Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.0-flash-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

For younger men and women, rct adding protein to boost lean mass 95% failed to show any…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-pro-high’s answer.
  1. User

    For younger men and women, rct adding protein to boost lean mass 95% failed to show any significant increase in body mass 25 out of 26 failed. But enough trend in that direction that if you do meta analysis you can tease out about .3 kg increase over 13 weeks of an extra 40 grams of protein a day when added to a resistance training program – less than most people imagine – and that lean mass could be just water retention or liver and kidney swelling there’s actually not a great correlation between changes in lean mass measurements and the gold stnadards which is MRI where you can see the acutal muscle mass themselves.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, I understand. You're describing research regarding the effectiveness of adding extra protein to the diet of young men and women to increase lean body mass, specifically in the context of resistance training. Here's a breakdown of the points you've made:

    • RCT Failures: You're stating that a large percentage (95%) of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) examining the effect of added protein on lean mass in younger adults show no statistically significant increase in body mass. Specifically, 25 out of 26 studies failed to show significant increase.
    • Meta-Analysis and Small Increase: Despite the high failure rate of individual RCTs, meta-analyses (which combine the results of multiple studies) suggest a very small average increase in lean mass (around 0.3 kg) over about 13 weeks when individuals consume an additional 40 grams of protein per day alongside a resistance training program.
    • Lean Mass Measurement Issues: You're highlighting concerns about the accuracy and interpretation of "lean mass" measurements. The increase might not represent actual muscle growth. It could be due to water retention or swelling of organs like the liver and kidneys. Furthermore, changes in lean mass measurements don't always correlate well with actual muscle mass changes as measured by MRI (considered a "gold standard").

    In essence, you're suggesting that while extra protein might lead to a tiny increase in lean mass based on meta-analysis, the effect is small, and the nature of that "lean mass" increase is questionable. It's likely not the substantial muscle growth many people expect.

    To provide even more context and potentially refine this understanding, I'd like to check for recent research or meta-analyses that specifically address these points.

    Based on the search results, here's a refined and more detailed answer to your points:

    1. RCT Failures & Meta-Analysis:

    • Your statement about individual RCTs failing to show significant increases in lean mass with protein supplementation is supported by the general understanding in the field. Studies often have conflicting results due to variations in study design, participant characteristics (age, training status), protein type, dosage, and overall diet.[1]
    • Meta-analyses do often tease out a small, statistically significant effect. Several meta-analyses confirm that protein supplementation can lead to a modest increase in lean body mass (LBM) when combined with resistance exercise.[2] However, the effect size is often smaller than expected.
      • One meta-analysis ( source 4) including 49 studies with 1863 participants, found that protein supplementation increased fat-free mass (FFM) by an average of 0.30 kg during prolonged resistance training.
      • Another meta-analysis (source 15) showed a small but significant gain in LBM with increased protein intake in subjects undergoing resistance exercise training.
      • A systematic review and meta-analysis of 74 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) found that subjects engaged in RE who increased their protein intake experienced small but significant gains in LBM (source 13).
    • It's important to note that some meta-analyses also suggest that the benefits of protein supplementation plateau at intakes beyond 1.62 g/kg/day (source 20).

    2. Lean Mass Measurement Issues and MRI as a Gold Standard:

    • Accuracy Concerns: Your concerns regarding the interpretation of "lean mass" are valid. Lean mass, as measured by common techniques like DXA (Dual-Energy X-ray Absorptiometry) and BIA (Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis), includes water, organs, and other non-fat tissues, not just muscle.[3]
      • DXA-derived lean mass consists not only of muscle mass but also other non-bone and non-fat mass, including soft tissue and water (source 2).[3]
      • BIA results can be altered with hydration status, making it a less accurate measure of muscle mass compared to CT scans (source 2).
    • MRI as a Gold Standard: MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) is frequently cited as a gold standard for assessing muscle mass due to its ability to directly visualize and quantify muscle tissue (sources 1, 5, 8, 12). MRI provides detailed volumetric assessments of muscles (source 5).
      • MRI is considered more accurate than CT because of its higher contrast between different tissues (source 12).
    • DXA vs. MRI: Studies comparing DXA to MRI have shown good correlations but often poor agreement, with DXA sometimes overestimating lean mass (source 5). This is because DXA measures the attenuation of X-rays, which can be influenced by bone mineral content and lean mass, leading to overestimations of fat percentage in individuals with higher bone density or muscle mass (source 14).
    • Alternatives to MRI: While MRI is a gold standard, it's also expensive and not always readily accessible.[4] B-mode ultrasonography is being evaluated as a lower-cost alternative for measuring muscle hypertrophy and atrophy (source 1).

    3. Water Retention and Organ Swelling:

    • While not explicitly stated in all sources, your point about water retention and organ swelling contributing to "lean mass" gains is a valid consideration. Increases in lean mass, especially small changes, should be interpreted cautiously.
    • It is crucial to differentiate between actual muscle protein synthesis (MPS) and temporary fluctuations in fluid balance.

    In Summary:

    The scientific literature suggests that protein supplementation can augment muscle mass and strength gains during resistance training, but the effect is often modest. The increase in "lean mass" may not solely represent muscle growth and can be influenced by other factors like water retention. MRI is considered a gold standard for directly measuring muscle mass, offering more accuracy than other methods like DXA and BIA. When interpreting research on protein supplementation and muscle growth, it's important to consider the limitations of lean mass measurements and focus on studies that utilize more precise techniques like MRI when available.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.