can you browse the internet for a 5 year old references from 2025 so that I could change…
- User
can you browse the internet for a 5 year old references from 2025 so that I could change the outdated linkages here, it should be real and accesible it should also be related to political science and also aligns well : Table 7 Averages of Self-Assessed Skills (Competency Assessment)
COMPETENCY AREA MEAN I COMPETENCY AREA MEAN I
Effectively Communicating Ideas 3.91 M Regular Engagement 3.86 M Actively Listening 4.11 H Collaborating with LGUs 3.7 L Facilitating Discussions 3.93 M Designing Advocacy Campaigns 3.84 M Building Rapport 4.23 H Attending Conferences 3.75 L Facilitating Youth Consultations 3.91 M Scheduling Meetings 3.77 L Applying Laws 3.86 M Considering Community Needs 4.27 H Managing Budgets 3.84 M Prioritize Resource Allocation 4.27 H Utilizing Technology 4.07 H Transparent Allocation Process 3.89 M Developing Project Plans 4 H Regular Reviews 4 H Monitoring Project Progress 4.09 H Considering Financial Risks 3.91 M Maintaining Transparency 4.09 H Setting Clear Goals 4.29 H Seeking Input from Community 4.11 H Organized Project Activities 3.93 M Reporting Wrongdoing 4 H Monitoring Progress 3.93 M Ensuring Fairness 4.07 H Clear Communication During Implementation 4.07 H Conducting Regular Evaluations 3.82 M Empower Youth 4.18 H
NOTE : Legend: L: Low Self-Assessment (Average below 3.8) M: Moderate Self-Assessment (Average between 3.8 - 4.0) H: High Self-Assessment (Average above 4.0), Average are computed using this formula : Average = [(1 * Scale 1 Count) + (2 * Scale 2 Count) + (3 * Scale 3 Count) + (4 * Scale 4 Count) + (5 * Scale 5 Count)] / Total Responses. See Appendix E for the full Competency Assessment Table.
Table 7 presents the self-assessed average ratings of SK officials in San Fernando, Camarines Sur across various competency areas. Competency levels were categorized as High (H), Moderate (M), and Low (L) using a 5-point Likert scale. Notably, officials rated themselves highest in areas related to ethics, community engagement, and communication—such as Setting Clear Goals (4.29), Considering Community Needs (4.27), Prioritizing Resource Allocation (4.27), Building Rapport (4.23), and Empowering Youth (4.18). In contrast, lower scores were observed in more technical or administrative tasks like Collaborating with LGUs (3.70), Attending Conferences (3.75), and Scheduling Meetings (3.77). The self-assessed competency data reveals a complex pattern of perceived abilities that appears to align with the SK officials’ prior experiences. SK leaders demonstrated higher confidence in areas tied to interpersonal ethics and community engagement—Building Rapport (4.23), Facilitating Youth Consultations (4.02), Considering Community Needs (4.27), Prioritizing Resource Allocation (4.27), Maintaining Transparency (4.09), Ensuring Fairness (4.07), and Empowering Youth (4.18)—as well as skills in communication like Actively Listening (4.11), Clear Communication During Implementation (4.07), and Setting Clear Goals (4.29). This may be attributed to their prior involvement in school-based or community organizations where such competencies are commonly developed. The relatively high rating in Utilizing Technology (4.07) also reflects their familiarity with digital tools, likely due to their youth and educational background. On the other hand, competencies with moderate to low self-assessments—such as Collaborating with LGUs (3.70), Attending Conferences (3.75), Scheduling Meetings (3.77), Conducting Regular Evaluations (3.82), and Managing Budgets (3.84)—point to perceived weaknesses in technical and administrative aspects of governance. These ratings may stem from limited exposure to formal processes, minimal institutional support, or insufficient training, as only four respondents had undergone the SK Mandatory Training and the majority (65.91%) had less than one year of experience. The data suggests that SK officials in San Fernando are entering their roles with strong ethical foundations and social leadership skills, but with limited preparedness for administrative and technical responsibilities. The 0.57-point gap between the highest and lowest competency scores implies that the gap is not insurmountable but still significant enough to merit targeted intervention. The results reflect a learning curve among newly appointed SK leaders, particularly in navigating government systems, managing resources, and engaging with formal institutions. These competency disparities are not necessarily due to a lack of potential, but more so due to inadequate exposure, formal training, and role clarity. Their strong self-assessed communication and community engagement skills can serve as valuable social capital, enhancing participatory governance. However, their lack of confidence in administrative functions may hinder the successful implementation of youth-oriented programs unless proper support systems and training are put in place. These findings resonate with several key leadership and development theories. Seemiller (2018) emphasized the importance of youth leadership programs in cultivating civic responsibility and leadership capacity, which aligns with the SK officials’ strong ethical and engagement-related competencies. Kouzes and Posner (2017) further reinforce the relevance of building rapport and community collaboration in leadership, traits clearly reflected in the officials’ self-assessments. The technical competency gaps support Moldoveanu’s (2021) theory on the value of action-based learning, suggesting the need for real-world application to develop governance capacity. Similarly, Bandura’s (1977) Social Cognitive Theory highlights the role of observational learning and mentorship—emphasizing the potential of SK officials to grow by learning from more experienced leaders. Additionally, Smith (2020) noted the developmental impact of teamwork-oriented activities such as sports and publications—areas less represented in the SK officials’ experience, potentially limiting their collaborative skills. Finally, Fukuyama (2011) argued that robust governance requires both ethical leadership and technical proficiency, highlighting the dual development track needed for effective youth leadership in government. Based on the findings, it is recommended that a structured and competency-based training program be implemented for SK officials in San Fernando, focusing on developing practical skills in legal procedures, financial management, project planning, and LGU collaboration. These training sessions should be designed to include real-life applications and experiential learning methods to bridge the technical skill gaps effectively. In addition, establishing mentorship programs that connect SK officials with experienced barangay and municipal leaders can provide valuable guidance and modeling through observational learning. Comprehensive onboarding sessions should also be introduced to orient officials about their roles, responsibilities, and the resources available to them. Given their strong ethical foundation and communication skills, integrating civic education with hands-on community projects can enhance their leadership capacity while reinforcing civic engagement. Lastly, fostering a culture of collaboration through youth summits, leadership workshops, and team-building initiatives can help strengthen their interpersonal and organizational competencies, ultimately enabling them to function more effectively within the local governance system.
Assistant
Okay, I can help you find potential recent references (from approximately 2020-2025) related to political science and leadership development that could align with the points made in your text about SK officials' competencies.
Finding exact replacements that perfectly mirror the original author's specific argument and context can be challenging, but I will look for relevant recent works that address the core themes. I will use the Google Search tool to find potential academic articles, books, or reputable reports.
Based on the search results and the points in your original text, here are some potential recent references (2020-2025) related to political science, leadership, and governance that might be suitable replacements or additions. I've tried to align them with the themes supported by your original citations:
1. For Seemiller (2018) - Importance of youth leadership programs for civic responsibility and capacity:
- Potential Replacement/Addition:
- IFES (2025): Understanding Young People’s Political and Civic Engagement as a Counter to Democratic Backsliding. This report discusses how civic education and opportunities for youth to lead activities directly encourage participation and build skills needed for democratic resilience[1][2][3]. (Results [19], [32])
- Stoneman (2002) (cited in recent works, e.g., [33]): Although older, the concept that youth civic engagement overcomes marginalization and contributes to societal change, often cited in recent literature, reinforces Seemiller's point about developing civic responsibility through programs.
- Ballard et al. (2021) (cited in [26]): Mentions research showing that youth involved in community engagement demonstrate greater civic responsibility.
- Racine County Youth In Governance Program (Ongoing, described in [34]): Explicitly states its goal is to develop youth leadership, build civic capacity, and create motivated leaders through direct participation in local government[3]. This serves as a practical example aligning with Seemiller's theoretical point.
2. For Kouzes & Posner (2017) - Relevance of building rapport and community collaboration:
- Potential Replacement/Addition:
- Lising & Rivera (2024): Sangguniang Kabataan competencies in Quezon Province: A basis for capacity development program. This study specifically mentions assessing SK officials' leadership competencies, including "fostering collaboration" and "building alliances," finding these areas advanced but still needing development. (Results [3], [10])
- IFES (2025): Mentions building communal trust and social cohesion as ways engaged youth can support democracy, highlighting the importance of community connection. (Results [19], [32])
- Bayeck (2020) (cited in [11]): Notes that non-digital games (like board games simulating elections) emphasize face-to-face communication, negotiation, and collaboration – skills crucial for civic participation[4].
- Lising et al. (2025): Assessing innovative and responsive young leaders in public service: Lens from community clientele. This study notes community perceptions that young leaders work collaboratively with the community and are accessible/approachable[5]. (Result [35])
3. For Moldoveanu (2021) - Value of action-based learning for developing governance capacity:
- Potential Replacement/Addition:
- Action Learning Congress 2025 (Event Announcement [22]): Focuses on "Developing Collective Purpose: Developing capacity for sustainable development" using action learning, explicitly linking the methodology to capacity building, particularly in community and organizational settings relevant to governance.
- OECD (Ongoing Project 2023-2025, [9]): Works on Administrative Capacity Building for Cohesion Policy Beneficiaries, implying practical application and learning by doing to strengthen capabilities in managing public funds and development[6].
- European Commission (ComPAct initiative, [20]): Aims to enhance administrative capacity through practical measures like peer exchange ("learning by doing") and training programs, supporting the idea of action-based capacity development in public administration.
- IFES (2025): Recommends giving young people opportunities to apply what they learn in trainings to their own lives and communities through youth-led activities, suggesting practical application enhances engagement and skills[1]. (Results [19], [32])
4. For Bandura (1977) - Role of observational learning and mentorship:
- Potential Replacement/Addition:
- Legislative Mentorship Initiative (LMI) (Ongoing, [12]): Explicitly aims to groom future public sector leaders through mentorship, equipping them with skills and expertise by learning from experienced figures.
- SAME Leader Development Program (Ongoing, [8]): Requires participants to select a mentor to guide their professional development throughout the year-long program focused on leadership skills[7].
- Kayton (2025): The Future of Mentorship: What I'm Seeing in 2025. Discusses trends like reverse mentoring and community-led mentorship, highlighting the evolving but enduring importance of mentorship for skill development and navigating professional environments (including soft skills)[8]. (Result [21])
- Public Service Fale (NZ programme for Pacific, [18]): Includes a specific "Fale Mentoring programme" as part of its offerings to build capability in Pacific public services[9].
5. For Smith (2020) - Developmental impact of teamwork-oriented activities:
- Potential Replacement/Addition:
- Lising & Rivera (2024): Found leadership competencies like "fostering collaboration" were relatively advanced among SK officials in Quezon, suggesting these skills are recognized and somewhat present, aligning with the need for teamwork. (Results [3], [10])
- Bayeck (2020) (cited in [11]): Mentions board games promoting collaboration skills critical for civic participation[4]. (Result [11])
- Power of Dialogue Consortium (Report, [28]): Emphasizes building partnerships and network-building (which requires collaboration) as essential for impactful youth political participation[10].
6. For Fukuyama (2011) - Need for both ethical leadership and technical proficiency:
- Potential Replacement/Addition:
- Jarbandhan (2021): Ethical Public Sector Leadership and Good Governance: Implications for the Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR)[11]. Argues that navigating complex modern challenges (like 4IR) requires ethically adept public leaders with sound knowledge (technical/domain understanding) to promote good governance[11]. (Result [23])
- Muchunguzi (n.d., likely recent): Ethical Leadership and Effective Management of Public Resources. Explores the nexus between ethical leadership and the effective management (implying technical skill) of public resources, arguing both are needed for development. (Result [24])
- Constançon (via Genius Boards, 2024): Emphasizes the blend of ethical leadership and strategic governance (implying technical/managerial competence) as defining successful, resilient organizations. (Result [29])
- National Youth Commission (Philippines, 2021, cited in [1]): Crafted an SK competency framework including core, technical, and leadership competencies, acknowledging the need for different skill sets for effective functioning.
- Lising & Rivera (2024): Assessed SK officials on core, technical, and leadership competencies, finding strengths and weaknesses across these different domains, mirroring the need for both ethical/interpersonal skills (often in core/leadership) and technical proficiency. (Results [3], [10])
Important Considerations:
- Accessibility: Many of these references are from academic journals (ResearchGate, Taylor & Francis, Sabinet), reports (IFES, OECD, UN), or organizational websites. Full access might require institutional subscriptions or library resources, but abstracts are often available.
- Direct SK Relevance: Several search results ([1], [2], [3], [10], [14], [35]) specifically discuss SK competencies in the Philippines and are very recent (often 2024). These could be highly valuable for contextualizing your findings within current Philippine research.
- Verification: Please review these suggestions and their original sources (or at least abstracts) to ensure they accurately reflect the point you want to support and fit the context of your paper.
This list provides potential starting points for updating your references with relevant, recent sources from the 2020-2025 timeframe that align with political science and leadership themes. Remember to cite appropriately based on the style guide you are using.
- Potential Replacement/Addition:
- User
okay, rewrite it then and also at the end use APA 7th foirmat to references
Assistant
Okay, here is the rewritten concluding paragraph incorporating more recent references (approx. 2020-2025) that align with the original themes, followed by the APA 7th edition reference list for those new citations.
Rewritten Paragraph:
These findings resonate with several key leadership and development theories and contemporary research. For instance, the emphasis on developing civic skills and democratic support through youth leadership activities (International Foundation for Electoral Systems [IFES], 2025) aligns with the SK officials’ strong self-assessed ethical and community engagement competencies. The importance of fostering collaboration and building alliances, identified as crucial leadership competencies for SK officials in recent studies (Lising & Rivera, 2024), reinforces the relevance of the rapport-building skills the officials reported. The technical competency gaps observed support the value of practical, action-based learning methods, highlighted as critical for building capacity in organizational and community development contexts (Action Learning Congress, 2025), suggesting the need for real-world application to develop governance proficiency. Similarly, the potential benefits of mentorship are underscored by initiatives focused on grooming future public sector leaders through guidance from experienced figures (Legislative Mentorship Initiative [LMI], n.d.). Furthermore, the necessity of building partnerships and networks for impactful youth political participation (Power of Dialogue Consortium, n.d.) points towards areas needing development, given the officials' lower self-assessment in formal collaboration. Finally, the argument that effective governance in the modern era demands both ethically adept leaders and a sound technical knowledge base (Jarbandhan, 2021) highlights the dual development track needed to enhance the overall effectiveness of these young leaders in government.
References (APA 7th Edition Format):
Action Learning Congress. (2025). Action Learning Congress 2025: Developing collective purpose: Developing capacity for sustainable development. [Conference announcement]. WIAL & Action Learning Action Research Association Ltd. https://www.wial.org/alc-2025/
International Foundation for Electoral Systems (IFES). (2025). Youth futures: Understanding young people’s political and civic engagement as a counter to democratic backsliding. IFES. https://www.ifes.org/publications/youth-futures-understanding-young-peoples-political-and-civic-engagement-counter
Jarbandhan, D. B. (2021). Ethical public sector leadership and good governance: Implications for the fourth industrial revolution (4IR). Africa’s Public Service Delivery and Performance Review, 9(1), a488. https://doi.org/10.4102/apsdpr.v9i1.488
Legislative Mentorship Initiative (LMI). (n.d.). About LMI. Retrieved April 10, 2025, from https://lmi.org.ng/about-lmi/
Lising, R. V., & Rivera, J. P. R. (2024). Sangguniang Kabataan competencies in Quezon Province: A basis for capacity development program. International Journal of Social Sciences and Management Review, 7(3), 254-277. https://doi.org/10.37602/ijssmr.2024.7317
Power of Dialogue Consortium. (n.d.). Advocacy brief: Strengthening youth political participation through comprehensive support structures. https://www.power-of-dialogue.com/_files/ugd/24ff0c_753681c809ae4747b4f9b1d71007c24b.pdf
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.