I am studying a bettingmarket at polymarket.com and looking at a category of 4 different…
- User
I am studying a bettingmarket at polymarket.com and looking at a category of 4 different bets that I am wondering whether it is possible to make a hedge across two or more of these markets, to end up with a guaranteed profit no matter the outcome. It is polymarket, which has this fundamental functionality: It lets you buy "shares" in a specific outcome. 1 share costs the same as %chance at time of purchase, example: Donald Trump visits England before June 2025 - 45% chance: this bet would cost 45cents per share to buy "Yes". and 55cents per share to buy "No". Furthermore, this evaluation of what a share is worth will keep changing as the probability changes, so it is possible to sell the shares again later on before the event occurs or happens.
Ask if you need any more information about how the machanism of this bettingmarket works.
Anyway here is the markets I am wondering if it is possible to create a spread across to make a bet that is 100% sure to make a profit. For practical purposes we will pretend that we have 100$ to spend across these markets, and we need to have a guaranteed profit to go for a bet.
First relevant market available: #: 1 Name: "US 10Y Treasury yield above 5% by June 30?" Probability/Price per share: Yes - 24% chance. No - 76%. Expiry: 30th June.
#: 2 Name: "How high will 10-year Treasury yield go in April?" Probability/Price per share (I will only list Yes-% and the No-% is easy to calculate based on: [100% -Yes%]) Multiple options: Option 1: 4.5% - Yes: 82% Option 2: 4.6% - Yes:71% Option 3: 4.8% - Yes: 44% Option 4: 5% - Yes: 9% Option 5: 5.2% - Yes: 4% Option 6: 5.5% - Yes: 2% Expiry: 30th April 2025
#: 3 Name: "How low will 10-year Treasury yield get in 2025?" Probability/Price per share (I will only list Yes-% and the No-% is easy to calculate based on: [100% -Yes%]) Multiple options: Option 1: 4% - Yes 90% Option 2: 3.5% - Yes 36% Option 3: 3% - Yes 24% Option 4: 2% - Yes 10% Expiry: 31st December 2025
#: 4 Name: "How high will 10-year Treasury yield go in 2025?" Probability/Price per share (I will only list Yes-% and the No-% is easy to calculate based on: [100% -Yes%]) Multiple options: Option 1: 4.5% - Yes 93% Option 2: 4.6% - Yes 72% Option 3: 4.8% - Yes 51% Option 4: 5% - Yes 44% Option 5: 5.2% - Yes 34% Option 6: 5.5% - Yes 23% Expiry: 31st December 2025
#: 5 Name: "10-year Treasury yield >4.5% next Friday?" Probability/Price per share: Yes: 57% - No: 43%
Please make sure you understand the question at hand and make sure you ask anything you need if something is not clear. If it is clearly possible or not possible, then please share proof of that.
Assistant
To determine if a guaranteed profit is possible through hedging across these Polymarket bets, I need to analyze the relationships between these markets and identify any pricing inefficiencies that could create arbitrage opportunities.
Understanding Polymarket Mechanics
Polymarket operates as a prediction marketplace where:
- You purchase "shares" in an outcome at a price equal to the market's current probability estimate[8]
- Winning shares pay out $1 each regardless of purchase price[8]
- You can sell shares before the event occurs if probability/price changes[8]
- The goal in arbitrage is to find combinations where total cost is less than guaranteed payout[2][4]
Analysis of Potential Arbitrage Opportunities
Let's examine the most promising combinations between these markets:
Market #1 vs Market #4
- Market #1: "US 10Y Treasury yield above 5% by June 30?" (Yes: 24%, No: 76%)
- Market #4, Option 4: "How high will 10-year Treasury yield go in 2025?" - 5% (Yes: 44%)
There's a 20 percentage point difference between these markets. Since June 30 falls within 2025, this could suggest an inconsistency. However, Market #1 asks if the yield will be above 5% on June 30, while Market #4 asks if it will reach 5% at any point during 2025. These are fundamentally different questions, so no clear arbitrage exists.
Market #2 vs Market #4
- Market #2, Option 4: "How high will 10-year Treasury yield go in April?" - 5% (Yes: 9%)
- Market #4, Option 4: "How high will 10-year Treasury yield go in 2025?" - 5% (Yes: 44%)
The difference (9% vs 44%) is logical since April is just one month of 2025, making arbitrage unlikely.
Trying a Sample Hedge Strategy
Let's try a specific strategy across Market #1 and Market #4:
- Bet $24 on "Yes" in Market #1 (24% chance yield will be above 5% on June 30)
- Bet $56 on "No" in Market #4, Option 4 (56% chance yield won't reach 5% in 2025)
Total investment: $80
Possible outcomes:
- Yield reaches above 5% on June 30: Win 100 on Market #1, lose 56 on Market #4. Net profit: $20
- Yield never reaches 5% in 2025: Lose 24 on Market #1, win 100 on Market #4. Net profit: $20
- Yield reaches 5% sometime in 2025 but isn't above 5% on June 30: Lose both bets. Net loss: $80
This strategy isn't guaranteed profit because of scenario 3.
Exploring Market #2 Internal Arbitrage
Let's check if there's an arbitrage opportunity within Market #2:
- Option 1: 4.5% - Yes: 82% (No: 18%)
- Option 2: 4.6% - Yes: 71% (No: 29%)
- Option 3: 4.8% - Yes: 44% (No: 56%)
- Option 4: 5% - Yes: 9% (No: 91%)
- Option 5: 5.2% - Yes: 4% (No: 96%)
- Option 6: 5.5% - Yes: 2% (No: 98%)
If the market is asking "will it reach at least this value," we could try:
- Bet $2 on "Yes" for 5.5%
- Bet $96 on "No" for 5.2%
Total investment: $98
Outcomes:
- If yield reaches 5.5
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.