Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

in the gacha game another eden, i asked for a water team, and i got this response: (1)…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-reasoning-pro-high’s answer.
  1. User

    in the gacha game another eden, i asked for a water team, and i got this response: (1) Hoarfrost Songstress: water/bow user. sets awakened water zone and provides buffs through song. not a bad idea. (2) Necoco (Extra Style): wind/bow user. Sets buffs (some distinct from the Songstress) that take advantage of the awakened zone. Can change ("kaleido") the element of herself and all frontline allies' attacks based on the zone's element. can do 5 hit attacks. uhh, okay, but she's wind... (3) Nocturne Ninja: wind/fist user. Has buffs too but has some wind-specific buffs and debuffs. Does lots of hits per turn. attacks with magic but scales on POWer instead of INTelligence. but she's wind, too... (4) Izuna: thunder/staff user. More magic DPS scaled by INT. but thunder? (5) Yukino (Another Style): water/bow reserve unit. Grasta mule. (6) Nero: water/fists reserve unit. Grasta mule. (7) Pyggie: water/blunt attacker sidekick. ok. (8) Moke: sidekick who is a debuffer and grants crit damage buff when a weakpoint is struck. might be cool, but the game has stopped giving boss weakpoints recently. overall, is the one who gave me this advice serious?!

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    The team composition advice you received has some merit, though it's not a pure water team in the traditional sense.

    Necoco ES is actually a brilliant inclusion despite being wind-based. From her kit, she has the crucial "kaleido" ability that changes her element and all frontline allies' attacks to match the active zone[1]. In a water zone, she'll effectively become a water attacker. This ability is powerful enough that it's specifically mentioned in discussions about team building as a way to make characters universal.

    Similarly, Nocturne Ninja can benefit from Necoco's element conversion in a water zone. The multi-hit nature of her attacks would work well with AF (Another Force) gauge building.

    Izuna as a thunder/staff user is the most questionable addition. While she might benefit from some general buffs, she doesn't synergize as well with the water theme unless there's some specific interaction not immediately apparent.

    The grasta mules (Yukino AS and Nero) make perfect sense as they're providing passive benefits from the reserve slots[7]. The sidekicks are also reasonable choices.

    Water teams are considered extremely powerful in the current meta. Players frequently mention that "water has the two best DPS in the game" and describe water teams as having "insane water dps"[1].

    While this team isn't a pure water composition, it's using Necoco's element conversion mechanic to create an effective team that can take advantage of water zone benefits. It's a legitimate strategy, though you could potentially improve it by replacing Izuna with a natural water DPS unit if available.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.