Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

why heroic launcher requests access to desktop downloads and documents folders?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high’s answer.
  1. User

    why heroic launcher requests access to desktop downloads and documents folders?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Heroic Games Launcher may request access to your Desktop, Downloads, and Documents folders for several reasons, primarily related to installing, managing, and locating game files:

    1. Game Installation Location: Users often choose to install games or store game-related files in common locations like Documents, Downloads, or even directly on the Desktop. Heroic needs permission to write files to these locations if you select them as installation paths.
    2. Importing Existing Games: If you already have games from Epic Games Store or GOG installed (perhaps previously installed via their native launchers), they might reside in these folders. Heroic needs access to scan these directories to find and import already installed games into its library.
    3. Downloading Files: Heroic needs to download game installers, updates, Wine/Proton versions, and other dependencies (like DXVK, VKD3D). The Downloads folder is a common default location for such files, and Heroic might need access to manage these downloads or allow you to select files from there (e.g., manually adding a game installer).
    4. Adding Non-Store Games/Executables: Heroic allows adding games or applications that are not from Epic or GOG. Users might have installers or executables for these located in Downloads or on the Desktop, requiring Heroic to have access to browse and select these files.
    5. Wine/Proton Prefixes and Save Games: While often stored within Heroic's own designated folders or the game installation directory itself, some configurations or older setups might place Wine prefixes (containing necessary compatibility files and potentially save data for Windows games run via Wine/Proton) or save game files within the Documents folder. Access might be requested to manage or locate these. For example, finding save files might involve looking in paths like /home/deck/Games/Heroic/Prefixes/[GameName]/drive_c/Users/[User]/AppData/Roaming/[GameName] on Steam Deck, which mirrors a structure often found within user profile folders like Documents on Windows. Some launchers assume a standard Documents folder exists for storing user-specific game data.
    6. Platform Permissions (Especially Linux/macOS):
      • Linux (Flatpak/Snap): If you install Heroic via methods like Flatpak or Snap, it runs in a sandbox with restricted file access by default. It needs explicit permission to access folders outside its sandbox. Requesting access to Downloads, Documents, etc., allows users to select install locations or import games from these common directories. Tools like Flatseal can manage these permissions for Flatpak applications.[1][2] Without these permissions, Heroic might be limited to installing games only within its specific data directory (e.g., /home/user/Games/Heroic/).
      • macOS: macOS has increasingly strict privacy controls. Applications often need explicit permission to access broad user folders like Desktop, Documents, and Downloads. Heroic requests this to ensure it can function if the user chooses to use these folders for game installs, imports, or related files.
      • AppImage (Linux): While generally less confined than Flatpak/Snap, AppImages might still interact with system permissions, although usually, they run with the user's standard permissions.

    In summary, Heroic requests access to these folders to provide flexibility for users to install games where they prefer, import existing installations, manage downloaded files, and ensure compatibility across different operating systems and installation methods (like sandboxed Flatpaks). You can often restrict these permissions if you plan to only use specific directories (e.g., a dedicated games folder on another drive), but doing so might limit functionality if you later try to interact with files in the restricted folders.

  3. User

    with heroic trying to play launcher rocket league on Mac, in logged in epic games, downloaded and after it saying installing some packages I play play and for a few seconds it says playing but then stops. no other indication that it is running, it doesn't even start. how to fix?

  4. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, this is a common issue when trying to run Windows games on macOS via compatibility layers like Wine/Proton, which Heroic uses. Rocket League no longer has a native macOS client (Epic removed it), so you must run the Windows version through a compatibility layer. The brief "Playing" followed by stopping usually indicates a problem with launching the game via that layer.

    Here's a breakdown of steps to troubleshoot and fix this:

    1. Check Heroic Logs: This is the most crucial step for silent failures.

      • Try launching Rocket League again.
      • Immediately after it fails, go to Heroic's settings (often a gear icon or in a menu).
      • Look for an option like "Show Logs" or "View Logs".
      • Open the log file and look for any errors, especially near the end of the log, related to Rocket League, Wine, Proton, or Crossover. Errors like "wine crash," "prefix creation failed," "permission denied," or missing dependencies can point you to the solution.
    2. Install/Select a Wine/Proton Version: Heroic needs a compatibility layer (like Wine, Proton-GE, or Crossover) to run Windows games.

      • Go to the "Wine Manager" section in Heroic (usually under Settings or a Tools menu).
      • Install a recent version of Wine-GE or Proton-GE. These community-built versions often have better compatibility than standard Wine. Start with the latest recommended GE version.
      • Go back to your Library, find Rocket League, and click the Settings icon for the game (often a gear or wrench).
      • Under the "Wine" or "Compatibility" section, explicitly select the Wine-GE or Proton-GE version you just downloaded from the dropdown menu. Don't leave it on "System Wine" unless you've specifically configured that elsewhere.
      • If you own Crossover (paid software, but excellent Wine implementation for Mac), make sure it's installed and selected in Heroic's main settings and potentially in the game's specific settings.
    3. Try Different Wine/Proton Versions: Sometimes specific game versions work better with specific Wine/Proton versions.

      • If the first version didn't work, go back to the Wine Manager and download another recent version (maybe slightly older) of Wine-GE or Proton-GE.
      • Select the new version in Rocket League's settings and try launching again.
    4. Verify/Repair Game Files: Corrupted files during download can cause launch failures.

      • In Heroic, find Rocket League in your library.
      • Click the settings icon for the game or look for options (sometimes hidden behind a three-dot menu).
      • Find and run the "Verify / Repair" option. This will check the game files against the server and re-download anything missing or corrupted.
    5. Check Wine Prefix: Each game usually runs in its own "Wine Prefix" (a simulated Windows C: drive environment).

      • In Rocket League's settings within Heroic, check the Wine Prefix path.
      • You could try forcing a rebuild: Rename or delete the existing prefix folder (make sure to note the path first!). Heroic should try to create a new, clean one the next time you launch. Be aware this will delete any game saves stored within that prefix if you haven't configured cloud saves properly.
      • Sometimes, essential components fail to install during prefix creation. You might need to use "Winetricks" (often accessible via the game's settings in Heroic) to manually install components like vcrun (various versions like 2015, 2017, 2019, 2022) or corefonts, though Heroic/Wine-GE often handle this automatically. The logs (Step 1) might indicate if specific components are missing.
    6. Check macOS Permissions: Ensure Heroic (and potentially the Wine processes it spawns) have necessary permissions.

      • Go to macOS System Settings > Privacy & Security.
      • Check sections like "Files and Folders" and potentially "Full Disk Access". Make sure Heroic has access to the location where Rocket League is installed, and potentially your Documents or Downloads folders if it needs to write temporary files or access configurations there.
    7. Apple Silicon (M1/M2/M3 Macs): If you have an Apple Silicon Mac, ensure Rosetta 2 is installed. Wine/Proton typically run x86_64 Windows code, which needs Rosetta translation on ARM-based Macs.

      • Open Terminal (Applications > Utilities > Terminal).
      • Run the command: softwareupdate --install-rosetta
      • Press Enter and agree to the license terms if prompted.
    8. Dependencies (Less Common, but possible): Wine itself might rely on certain system libraries. Ensure your macOS is reasonably up-to-date. If you installed Wine via Homebrew outside of Heroic, ensure it's correctly configured. However, using the Wine versions managed within Heroic is generally recommended.

    Start with steps 1, 2, and 4 as they are the most common solutions. Checking logs is key to understanding why it's failing silently.

  5. User

    ok I enabled auto install of dxvd and it runs and plays. but why is my resolution limited and not having the actual display abilities as options?

  6. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, that's progress! Getting the game to run is the first hurdle. The limited resolution options issue is also quite common when running games through compatibility layers like Wine/Proton (especially on macOS, which uses MoltenVK to translate Vulkan to Metal).

    Here's why this happens and how to fix it:

    Why it Happens:

    1. Wine/Proton Doesn't Perfectly Detect macOS Display Capabilities: The core issue is that Wine (the compatibility layer Heroic uses) has to interpret the display information provided by macOS and present it to the Windows game (Rocket League). This interpretation isn't always perfect. Wine might fail to detect all the resolutions your monitor supports or might misinterpret the native resolution, especially with Retina displays or unusual aspect ratios.
    2. DXVK/MoltenVK Layer: DXVK translates DirectX calls to Vulkan. On macOS, Vulkan calls are then translated to Apple's Metal graphics API via a layer called MoltenVK. Sometimes, limitations or bugs in any part of this chain (Wine -> DXVK -> MoltenVK -> Metal driver -> macOS Display Manager) can prevent the game from seeing the full range of resolutions.
    3. Game Configuration File: The game might have defaulted to a lower resolution during the initial (failed) startup attempts or when the prefix was created. It might have saved this low resolution in its configuration file and isn't properly re-detecting the available options now that it's running.
    4. Fullscreen vs. Windowed Mode: Sometimes, the game can detect resolutions correctly in one display mode (e.g., Borderless Windowed) but not another (e.g., Exclusive Fullscreen). Exclusive Fullscreen often has more issues with compatibility layers.
    5. macOS Display Scaling: If you're using macOS display scaling ("Looks like..." settings in System Settings > Displays), Wine might be detecting the "scaled" resolution rather than the panel's native hardware resolution.

    How to Fix It:

    1. Check In-Game Settings First:

      • Go into Rocket League's video/graphics settings.
      • Ensure the Aspect Ratio is set correctly (e.g., 16:9, 16:10 depending on your Mac's screen).
      • Try switching between Fullscreen, Borderless Windowed, and Windowed modes. Sometimes changing the mode forces a re-detection of available resolutions. Borderless Windowed often works best.
      • Look carefully through the list – sometimes the native resolution is there but not selected by default.
    2. Edit the Game's Configuration File (Most Likely Fix):

      • You need to find Rocket League's configuration file within its Wine prefix.
      • Find the Prefix: In Heroic, go to Rocket League's settings. Note the "Wine Prefix" path. It will be something like /Users/YourUsername/Games/Heroic/Prefixes/Rocket League/.
      • Navigate to the Config: Open Finder, use the "Go" menu -> "Go to Folder..." and paste the prefix path. Navigate inside the prefix, usually following a path similar to a Windows structure: drive_c/Users/YourUsername/Documents/My Games/Rocket League/TAGame/Config/. (Note: The exact path under drive_c might vary slightly depending on the Wine setup).
      • Find the File: Look for a file named TASystemSettings.ini.
      • Backup: Make a copy of this file before editing!
      • Edit: Open TASystemSettings.ini with a text editor (like TextEdit). Find the following lines (or similar):
        ResX=...
        ResY=...
        
      • Set Your Resolution: Manually change the ResX (width) and ResY (height) values to your Mac display's native resolution (e.g., ResX=2560, ResY=1600 for many MacBook Pros).
      • Save: Save the file.
      • Launch: Relaunch Rocket League through Heroic. It should now use the resolution you set. You might still need to check the in-game settings to ensure it's listed or selected correctly, but often this forces it.
    3. Use winecfg (Less Direct for Games):

      • In Heroic, go to Rocket League's settings.
      • Find an option like "Run winecfg" or similar to open the Wine configuration tool for that game's prefix.
      • Go to the "Graphics" tab.
      • You can try adjusting the "Screen resolution" slider here, although this affects the virtual desktop Wine thinks it has, which doesn't always translate directly to the game's available resolutions.
      • Ticking "Emulate a virtual desktop" and setting the resolution there might sometimes help, but it usually forces the game into a window of that size. It's generally better to edit the game's config file.
    4. Check macOS Display Settings:

      • Go to System Settings > Displays.
      • If you are using "Scaled" resolutions, try setting it to "Default for display" temporarily and see if that changes what Rocket League detects (though this might make your desktop icons/text too small or large). This helps diagnose if scaling is interfering.
    5. Update Wine/Proton Version:

      • Ensure you are using a recent version of Wine-GE or Proton-GE via Heroic's Wine Manager. Newer versions often include fixes for display detection.

    Start with checking in-game settings and then editing the TASystemSettings.ini file, as that's the most common and direct way to fix resolution issues with Rocket League under Wine/Proton.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.