Skip to content
The Chat Archive
sonar-reasoning-pro-high LMArena Search Arena 24K

What is the name of the resolution enacted by Crow Tribal Council in 1973?

  1. User

    What is the name of the resolution enacted by Crow Tribal Council in 1973?

  2. Assistant

    The resolution enacted by the Crow Tribal Council in 1973 was Resolution 74-05, also referred to as "Resolution Tribal Edict No. 74-05"[1][3]. This resolution was passed in October 1973 and prohibited hunting and fishing within the boundaries of the Crow Indian Reservation by anyone who was not a member of the Crow Tribe[1][3].

    The resolution stated in part: "Be it ordained by the Crow Tribe, meeting in a duly held and noticed council that hunting, fishing and trespassing within the exterior boundaries of the Crow Indian Reservation is hereby prohibited and the proper officials of the United States and the Crow Tribe of Indians are hereby directed and authorized to enforce the provisions of this ordinance and any federal statute which would prohibit such hunting and fishing and trespassing, provided, however, that the provisions of this ordinance shall not apply to the members of the Crow Tribe of Indians"[1].

    This resolution was enacted in response to increasing food prices and tribal enrollment, coupled with decreasing supplies of fish and game on the reservation[3]. The resolution later became central to the legal dispute in United States v. Montana, which eventually reached the Supreme Court as Montana v. United States, regarding tribal authority to regulate hunting and fishing by non-members within reservation boundaries[1][3].

  3. User

    name of the man who defied it

  4. Assistant

    According to the search results, the man who defied the Crow Tribal Council's Resolution 74-05 was James Junior Finch. In May 1974, Finch, who was not a member of the Crow Tribe, deliberately went fishing in open defiance of the tribal resolution that prohibited hunting and fishing within the reservation boundaries by non-tribal members[2].

    This act of defiance led to charges being filed against Finch in district court[2]. His case became significant in the legal dispute between the Crow Tribe and the State of Montana regarding regulatory authority over hunting and fishing on reservation lands. The case eventually evolved into United States v. Montana in the lower courts, and ultimately reached the Supreme Court as Montana v. United States[2].

    Finch's deliberate challenge to tribal authority triggered a series of judicial decisions that culminated in the landmark 1981 Supreme Court ruling that established important precedents regarding tribal sovereignty and regulatory authority over non-members on reservation lands[2][10].

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.