Skip to content
The Chat Archive
sonar-reasoning-pro-high· Perplexity LMArena Search Arena 24K

Our paper will focus on Monica Sone’s Nisei Daughter and on how Monica Sone…

  1. User

    Our paper will focus on Monica Sone’s Nisei Daughter and on how Monica Sone conceptualizes her own ethnicity—in other words, on what being Japanese means to her.

    Your paper should do so by concentrating on a particular phase in the development of her ethnicity. What “phases” she goes through in the book is something we’ll discuss in more detail in class, but also something you will discover (or have discovered) on your own while reading the book.

    How does one write about the development of ethnicity, in this case, the meaning “Japaneseness” holds for Sone? One does so by focusing on the words, symbols, and situations that the book associates with being Japanese. What word choice does the author employ when speaking of her ethnicity? What is the attitude towards her ethnicity implied by that word choice, by symbols and situations? You have to do more than simply state what the author’s attitude is: you have to explain to a reader what in the text makes you think so. Your argument must be supported by quotations from the book that will serve as evidence. You must interpret those quotations to convince the reader that your argument on how Sone sees being Japanese is a reasonable one.

    The paper should be a minimum of three pages long (double-spaced, 12-point font, one-inch margin). Please submit the document as a Microsoft Word document, as pdf file. here is also a link to the book to refresh your memory and grab quotes from https://archive.org/details/nationalcovenant00scot/mode/2up

    PS: Below is a paper a former student wrote some years ago. It should give you a good idea. of what a paper like this might look like, though it is a little sparse with evidence (but otherwise well written and argued).

    Former Student

    English 202

    Dr. Martin Japtok

                                                                                                              Ethnic Identity Crisis
    
    
    
    Ideally, the on-going globalization of the world should be an arena for all kinds of flows and exchanges in which the local is synergized with the global and vice versa. In reality, of course, globalization has also fragmented people’s ethnic identities and fueled ethnic divisions. Monica Sone, the author of Nisei Daughter, is one of those who struggle with identifying herself in terms of a single ethnicity, due to the two different cultures that she inherits. Sone is a Japanese-American woman who describes her childhood, adolescence, and young womanhood while growing up in a Japanese immigrant family in Seattle, Washington in the 1930s. In her autobiography, she begins by introducing the shocking moment when she first found out that she was Japanese. From then on, she traces how the meaning of being Japanese changes from her early days spent both in the American and the Japanese school to the internment camps of Idaho, where her family was relocated by the United States War Department during the World War II. The very first phase of the book lets the readers encounter Sone’s unique ethnic identity that is developed through her denial of being Japanese.  The first scene of the book starts out with her discovery of the fact that she is Japanese and that her parents want her to attend Japanese school. In reaction to being made to go to the Japanese school, Sone ends up establishing negative views on being Japanese and is in denial of her Japaneseness during her childhood. 
    
     From the very early stage of life, Sone develops a sense of rejection toward being Japanese. When Sone was six years old, her mother triggers Sone’s first realization that she is Japanese at the dinner table, and her immediate reaction is negative already: “Terrible, terrible, terrible! So that’s what it means to be a Japanese- to lose my afternoon play hours!”(Sone 4).  The association that she makes between being Japanese and losing playtime is a good enough reason for her, being an innocent little child, to develop a somewhat negative image of Japaneseness. At this point of her life, she does not know that certain ethnic groups are considered to be the minority in society while others are considered to be the majority, and therefore, she does not understand why she needs to go to the Japanese school when non-ethnic American kids do not have to get extra tutoring. Therefore, she naturally asks: “Why did father and Mother make such a fuss just because we had Japanese blood?”(5). This particular scene of passionate rejection to attend Japanese school already lets the readers anticipate that the early stage of her ethnic identity development will more or less be accompanied by her dislike of what she calls her “Japanese blood.”
    
      In the first chapter, “A Shocking Fact of Life,” Sone often compares the Japanese mindset to the American mindset, indicating that she favors the latter. For example, she states that, "At Bailey Gatzert School I was a jumping, screaming, roustabout Yankee, but at the stroke of three when the school bell rang and doors burst open everywhere, spewing out pupils like jelly beans from a broken bag, I suddenly became a modest, faltering, earnest little Japanese girl with a small, timid voice" (22). Sone describes this experience as feeling like a “chameleon”, having to switch her personality between the two schools. This statement is the key to understanding much of this phase of Sone’s racial identity development. The words she uses to describe American children in her school do not necessarily have a positive connotation, but she still repeatedly hints at her preference for  identifying as an American girl. For instance, she sees life as, “too urgent, too exciting, too colorful for me to be sitting quietly in the parlor and contemplating a spray of chrysanthemums in a bowl as a cousin of mine might be doing in Osaka”(28). She associates the Japanese mindset with something negative such as boredom and colorlessness, just the opposite of the typical American conception of life to which she considers herself accustomed. Though she thinks that the sole reason why she wants to be viewed as an American is simply because she can relate to what she considers the American mentality much better than to what she sees the Japanese one, the truth is that her racial identity is a product of her subconscious effort to ignore the undeniable presence of “Japaneseness” in her. That is to say, she is more Japanese than she thinks she is.
    
      The evidence of her being in denial of one of the two nationalities is most prominently expressed in how she describes her house: “At first glance, there was little about these simple, sparse furnishings to indicate that a Japanese family occupied the rooms” (11). This remark sounds strange because the following sentence states that she sees Japanese zori, “Japanese parasols,” “Seattle’s Japanese community paper,” and an “Oriental abacus board” in the house. Why did she have to insist that her house looks just the same as any other American’s if that is true only at first glance? She could have chosen to simply write that her house shows a mixture of both Japanese and American culture if she did not mean to indicate a preference between the two. The same goes with her description of meals that her parents prepare. While she names many Japanese ingredients that she sees in her kitchen such as shoyu, nappa, daikon and nuka, she also mentions distinctly American dishes that her father cooks, such as “ham and eggs, steaks and potatoes, apple and pumpkin pies,” concluding that “we [she and her family] adhered mostly to a simple American menu” (13). By emphasizing American traits whenever she writes about both Japanese and American culture, she let the readers know that she prefers to be seen as an American.
    
     She obviously feels that the racial category that is automatically stamped on her is nothing but a burden, for it almost compels her to acquire certain qualities that she currently does not have or want to have. One of such qualities that she feels most alienated from is a disciplined mind, which Japanese culture strongly emphasizes. As she describes her life in Japanese school, she describes her realization that “[t]here was a driving spirit of strict discipline behind it all which reached out and weighed heavily upon each pupil’s consciousness” (24). The expression “weighed heavily upon” reveals how the school accelerated the pressure on her to be molded into an ideal Japanese girl, imposing what she describes as oppressive and almost militaristic rules to follow. After all, her incompatibility with Japanese traits that she says she learns in Japanese school ends up justifying her idea that she is more American than Japanese. Moreover, what reinforces such an idea further is her admiration for American traits.
    
      Montana, a white American man who lives in her father’s hotel, is introduced in the book as a symbol of Americanness, which Sone adores very much. How she sees Americanness in Montana is evident in her description of him: “a wall-shaking mountain of a man”(19), “Well over six feet tall with a tightly curled, black beard growing rampant down over his faded flannel shirt, Montana was an awesome figure”(32). Furthermore, before her ethnic identity gets confused by her realization that she is both Japanese and American, she blindly put a total faith in what this white man called her, a Yankee: Montana “. . . called me a Yankee. I didn’t see how I could be a Yankee and Japanese at the same time” (19). She is hesitant to see herself as Japanese even though she was surrounded by Japanese family, Japanese friends and Japanese customs all through her life. That is to say, instead of listening to the wisdom of Japanese adults, she favors the wisdom of American strangers. She idealizes Americans excessively, wishing to be regarded as one.
    
    Monica Sone continually keeps her eyes aside from the reality that she has inherited Japanese culture, interpreting her environment in a fixed way that emphasizes her Americanness.  Her negative image of being Japanese was established at a very early age, only to be reinforced later by the arbitrary judgment that derives from her comparisons between the American mindset and the Japanese mindset. In Japanese school, she is almost convinced of her incompatibility with Japaneseness, given that she does not possess the quality asked for in a Japanese girl. In this phase of the book, the readers are not yet provided with enough information to judge why she is eager to be regarded as an American. Up to this point, the readers are left feeling puzzled, expecting to find the clues for the reason for her difficult relationship with her ethnicity, which is later revealed to have something to do with her experience of ethnic discrimination that she had to undergo from her childhood onward. This long-lasting discrimination in her life caused her to believe that she is not good enough as a person if she is not an American, the ethnic group that she has come to think of as superior by internalizing discrimination.
    
  2. Assistant

    Monica Sone’s Nisei Daughter traces her evolving understanding of her Japanese American identity through distinct phases, marked by conflict, disillusionment, and eventual reconciliation. By examining her word choice, symbolic contrasts, and pivotal experiences, we can map how her perception of “Japaneseness” shifts from childhood denial to a blended cultural identity.

    Phase 1: Childhood Denial and Cultural Duality

    Sone’s earliest awareness of her ethnicity is framed by resistance and alienation. At six, she describes learning of her Japanese heritage as a “shocking fact of life,” associating it with the loss of playtime and freedom[1][3]. Her parents’ insistence on Japanese school (Nihon Gakko) forces her to adopt a split identity:
    > “At Bailey Gatzert School I was a jumping, screaming, roustabout Yankee, but at the stroke of three ... I suddenly became a modest, faltering, earnest little Japanese girl”[3][9].

    The metaphor of a “chameleon” underscores her discomfort, as she navigates strict Japanese discipline (e.g., bowing, silence) against her “Yankee” exuberance[1][2]. Symbols like the Carrollton Hotel—where American apple pie sits alongside Japanese zori sandals—reflect her family’s bicultural life, yet Sone emphasizes its “simple American menu” and downplays Japanese elements[3][9]. This selective framing reveals her early preference for Americanness, which she idealizes through figures like Montana, a white tenant whose approval she craves[9].


    Phase 2: Wartime Disillusionment and Forced Reckoning

    The bombing of Pearl Harbor and subsequent internment shatter Sone’s belief in her American identity. Executive Order 9066 reduces her citizenship to a “hyphenated” abstraction:
    > “Maybe I wasn’t considered an American anymore. My citizenship wasn’t real after all”[4].

    In Camp Minidoka, she confronts systemic racism, symbolized by barbed wire and armed guards, which starkly contrasts her earlier Seattle life[3][6]. The camp becomes a liminal space where she grapples with her dual heritage. While some internees resent the U.S. government, Sone’s family clings to resilience, yet her narration reveals bitterness:
    > “We were ... enemy aliens, yet we were born here”[1][3].

    This phase forces her to confront the fragility of assimilation. The War Department’s recruitment of Nisei soldiers highlights the paradox of their loyalty:
    > “First they change my army status ... and now they want me to volunteer for a suicide squad”[3].

    Here, “Japaneseness” is both a marker of exclusion and a source of communal strength, as seen in her family’s efforts to maintain traditions like New Year’s rituals[1][6].


    Phase 3: Reconciliation and Hybrid Identity

    Post-internment, Sone’s narrative shifts toward integration. In Chicago and college, she adopts “Monica” over “Kazuko,” symbolizing a pragmatic embrace of her American self while retaining pride in her heritage[7][9]. Reflecting on her journey, she concludes:
    > “The Japanese and American parts of me were now blended into one”[3][6].

    This reconciliation is rooted in her parents’ teachings:
    > “We’re all Americans ... even if our faces are different”[3].

    Symbols of hybridity—such as her family’s pantry blending rice and soy sauce with “ivory-painted canisters” of American staples—mirror her internal synthesis[3][9]. Her autobiography itself becomes an act of cultural bridging, using a childlike tone to humanize Japanese American struggles for white readers[1][6].


    Conclusion

    Sone’s conceptualization of ethnicity evolves from denial (rejecting Japanese school), through crisis (internment’s dehumanization), to a conscious embrace of duality. Her word choice (“chameleon,” “two-headed freak”) and symbolic contrasts (freedom vs. discipline, barbed wire vs. apple pie) chart this trajectory. By the memoir’s end, “Japaneseness” is neither a burden nor a binary but a facet of a layered identity, resiliently forged through adversity.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.