Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.0-flash-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

What is the best way to approach a company about a website redesign? I mean the trick to…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar’s answer.
  1. User

    What is the best way to approach a company about a website redesign? I mean the trick to getting decision makers on the phone.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, getting a decision-maker on the phone for a website redesign pitch can be tricky! Here's a breakdown of strategies to improve your chances:

    1. Research and Target the Right Person

    • Who makes the decisions? Don't just call the general company number. Investigate who is most likely to be involved in website decisions. This could be:
      • Marketing Manager/Director: If the website is primarily a marketing tool.
      • Head of Digital/E-commerce Manager: If it's an e-commerce site or heavily focused on online sales.
      • CEO/Owner (Smaller Companies): In smaller companies, the top executive might be directly involved.
      • VP of Sales: If the website is critical for lead generation or sales enablement.
    • LinkedIn is your friend: Use LinkedIn to identify people by title and department. Look for people who have recently joined the company or who have mentioned website updates/challenges in their profile.
    • Company Website: Dig through the "About Us" or "Leadership" pages on the company's website.
    • Industry News/Press Releases: See if anyone is quoted about digital initiatives or website changes.

    2. Craft a Compelling Reason to Talk

    • Personalized Value Proposition: Generic pitches are a waste of time. Show that you understand their business, their target audience, and their current website's shortcomings.
    • Focus on their pain points, not your services: What problems are they facing that a website redesign could solve? Examples:
      • Low conversion rates
      • Poor user experience
      • Outdated design
      • Mobile unfriendliness
      • Lack of leads
      • Poor SEO ranking
    • Quantifiable benefits: If possible, give them an idea of the potential ROI. E.g., "We believe a redesign could increase your lead generation by X% based on [specific analysis]."
    • Do your homework: Use tools to analyze their current website:
      • SEO tools (SEMrush, Ahrefs): Identify keyword ranking issues, backlink opportunities, and technical SEO problems.
      • Website speed tests (Google PageSpeed Insights): Highlight slow loading times.
      • User experience reviews: Look for usability issues or negative customer feedback related to the website.

    3. Multiple Outreach Methods

    • Email:
      • Subject Line is Key: Make it specific and attention-grabbing. Examples:
        • "Quick Website Improvement Idea for [Company Name]"
        • "[Company Name] Website: Missed Opportunities?"
        • "[Competitor Name] is Outranking You - Here's Why"
      • Keep it concise: Decision-makers are busy. Get to the point quickly.
      • Personalize it: Mention something specific you learned about them or their company.
      • Include a call to action: "Would you be open to a quick 15-minute call to discuss this further?" or "I've put together a few initial ideas. Can I send them over?"
    • LinkedIn Messaging:
      • More informal than email: But still professional.
      • Use mutual connections: If you share connections, mention that in your message.
      • Engage with their content: Like, comment, or share their posts before reaching out. This builds familiarity.
    • Phone Calls:
      • Use as a follow-up: Don't cold call without prior research.
      • Be prepared: Have a brief, compelling script ready.
      • Ask for referrals: If the person you reach isn't the right one, ask them to point you to the decision-maker.
    • Video Message:
      • Record a personalized video: Tools like Loom allow you to quickly record a video of yourself talking directly to the prospect and even showcasing their website with suggestions. This can be a very effective way to stand out.

    4. Persistence and Timing

    • Follow up: Don't give up after one attempt. Send a follow-up email a few days later if you don't hear back.
    • Vary your approach: Try different subject lines, messaging, and outreach methods.
    • Track your results: See what's working and what's not, and adjust your strategy accordingly.
    • Best time to call/email: Research suggests Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays are the best days, and mid-morning or mid-afternoon are often the best times.

    5. What to Say (Example Phone Script)

    • (After getting through to the decision-maker): "Hi [Decision Maker Name], this is [Your Name] from [Your Company]. I'm reaching out because I've been analyzing [Company Name]'s website, and I noticed a few opportunities to improve [mention a specific issue, e.g., mobile conversion rates, lead generation, SEO ranking].
    • "For example, I saw that [specific example of the issue and its potential impact]. We've helped similar companies like [mention relevant client] increase their [positive outcome] by [quantifiable result].
    • "I have a few initial ideas on how to address this, and I was hoping to schedule a quick 15-minute call to discuss them further. Would you be available sometime next week?"

    Key Takeaways:

    • Relevance is paramount: Show you understand their business and their website's specific needs.
    • Focus on value: Explain how a redesign will benefit them, not just how great your services are.
    • Be persistent and professional.

    To help me tailor this advice further, could you tell me:

    • What industry are you targeting?
    • What specific types of website redesigns do you specialize in (e.g., e-commerce, B2B lead generation, etc.)?
    • What is the typical size of company you target?

    Based on the information I found, here's a breakdown of strategies to improve your chances of getting a decision-maker on the phone for a website redesign pitch:

    1. Identify and Target the Right Decision-Maker:

    • Research: Use LinkedIn, company websites ("About Us" or "Leadership" pages), and industry news to identify the relevant decision-maker. Possible titles include Marketing Manager/Director, Head of Digital/E-commerce Manager, CEO/Owner (for smaller companies), or VP of Sales.
    • Job Titles Can Vary: Consider that job titles can differ based on company size[1]. You might need to talk to a CEO in a startup, but a lower-level manager in a large corporation[1].
    • Ideal Customer Profile (ICP): Define your ideal customer and buyer persona. This impacts who you target and how[2][3][4]. What duties do they have? How long have they been at the company? How do they make decisions? Are they the end-users?
    • Map the Organization: For public companies, review their 10-K filing[4]. For private companies, use LinkedIn Sales Navigator[4]. Identify decision-makers, gatekeepers, and influencers[4].
    • Existing Customers/Leads: Analyze your existing customers and late-stage leads to build a picture of your typical business decision-maker[1].

    2. Craft a Personalized and Compelling Pitch:

    • Focus on THEIR Pain Points: Address their specific problems (low conversion rates, poor user experience, outdated design, mobile issues, lack of leads, poor SEO)
    • Quantifiable Benefits: Highlight potential ROI improvements (e.g., increased lead generation)[5].
    • Demonstrate Value: Showcase relevant case studies and quantify benefits with data[1][5][7].
    • Do Your Homework: Analyze their current website using SEO tools (SEMrush, Ahrefs) and website speed tests (Google PageSpeed Insights).
    • Personalized Value Proposition: Show that you understand their business, target audience, and website shortcomings.
    • Tailor Your Outreach: Adapt your approach based on your understanding of their priorities[1].
    • ROI-Focused: Emphasize the potential for a strong return on investment through conversion optimization[6]
    • Identify the Problem: Address issues like an outdated website, poor user experience, low conversion rates, or a lack of mobile responsiveness[6].
    • Offer a Solution: Present your web design services as the solution[6].
    • Highlight the Benefits: Explain what the client will gain.
    • Show, Don't Just Tell: Use "before-and-after" stories so prospects can see how you've transformed other sites[7]. Create companion case studies with statistics demonstrating results[7].

    3. Effective Outreach Methods:

    • Email:
      • Subject Line is Critical: Make it specific and attention-grabbing. Examples: "Quick Website Improvement Idea for [Company Name]", "[Company Name] Website: Missed Opportunities?", "[Competitor Name] is Outranking You - Here's Why".
      • Personalize it: Mention something specific you learned about them or their company.
      • Concise and Direct: Get to the point quickly.
      • Call to Action: "Would you be open to a quick 15-minute call...?"
    • LinkedIn Messaging:
      • Informal but Professional:
      • Leverage Connections: Mention mutual connections.
      • Engage First: Like, comment, or share their posts to build familiarity.
    • Phone Calls:
      • Follow-Up: Use calls after initial email/LinkedIn outreach.
      • Prepared Script: Have a brief, compelling script ready.
      • Ask for Referrals: If you reach the wrong person, ask for the correct contact.
    • Video Message: Record a personalized video showcasing their website and your suggestions.
    • Befriend the Gatekeeper: Build a relationship with the gatekeeper; appreciate their job and help them achieve it[4].

    4. Persistence and Timing:

    • Follow Up: Don't give up after one attempt.
    • Vary Your Approach: Try different subject lines and messaging.
    • Track Results: Analyze what works and adjust your strategy.
    • Best Days/Times: Wednesdays and Thursdays are often cited as the best days[8][9]. Late morning (10 AM - 11 AM) or late afternoon (4 PM - 5 PM) can be effective[10]. Avoid early mornings (before 9 AM/10 AM), lunch hours, and late evenings.

    5. What to Say (Example Phone Script):

    • "Hi [Decision Maker Name], this is [Your Name] from [Your Company]. I'm reaching out because I've been analyzing [Company Name]'s website, and I noticed a few opportunities to improve [mention a specific issue].
    • "For example, I saw that [specific example of the issue and its potential impact]. We've helped similar companies like [mention relevant client] increase their [positive outcome] by [quantifiable result].
    • "I have a few initial ideas on how to address this, and I was hoping to schedule a quick 15-minute call to discuss them further. Would you be available sometime next week?"

    Key Subject Line Strategies

    • Personalization: Use the prospect's name or company name.
    • Questions: Pose a relevant and thought-provoking question.
    • Value/Benefits: Offer tips or ideas related to their pain points[3][5][7].
    • Urgency: (Use sparingly and truthfully) Indicate a deal expiring soon.
    • Intrigue/Curiosity: Create a sense of mystery[11].
    • FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out): Highlight what they could be missing.

    By combining thorough research, a tailored message, and consistent, multi-channel outreach, you'll significantly increase your chances of connecting with the right decision-maker and securing that website redesign project.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt