Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

who controls this world indirectly

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-search-preview-high’s answer.
  1. User

    who controls this world indirectly

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    The Indirect Controllers of the World

    The question of who controls the world indirectly is complex and multifaceted, involving various power structures and mechanisms that exert influence globally without direct governance. Several entities exercise different forms of indirect control through political, economic, military, and cultural means.

    Global Financial Institutions and Investors

    Some of the most powerful indirect controllers of the world are major financial institutions that manage vast amounts of global wealth:

    The "Big Three" investment firms—BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street—collectively control nearly 90% of the most powerful companies in America through their shareholdings[8]. BlackRock alone has assets under management worth approximately $11.5 trillion, equivalent to over 40% of the US GDP[8]. These financial giants exercise enormous influence through their voting rights as shareholders, effectively directing corporate decisions across virtually every major industry[8].

    These financial institutions have been accused of using their economic power to influence both companies and governments. For example, BlackRock secured unprecedented access to China's financial markets, raising questions about what concessions were made in return[8]. The company has also been criticized for investments in Chinese firms blacklisted by the US government[8].

    Governments Through Hegemony

    Historically, world domination has been achieved not only through direct military conquest but also through establishing hegemony—an indirect form of rule where the leading state exercises power over subordinate states[1]. This hegemonic control includes:

    • Implied threat of force
    • Offers of protection
    • Bestowal of economic benefits

    Many historians and political scientists argue that the United States attained global hegemony since 1945 or 1991, while others point to the British Empire's indirect control in the 19th century[1]. During the Cold War (1945-1990), both the USA and USSR exercised indirect power by:

    • Forming military alliances (NATO and Warsaw Pact)
    • Providing foreign aid to "buy" support from developing nations
    • Supporting regimes in the developing world in exchange for their loyalty[2][10]

    Multinational Corporations

    Giant corporations exercise enormous indirect control over global resources, supply chains, and policies:

    Walmart, as the world's largest employer with 2.1 million employees, doesn't just place orders but dictates to factories what to produce, how to make it, and at what cost[8]. Nestle, the world's largest food manufacturer, has been criticized for controlling water resources by pumping millions of gallons from public sources while paying minimal fees[8].

    Cargill, which controls a vast proportion of the world's main agricultural commodities, has shaped farming practices globally, driving the industry toward large-scale production of a handful of commodities like wheat, maize, and soya[8]. This transformation has disadvantaged family farms and made farming an agribusiness-dominated industry[8].

    Mechanisms of Indirect Control

    Modern indirect control operates through several interconnected mechanisms:

    Political Control

    • Dominance in international decision-making within organizations like the United Nations, G7, and World Trade Organization
    • Disproportionate influence by certain countries in global governance[2][10]

    Military Control

    • Threat of powerful armed forces with global reach
    • Selective arms trading that provides weapons to allies but not enemies[2][10]

    Economic Control

    • Trade deals and economic blocs creating interdependence between like-minded countries
    • Neo-colonial mechanisms including debt-aid relationships, where developing countries owe money to developed nations while depending on their aid[2][10]
    • Poor terms of trade forcing developing countries to export low-value commodities while importing expensive manufactured goods[10]

    Cultural Control

    • Global media, film, music, arts, and transnational brands spreading particular ideologies and values
    • The export of consumer culture promoting specific worldviews (like democracy and capitalism)[2][10]

    Plutocracy as a Form of Indirect Control

    Plutocracy—government controlled exclusively by the wealthy—represents another form of indirect control[5][12]. This doesn't require an overt government format; instead, it can emerge by allowing wealthy individuals access to certain programs and resources that give them disproportionate influence[5].

    In a plutocratic system, access to political power requires either personal wealth or the support of wealthy interests[5]. Policies enacted in such systems tend to benefit the wealthy, though they're rarely presented explicitly as such[5]. Princeton and Northwestern University researchers concluded that "economic elites and organized groups representing business interests have substantial independent impacts on U.S. government policy, while average citizens and mass-based interest groups have little or no independent influence"[5].

    The world isn't controlled by any single entity, but rather by an intricate web of financial institutions, powerful nations, multinational corporations, and wealthy individuals exercising varying degrees of indirect influence over global affairs.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.