Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-search-preview-high-loc· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Write me a rocm kernel to do a a fp4 microscaled matmul in fp32. for example, one of the…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Perplexitysonar-pro-high’s answer.
  1. User

    Write me a rocm kernel to do a a fp4 microscaled matmul in fp32. for example, one of the specific operations is a (2048 x 12288) matrix multiplied by a (12288 x 49152) matrix, which outputs a (2048 x 49152) matrix. do this matmul kernel based on the capabilites of gcn 5.1 aka radeon instinct mi50. so i need some microscaled dequant and requant. find out how the nvidia blackwell microscaling works and keep to that fp4 and fp6 format with the scale factor etc. make good use of the relevant best practices. this is a really good starting point from the rdna3 side, unfortunately gcn5.1 isnt as nice. https://seb-v.github.io/optimization/update/2025/01/20/Fast-GPU-Matrix-multiplication.html this is a very good one for cuda like stuff: https://siboehm.com/articles/22/CUDA-MMM this is a good one for the whole concept: https://justine.lol/matmul/ in general: please inform yourself from the relevant vega and gcn5.1 arch docs (https://www.amd.com/content/dam/amd/en/documents/radeon-tech-docs/instruction-set-architectures/vega-shader-instruction-set-architecture.pdf) and llvm (https://llvm.org/docs/AMDGPU/AMDGPUAsmGFX906.html) on how to properly do these things. reminder: look up cache sizes, lds structure etc, vega20 is also known as gfx906. if you cannot access the internet, use chain of thought with regards to the process and the content of the links.

  2. Assistant

    Implementing a matrix multiplication (matmul) kernel on the AMD Radeon Instinct MI50 (GCN 5.1 architecture) that utilizes FP4 microscaling with FP32 accumulation involves several key steps:

    1. Understanding FP4 Microscaling:

      • FP4 Format: FP4 represents numbers using 4 bits, allowing for 16 distinct values. Due to its limited range and precision, it's often used with a scaling factor to map a wider range of values.
      • Microscaling Concept: This involves scaling FP4 values to a higher precision format (e.g., FP32) during computation and then re-quantizing the result back to FP4. This approach balances memory efficiency with computational accuracy.
    2. GCN 5.1 Architecture Overview:

      • Compute Units (CUs): The MI50 comprises 60 CUs, each capable of executing multiple wavefronts.
      • Wavefront Size: Each wavefront consists of 64 threads.
      • Local Data Share (LDS): Each CU has 64 KiB of LDS, facilitating efficient data sharing among threads within a workgroup.
      • Caches:
        • L1 Vector Cache: 16 KiB per CU.
        • L1 Scalar Cache: 32 KiB shared among three CUs.
        • L2 Cache: 4 MiB shared across the GPU.
    3. Kernel Implementation Strategy:

      • Data Layout and Memory Access:
        • Store matrices in a row-major format to optimize coalesced memory accesses.
        • Utilize LDS to cache sub-matrices (tiles) of the input matrices, reducing global memory accesses.
      • Thread Mapping:
        • Assign each thread to compute a single element of the output matrix.
        • Organize threads into workgroups that collaboratively load and process tiles of the input matrices.
      • FP4 Dequantization and Requantization:
        • Each FP4 value is associated with a scaling factor.
        • During computation, convert FP4 values to FP32 by multiplying with their respective scaling factors.
        • After computation, convert the FP32 result back to FP4 by dividing by the scaling factor and quantizing.
    4. Kernel Code Outline:

      • Kernel Launch Configuration:
        • Determine grid and block dimensions based on matrix sizes and hardware capabilities.
      • Shared Memory Allocation:
        • Allocate LDS for storing tiles of matrices A and B.
      • Loading Tiles into Shared Memory:
        • Each thread loads a portion of the matrices into LDS, ensuring coalesced accesses.
      • Matrix Multiplication:
        • Perform the multiplication of the loaded tiles, accumulating results in FP32.
      • Storing Results:
        • Write the computed tiles back to global memory.
    5. Performance Considerations:

      • Memory Coalescing: Ensure global memory accesses are coalesced to maximize bandwidth utilization.
      • LDS Utilization: Effectively use LDS to minimize global memory accesses and leverage data reuse.
      • Occupancy Optimization: Balance the number of active wavefronts per CU to maximize resource utilization without exceeding hardware limits.

    By carefully designing the kernel to leverage the MI50's architecture and implementing efficient FP4 microscaling, you can achieve a high-performance matrix multiplication suitable for large-scale computations.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.