Search for internet articles about the authors who wrote a letter against Derrida
- User
Search for internet articles about the authors who wrote a letter against Derrida
Assistant
In 1992, a group of 19 academics, including prominent philosophers such as Willard Van Orman Quine, Ruth Barcan Marcus, David Armstrong, and René Thom, signed a letter opposing the awarding of an honorary degree to Jacques Derrida by Cambridge University. The letter, published in The Times of London, argued that Derrida's work did not meet "accepted standards of clarity and rigour" and described his philosophy as consisting of "semi-intelligible attacks upon the values of reason, truth, and scholarship." The signatories claimed that Derrida's influence was largely confined to fields outside philosophy, such as literature and film studies, and criticized his use of "tricks and gimmicks" akin to those of Dadaist art[1][10][15][17].
The protest was led by D.H. Mellor, a professor of philosophy at Cambridge, and supported by other analytic philosophers who viewed Derrida's deconstructionist approach as lacking in philosophical rigor. Despite the opposition, Cambridge University ultimately awarded Derrida the honorary degree after a formal vote, with 336 votes in favor and 204 against[1][15].
Derrida responded to the criticism by highlighting what he saw as the "journalistic" and "philosophical nationalism" of the letter, arguing that it violated the very principles of reason and scholarship it purported to defend. He also challenged his critics to engage more substantively with his work rather than dismissing it outright[1][15][17].
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.