Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gemini-2.0-flash-grounding· Google LMArena Search Arena 24K

in the gacha game another eden, i asked for a water team, and i got this response: (1)…

  1. User

    in the gacha game another eden, i asked for a water team, and i got this response: (1) Hoarfrost Songstress: water/bow user. sets awakened water zone and provides buffs through song. not a bad idea. (2) Necoco (Extra Style): wind/bow user. Sets buffs (some distinct from the Songstress) that take advantage of the awakened zone. Can change ("kaleido") the element of herself and all frontline allies' attacks based on the zone's element. can do 5 hit attacks. uhh, okay, but she's wind... (3) Nocturne Ninja: wind/fist user. Has buffs too but has some wind-specific buffs and debuffs. Does lots of hits per turn. attacks with magic but scales on POWer instead of INTelligence. but she's wind, too... (4) Izuna: thunder/staff user. More magic DPS scaled by INT. but thunder? (5) Yukino (Another Style): water/bow reserve unit. Grasta mule. (6) Nero: water/fists reserve unit. Grasta mule. (7) Pyggie: water/blunt attacker sidekick. ok. (8) Moke: reserve sidekick who is a debuffer and grants crit damage buff when a weakpoint is struck. might be cool, but the game has stopped giving boss weakpoints recently. overall, is the one who gave me this advice serious?!

  2. Assistant

    Let's break down the team composition advice you received for Another Eden, and whether it makes sense for a "water team," given the characters provided.

    It appears the advice is trying to create a team that centers around a Water Zone, but isn't exclusively water-based. Here's an analysis:

    • (1) Hoarfrost Songstress: The core of the team. Setting the Awakened Water Zone is crucial. She's water, and a zone setter, so she fits perfectly.
    • (2) Necoco (Extra Style): This is where it gets less straightforward. While Necoco is wind, her Kaleido ability is the key. In an Awakened Water Zone, "Kaleido" will change the element of attacks to water. The buffs she provides are also meant to synergize with the zone. So, while not naturally water, she becomes a water attacker within the zone.
    • (3) Nocturne Ninja: Similar to Necoco, Nocturne Ninja is wind by default. The advice suggests that the buffs the ninja provides could still be useful, but it could be argued that this team slot could be optimized for a water-based character.
    • (4) Izuna: Izuna's inclusion seems questionable at first glance, being a thunder character. There's no apparent mechanism for her to become a water attacker. It's possible the advisor is thinking of general team buffs/debuffs she provides, but her damage output won't benefit from the Water Zone. Her inclusion weakens the "water team" concept.
    • (5) Yukino (Another Style) & (6) Nero: As Grasta mules, their element doesn't matter as much. They are there to hold Water-enhancing Grasta to boost the damage of the main attackers. Nero being a water character is a plus.
    • (7) Pyggie: A water-based sidekick is a good fit.
    • (8) Moke: The advisor acknowledges the potential issue of weakpoints becoming less relevant. If bosses don't have weakpoints, Moke's utility drops significantly.

    Conclusion:

    The advisor seems to be suggesting a team that maximizes the Awakened Water Zone, even if it means including non-water characters who can, situationally, become water attackers (Necoco) or provide other forms of support. However, the inclusion of Izuna (thunder) seems like a misstep, as she doesn't gain much benefit from the Water Zone.

    Is the advice serious? Yes, but with caveats. The advice is serious in the sense that it's a legitimate team-building strategy focusing on zone synergy. However, it's not a pure water team, and the inclusion of Izuna is debatable. A more optimized "water team" would likely replace Izuna with another strong water DPS character. You could also consider if Nocturne Ninja provides enough unique support to justify their inclusion over another water character.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.