Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

in the gacha game another eden, i asked for a water team, and i got this response: (1)…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar’s answer.
  1. User

    in the gacha game another eden, i asked for a water team, and i got this response: (1) Hoarfrost Songstress: water/bow user. sets awakened water zone and provides buffs through song. not a bad idea. (2) Necoco (Extra Style): wind/bow user. Sets buffs (some distinct from the Songstress) that take advantage of the awakened zone. Can change ("kaleido") the element of herself and all frontline allies' attacks based on the zone's element. can do 5 hit attacks. uhh, okay, but she's wind... (3) Nocturne Ninja: wind/fist user. Has buffs too but has some wind-specific buffs and debuffs. Does lots of hits per turn. attacks with magic but scales on POWer instead of INTelligence. but she's wind, too... (4) Izuna: thunder/staff user. More magic DPS scaled by INT. but thunder? (5) Yukino (Another Style): water/bow reserve unit. Grasta mule. (6) Nero: water/fists reserve unit. Grasta mule. (7) Pyggie: water/blunt attacker sidekick. ok. (8) Moke: reserve sidekick who is a debuffer and grants crit damage buff when a weakpoint is struck. (i think moke might be cool, but the game has stopped giving boss weakpoints recently). overall, is the one who gave me this advice serious?!

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    Based on the team recommendation you received, this actually makes more sense than it first appears. The recommendation leverages some key mechanics in Another Eden that create powerful synergies beyond just matching elements.

    Yes, this is a legitimate water team strategy, despite having wind and thunder characters. Here's why:

    Necoco's key ability is what makes this team work. According to discussions about team compositions, "Necoco ability to change parties' elements to any" is a game-changing feature[1]. When in a water zone, Necoco can use her "kaleido" skill to convert everyone's attacks to water element, effectively making your wind and thunder characters function as water attackers.

    This team setup follows a common meta strategy:

    1. Hoarfrost Songstress sets the awakened water zone, providing the foundation (+100% water damage)[12].

    2. Necoco ES serves as the element converter and buffer. In water zone, she can heal for approximately 3,000 HP and increase your water damage by 50% for the whole team[13]. Her buffs complement the Songstress's buffs since they're distinct.

    3. Nocturne Ninja is valued for her multi-hit capabilities. Once Necoco converts her attacks to water, those wind-specific buffs actually become water buffs.

    4. Izuna, similarly, becomes a water attacker when converted by Necoco, providing magic DPS that scales with INT.

    5. The reserve units (Yukino AS and Nero) function as "grasta mules" - they hold sharable grasta that benefit your frontline attackers[5]. This is an advanced strategy where characters in reserve provide passive buffs through equipment.

    6. Pyggie (water sidekick) and Moke (debuffer sidekick) provide additional support.

    This type of composition is part of what players call "universal" teams that utilize characters like Necoco or Iphi to change elements[1]. An example mentioned in discussions shows "Eva and Flamme with whatever support is needed... and slap a water grasta on somebody."[1]

    So yes, the person who gave you this advice understands the current meta strategies in Another Eden. It's actually quite sophisticated team building.

  3. User

    yeah, there were other traditional mono-water teams recommended, but as the asker who pulled 5-star mazrika and 5-star izuna, i was intrigued by this out of the box advice, especially because there's a current campaign in which i can get the normal style version of these characters for free just by going through the main story and pick up materials to sidegrade them into their recommended forms. this game is quite deep!

  4. Perplexity Assistant

    Your interest in this "out of the box" team recommendation makes perfect sense. This is actually a sophisticated meta strategy in Another Eden that leverages some key game mechanics!

    The team recommendation you received showcases one of the most powerful team-building approaches in the current meta: element conversion. The key component that makes this work is Necoco ES's "kaleido" ability, which can change herself and all frontline allies' attacks to match the active zone element[1].

    Here's why this team is strategically sound:

    1. Hoarfrost Songstress establishes an awakened water zone, which significantly boosts water damage (+100% water damage).

    2. Necoco ES, despite being wind, becomes your elemental converter. In water zone, she transforms everyone's attacks to water element, effectively making your wind and thunder characters function as water attackers[1][3].

    3. Nocturne Ninja (the "Nocturne Ninja Tsubame" referenced in the tier list) appears in the A-tier and brings valuable multi-hit capabilities, which become water hits after Necoco's conversion[1].

    4. Izuna, while thunder-based, becomes a magic DPS water attacker under Necoco's conversion.

    5. Your reserve units (Yukino AS and Nero) function as "grasta mules" - they hold specialized equipment (grasta) that provides passive buffs to your frontline attackers[5]. This is an advanced strategy that high-level players employ.

    This approach is actually part of what players call "universal" teams that utilize characters like Necoco to change elements[3]. According to the meta discussions in the search results, this team-building approach became popular after the game's evolution through various updates[3][4].

    Mazrika appears in the S-tier of the April 2025 tier list as a water character, confirming she's a strong unit for your team[1]. Your plan to obtain the normal styles through the main story and gather materials for sidegrading is a solid approach to building this team.

    This game indeed has incredible depth to its mechanics and team-building strategies!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt