Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

in another eden, the new damage formula is suspected to work as follows: calculate…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-search-preview-high’s answer.
  1. User

    in another eden, the new damage formula is suspected to work as follows: calculate damage according the pre-update formula. if the damage is 2,500,000,000, use that number. if it exceeds that, reduce the excess damage by 95% and add it to 2,500,000,000. the final damage shall not exceed 9,999,999,999. each hit is subject to this cap, not total damage output per move, so characters with high hit counts can (still?) do massive damage per move. before the update, various chatbots speculated that this would make low hit attackers more viable, but it turns out the setup needed to reach 9,999,999,999 involves so much situational support that it's not optimal for astral archive use. i haven't seen any new record-breaking astral archive challenge world record videos either. am i being impatient or is this really trending toward no big meta shift for this update?

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    The new damage formula update in Another Eden, as you described, appears to implement a damage cap system per hit where:

    • Damage is first calculated using the pre-update formula.
    • If the damage is 2,500,000,000 or less, that number is used as is.
    • If the damage exceeds 2,500,000,000, the excess damage beyond this threshold is reduced by 95%, then added back to 2,500,000,000.
    • The final damage per hit cannot exceed 9,999,999,999.
    • This cap applies to each individual hit, not the total damage output of a multi-hit move, allowing characters with high hit counts to still achieve very high total damage per move.

    Before the update, speculation suggested this would make low-hit attackers more viable since their damage wouldn't be as heavily penalized by the cap. However, practical experience and community observations indicate that reaching the maximum damage cap of 9,999,999,999 per hit requires very situational and extensive support setups, which are not optimal for common uses like Astral Archive challenges. This complexity and the need for specific conditions mean that the meta has not shifted dramatically in favor of low-hit attackers or fundamentally changed the damage output landscape.

    Additionally, there have been no notable new world record-breaking videos for Astral Archive challenges since the update, suggesting that the update has not led to a significant meta shakeup or damage breakthrough in that content.

    In summary, your observation that the update is trending toward no major meta shift is accurate. The damage cap mechanics limit the effectiveness of extremely high damage per hit setups, and while multi-hit characters can still do massive damage, the overall impact on the meta and record-breaking damage outputs appears minimal so far. It is not just impatience; the current trend shows a stabilization rather than a revolution in damage potential post-update[1][2][3][5].

  3. User

    note that the old damage cap was simply to cap damage at 2**31-1.

  4. Perplexity Assistant

    Thanks for the additional context! Knowing that the old damage cap was simply the 32-bit signed integer limit (2,147,483,647, or 2^31 - 1) helps clarify the significance of the new formula.

    What This Means for the Damage Cap and Meta

    Old Cap: 2,147,483,647 (2^31 - 1)

    • Damage per hit was hard-capped at this value.
    • Any damage calculation exceeding this would be truncated or capped at this max.
    • This limited the maximum damage output per hit, regardless of how strong the attacker or buffs were.
    • Multi-hit moves could still multiply damage, but each hit was capped individually.

    New Cap and Formula:

    • Base cap raised to 2,500,000,000 (slightly above the old cap).
    • Excess damage beyond 2.5 billion is heavily reduced (only 5% effective).
    • Absolute max per hit damage is now 9,999,999,999.
    • This introduces a soft cap effect: damage can exceed the old hard cap, but with diminishing returns on excess damage.
    • Multi-hit moves can still rack up huge total damage because each hit is capped individually.

    Why This Matters for Meta and Player Expectations

    1. Softer Cap Allows More Damage, But With Diminishing Returns
      The new formula lets damage per hit go beyond the old 2.1 billion hard cap, but the 95% reduction on excess damage means pushing damage far beyond 2.5 billion is inefficient. This discourages pure stacking of damage buffs to break the cap, as the returns diminish sharply.

    2. Multi-Hit Characters Still Shine
      Since the cap applies per hit, characters with many hits can still do massive total damage, preserving their value in high-damage setups.

    3. Low-Hit Characters Less Viable for Max Damage
      The initial speculation that low-hit attackers would become more viable because their damage wouldn't be capped as harshly doesn’t fully pan out. To reach near the new max damage, they need very specific and situational support setups, which are often impractical for general content like Astral Archive.

    4. No Major Meta Shift Observed Yet
      The lack of new record-breaking videos or meta shakeups suggests the update is more of a refinement than a revolution. Players are still optimizing within similar frameworks, and the damage ceiling remains a limiting factor.


    Conclusion

    You are not being impatient — the current trend genuinely points to no big meta shift from this update. The new damage formula softens the old hard cap but introduces diminishing returns that balance out potential damage spikes. This keeps the meta stable, favors multi-hit characters for max damage, and maintains the status quo in high-level content like Astral Archive.

    If anything, this update seems designed to prevent runaway damage inflation while still allowing some room for growth, rather than to drastically change the competitive landscape.


    If you want, I can help analyze specific characters or setups under the new formula to see how they fare!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.