explain why yann le cunn says llms are on their way out. give specific quotes
- User
explain why yann le cunn says llms are on their way out. give specific quotes
Assistant
Yann LeCun, Meta's Chief AI Scientist and a Turing Award laureate, believes that Large Language Models (LLMs) will become obsolete within the next few years. As one of the pioneers of deep learning and a key figure in AI development, his perspective challenges the prevailing enthusiasm about LLMs. Here's why he believes LLMs are on their way out:
Fundamental Limitations of LLMs
LeCun is explicit about the timeline for LLM obsolescence, stating that he "anticipates that LLMs could become largely obsolete within five years"[1]. This belief stems from his assessment that current language models lack true understanding and reasoning abilities:
"An LLM generates one token at a time, processing a fixed amount of computation to produce each token. This is clearly a reactive process—there's no reasoning involved."[1]
He makes a clear distinction between how humans think and how LLMs operate:
"Once we abandon old assumptions about the connection between thought and language, it is clear that these systems are doomed to a shallow understanding that will never approximate the full-bodied thinking we see in humans."[5]
LeCun emphasizes that while LLMs may appear intelligent, they represent a fundamentally limited approach:
"LLMs are destined for obsolescence within a few years due to their failure to accurately represent the continuous high-dimensional spaces that define much of our reality."[3]
Inability to Model the World Beyond Language
A central critique from LeCun is that LLMs only model language patterns rather than understanding the underlying reality those words represent:
"The goal is for AI systems to focus on the world being talked about, not the words themselves — but LLMs don't grasp the distinction."[5]
He points out a fundamental limitation in their design:
"This clearly indicates that we will never achieve human-level intelligence by solely training on text. It's simply not going to happen."[1]
LeCun highlights how the lack of world modeling restricts what LLMs can accomplish:
"Current AI systems have a very hard time solving new problems that they've never faced before. Right? So they don't have this mental model, this world model I was telling you about earlier, that allows them to kind of imagine what the consequence of their actions or whatever."[6]
Superficial "Reasoning" Through Hacks
LeCun is particularly critical of how LLMs create an illusion of reasoning through statistical text prediction:
"you ask it to go through the steps of reasoning. And as a consequence, it produces more tokens and then spends more computation answering that question. But it's a horrible trick. It's a hack. It's not the way humans reason."[6]
He offers evidence of their limitations with novel problems:
"if you test all the best LLMs on the latest math Olympiad, they basically get zero performance, because there are new problems they have not been trained to solve."[6]
"critics are right to accuse these systems of being engaged in a kind of mimicry. This is because LLMs' understanding of language, while impressive, is shallow."[5]
What Will Replace LLMs
LeCun envisions a new paradigm that will supersede current approaches:
"If we can achieve our goals within three to five years, we will establish a vastly improved framework for systems capable of reasoning and planning."[1]
He urges young developers to "Focus on next-generation AI systems that transcend the limitations of LLMs"[1], suggesting they pursue alternatives rather than following the LLM trend.
LeCun is actively working on alternatives that better model the physical world:
"LLMs may become obsolete within five years, supplanted by new models like the JEPA-based systems he is creating, which possess an understanding of the physical world and exhibit System 2 capabilities."[3]
He outlines what the next generation of AI should achieve:
"We need machines that understand the physical world. We need machines that are capable of reasoning and planning. We need machines that have persistent memory."[6]
Limited Future Role for LLMs
Despite his belief in their eventual obsolescence, LeCun acknowledges that LLMs won't disappear entirely:
"There's a minor function for LLMs, primarily in translating abstract thoughts into language."[1]
He compares this to how language processing works in the human brain:
"In the human brain, this task is managed by Broca's area, located here," he said, gesturing to a small region near his left temple. "This area only emerged in the last couple of hundred thousand years. If you lose the function of Broca's area, you can still think; you just can't articulate your thoughts."[1]
LeCun's critique doesn't suggest LLMs are useless but rather that they represent a limited approach to AI that will be surpassed by systems with deeper understanding and reasoning capabilities.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.