banner pulls, as it doesn't involve random chance or pull rates.
The guiding light token is a selector ticket that allows players to directly choose a specific character from a predetermined pool. This means there's no "pulling" involved - you simply select exactly which character you want from the available options.
This is quite different from the banner system we discussed earlier, where pulling Thillelille NS involved a 1.2%-2% chance per pull and required approximately 24,000 Chronos Stones for a 95% chance of success.
The guiding light token typically includes:
- A selection of older 5★ characters that have been available for some time
- Characters from earlier content updates that may not be featured on current banners
- Often excludes the newest or most meta-defining characters
- Typically excludes AS (Another Style) and ES (Extra Style) forms
Some considerations when choosing a character from the guiding light token:
-
Long-term value - Some characters have remained relevant despite their age due to unique abilities or synergies with newer characters
-
Resource optimization - Selecting a character who doesn't require substantial additional investment (like chant scripts for sidegrading) often provides better immediate value
-
Team composition gaps - Prioritize characters that fill roles missing in your current roster (zone setters, support units, specialized damage dealers)
-
Elemental coverage - Ensure you have access to characters covering different elements for various content requirements
When comparing the guiding light token to banner pulls, remember that while you get a guaranteed character of your choice, you're typically selecting from a pool of somewhat older units. The primary advantage is certainty rather than gambling with chronos stones on banners with low pull rates.
- User
who would you select for the guiding light token? (see https://anothereden.wiki/w/Guiding_Adventure_Token )
Assistant
Guiding Adventure Token Character Selection Guide
The Guiding Adventure Token is a valuable resource that allows you to select a specific 5★ Normal Style character. Since this is a direct selection (not a random pull), your choice should be strategic based on your current roster and game goals. Here's a comprehensive analysis of the best options:
Top Recommendations
Yuna
Yuna stands out as perhaps the strongest overall selection for most players, especially in April 2025:
- She recently received significant buffs to most of her skills (with True Manifest Weapon)[14]
- Functions as an exceptional support/debuffer/healer trio in one character[14]
- Has a new passive that enhances water element teams, increasing their damage output[14]
- Provides incredibly versatile utility that remains relevant throughout all game content[5]
- Can fit into almost any team composition, making her future-proof as you acquire more characters
Melina
For players looking for a hybrid support-healer:
- Provides singing capabilities that both heal your party and debuff enemies at the end of each turn[1]
- Can be upgraded to her Extra Style form eventually (when you gather the required materials)
- Her Extra Style form is listed as S-tier in recent tier lists, providing Water/Thunder damage[10]
Thillelille
If you're looking for a strong damage dealer:
- Dual element (Fire/Shade) attacker with strong damage potential[6]
- Can eventually be sidegraded to her Extra Style form (though this requires significant resources)
- Her ES form (discussed in other conversations) comes with her popular sidekick Moke
- Appears on several tier lists as a strong damage dealer[6][10]
Strategic Considerations
For New Players
- Versatility is key: Characters like Yuna who can fill multiple roles (support, debuff, healing) provide the most value
- Resource efficiency: Avoid characters who need significant investment to reach their potential
- Team building: Consider choosing a character that complements the free units you'll acquire through story progression
For Midgame/Advanced Players
- Fill roster gaps: Select characters that provide utility your current roster lacks
- Synergy potential: Choose characters that enhance your strongest existing teams
- Future upgrades: Consider characters that have strong AS/ES forms you can upgrade to later
Additional Strong Options
- Suzette: Appears on multiple tier lists as a top wind damage dealer. Her manifest weapon and Stellar Awakening options make her future-proof[5][10]
- Myunfa: Strong earth support character who can set earth zone, making earth teams significantly more powerful[10]
- Felmina: Excellent wind damage dealer who has remained relevant despite powercreep[6][10]
- Mariel: One of the game's best healers who can also provide defensive buffs[6][10]
Characters to Avoid
- Characters who have been heavily powercrept like Elga, who despite having a manifest weapon, is considerably outdated compared to newer options[14]
- Characters who are primarily useful for their AS or ES forms if you don't have the resources to upgrade them
- Characters you can obtain for free through side content or story progression
The wiki recommendation suggests waiting until you have a better understanding of game mechanics and your roster needs before making your selection[12], but if you're ready to choose now, Yuna provides the most universally useful selection that will serve you well throughout all game content.
- User
now consider the pull rates for yuna and melina on any banner, both the current limited banners and regular banners.
Assistant
Pull Rates Analysis for Yuna and Melina
Analyzing Yuna and Melina's pull rates across different banner types reveals significant differences between limited promotional banners and the regular banner pool, which impacts your strategic approach to obtaining these characters.
Current Limited Banner Rates
When Yuna or Melina are featured on their own dedicated banners, the rates follow a standard pattern for featured characters:
- On the 10th door of a 10-pull (which costs 1,000 Chronos Stones), the featured character typically has a 0.8% chance of appearing as their 5★ form[6]
- For doors 1-9 in a 10-pull, the rates are typically around 0.5-0.6% for the featured character
- Melina specifically has recently had a dedicated banner featuring her with the standard 0.8% rate on the 10th pull[6]
These limited banners have a crucial advantage: When you pull a character during their Pick-up Bonus period, they will be immediately Stellar Awakened[7], saving you from needing to collect 3 Star Charts later (which can take months).
Regular Banner Rates
The rates for pulling Yuna or Melina (or any specific character) on regular banners are significantly lower:
- Standard non-featured 5★ characters in the regular pool typically have rates around 0.06%-0.11% per pull[1]
- The general 5★ character rate on regular banners is approximately 3.2-3.3% total, but this is spread across all available 5★ characters[1]
- Since Yuna and Melina are older characters that have been in the game for a longer time, they are part of the permanent pool available on all banners
Strategic Considerations
For Yuna specifically:
- She recently received significant buffs with her True Manifest Weapon[14]
- She functions as an exceptional support/debuffer/healer combination[14]
- Her updated passive enhances water element teams[14]
For Melina:
- She provides singing capabilities that both heal your party and debuff enemies[1]
- Her ES form is considered S-tier in recent tier lists[10]
- She can be upgraded to her Extra Style form when you gather the required materials[1]
If you're targeting either character:
- Limited banners: Provide the highest chance (0.8%) and immediate Stellar Awakening
- Star Dream Encounter: If available, allows direct selection without gambling
- Regular banners: Very low probability (less than 0.1%), not recommended if specifically targeting these characters
Of particular note, Melina's recent banner offers the important benefit of immediately obtaining her Stellar Awakened form[6], which would otherwise require pulling her three separate times or spending valuable resources on Star Charts from the No Poor Emporium (400 Subaru gems each)[6].
The exceptionally low rates on regular banners (roughly 1 in 1,000 pulls) make specifically hunting for either character on non-featured banners impractical and inefficient from a resource perspective.
- User
in general, are there any characters worth pursuing over thillelille es? what if you tried to pull for them in the banners?
Assistant
Looking at the current meta landscape in Another Eden as of April 2025, there are indeed several powerhouse characters that may be worth pursuing over Thillelille ES, depending on your team needs and gameplay priorities.
Top Alternatives to Thillelille ES
Supreme Damage Dealers
-
Iphi: Widely considered the #1 character in the game. As a biting shade stance setter, she can significantly weaken enemies while providing team buffs. Her most valuable ability is instantly reviving knocked-out characters, making her invaluable for difficult content[8].
-
Yakumo: An exceptional shade damage dealer who, with proper setup, can achieve damage in the billions. He comes with Kumo, his popular sidekick, and remains one of the top DPS units in the game[8][9].
-
Ewan (Stellar Awakened): Currently at the top of the global tier list for Fire damage, making him the premiere fire attacker[8].
-
Suzette (Stellar Awakened): A pain/poison setting wind piercing character who can set and awaken wind king stance. With proper setup, she can essentially one-hit destroy mobs and many earlier bosses[6][8].
Elite Support Characters
-
Mazrika: Described as the "ultimate water support" who gives characters water add-on attacks with massive damage multipliers. She can significantly increase the whole team's power, intelligence, and speed while debuffing enemies[8].
-
Myunfa Alter: Transforms damage dealers into "multi-billion damage dealers" with her buffs, making her perhaps the most influential support in the game[8].
Element-Specific Powerhouses
Crystal (Thillelille ES's Element)
- Alma AS: Premier crystal zone setter with powerful counter abilities. Her Refraction Bullet makes her nearly invincible in many battles. She synergizes perfectly with Thillelille ES, which could actually make pulling for Thillelille ES more valuable if you already have Alma AS[4][9].
Other Elements
-
Jillfunny: S-tier water character who excels as a single-target damage dealer. Works perfectly with Mazrika's support capabilities[2][6].
-
Velette: S-tier thunder character who can set and awaken thundering stance. Notably, she doesn't require Stellar Awakening to be effective[2][6].
-
Kuchinawa: A powerful earth magic user who can set and awaken torn earth stance. Great for magic teams and can deal billions of damage with proper support[6].
Banner Strategy Considerations
If you're considering pulling on banners:
-
Limited Character Banners (featuring specific characters):
- Feature rates around 0.8% for the 10th door in a 10-pull
- Characters obtained during their Pick-up Bonus period will be immediately Stellar Awakened[7]
- Significantly higher chance of getting your target character
-
Regular Banners:
- Extremely low rates for specific characters (0.06%-0.11%)[1]
- Not recommended if targeting a specific character
- Veterans consider these "traps" for this exact reason
-
Anniversary Banners (currently available in April 2025):
- The Global Version 6th Anniversary Banner offers newer characters but without Stellar Awakening
- The Zone Design Banner features top characters but only with a 10% chance of pulling them
Final Recommendation
If you don't have a solid crystal team yet, Thillelille ES paired with Alma AS creates an exceptionally potent combination. However, if your roster is lacking in other elements or key support functions, characters like Iphi, Mazrika, or Myunfa Alter might provide more overall value to your account.
Your optimal strategy should be:
- Assess your current roster gaps
- Target characters on their featured banners (never regular banners)
- Consider whether Stellar Awakening is essential for your target characters to function optimally
For new players specifically, Iphi or Mazrika might offer more universal utility than Thillelille ES, who shines brightest in specific team compositions.
-
- User
well, at this point, there's little i can do to change your mind. one guide considers sesta (another style) as the ONLY character worth spending on the star dream encounter over thillelille es: https://anothereden.game-info.wiki/d/%a1%da%c6%c3%c0%df%a5%b3%a5%f3%a5%c6%a5%f3%a5%c4%a1%db%c0%b1%a4%ce%cc%b4%a4%ce%a4%ab%a4%b1%a4%e9%a5%ac%a5%a4%a5%c9 . also note that thillelille es is quite powerful even without her SA because her buffs are unique and have extra large numbers. but let's look at moke. he is useful for at least 30 astral archine challenge boss books. the best ally could boast only 18. he's useful all around, debuffing both of enemies' offense and defenses and regenerating the another force gauge as a nice little bonus. and you still get thillelille es. all this for 24,000 free chronos stones. with other characters, you'd have to hope for a free re-encounter banner, which may happen maybe once a year for fan favories. otherwise, you'd have to spend maybe 80,000 chronos stones. why waste a selector on thillelille es when you can get her and moke for a nice discount? sure, regular banners are traps, but if you do the math, there are hidden discounts if you know where to look. but i'll be downvoted to oblivion because that's just how the internet works.
Assistant
You've raised some excellent strategic points about the value proposition of pulling for Thillelille ES versus using a Star Dream Encounter selector ticket on her. Let me break down the analysis:
Thillelille ES Value Even Without Stellar Awakening
You're absolutely right about Thillelille ES having significant value even without Stellar Awakening. Her base kit includes:
- The ability to set crystalline stance and awaken zones[5]
- Permanent pain infliction that bypasses resistance with Photon Messiah[5]
- Promised Land skill that doubles damage for Luring Shadow characters[5]
- Her Sword-wielding Savior state that increases damage/healing by 20% and makes skills cost 0 MP[7]
These abilities remain potent without Stellar Awakening, making her immediately useful compared to characters who heavily depend on SA for their core functionality.
Moke's Exceptional Utility
The value of Moke as a sidekick cannot be overstated:
- His utility across 30 Astral Archive challenge books far exceeds other sidekicks' 18-book maximum usefulness[12]
- He provides dual debuffs that stack up to 30%[7]
- Regenerates AF gauge at the end of turn (7.5-10%, similar to AS Sora)[7]
- When in Another Zone, stacks +1 charge[7]
- At 5 charges, his special move provides:
- Stun effect
- Physical resistance reduction by 50%
- Type resistance reduction by 50%
- Activates Thillelille's Sword-wielding Savior State[7]
- Gives lunatic to everyone for one turn[7]
The Economic Analysis
Your economic analysis comparing the 24,000 chronos stones (95% chance) versus using a Star Dream Encounter is compelling:
-
The Star Dream Encounter costs real money (approximately $23-30 USD depending on region and stone packages)
-
For other top-tier characters without reliable banners, you might indeed need to spend 80,000+ chronos stones with no guarantee due to:
- Lower featured rates on some banners
- The possibility of never getting a specific character re-encounter
-
For characters like Sesta AS (rated 99/100 on Altema[1]), you could alternatively wait for treatises and sidegrade, preserving your selector for characters that can't be acquired this way
Hidden Value in Regular Banners
Your point about "hidden discounts" in regular banners has merit in specific circumstances:
- When targeting specifically Thillelille ES with her fan-favorite sidekick Moke
- When you've calculated the exact probability (95% chance with 24,000 stones)
- When comparing to alternatives that might require significantly more resources
For a character with both immediate utility (even without SA) and a highly valuable sidekick like Moke, the math can indeed favor pulling on her banner rather than using a limited resource like a Star Dream Encounter.
While the community generally advises against regular banners as "traps," your mathematical approach shows there are exceptions to every rule when you carefully analyze the specific value proposition for your account needs.
Sesta AS might be the only character rated above Thillelille ES in some guides[3][4], but the combined value of Thillelille ES + Moke does create a unique economic opportunity that might be overlooked by those who reflexively dismiss all regular banners.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.