Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar· PerplexityHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Please suggest the best recipes/ideas for cookie ice cream sandwiches, only using…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-mini-search-preview’s answer.
  1. User

    Please suggest the best recipes/ideas for cookie ice cream sandwiches, only using ingredients from Asda and/or Tesco. Please list substitutes for key and/or hard to find ingredients. I’m after the most avant-garde, ultra-contemporary, hyper-modern flavour profiles and combinations that are in season across menus in 1,2, and 3 Michelin-star restaurants internationally as of now. Please suggest items that are ready to eat, or need as little prep as possible. I have an air fryer, and also a saucepan, if need be.

  2. Perplexity Assistant

    Here are some cutting-edge cookie ice cream sandwich ideas using ingredients available at Asda and Tesco, inspired by contemporary Michelin-starred flavor trends. The recipes balance avant-garde combinations with minimal prep, leveraging your air fryer for efficiency.


    Modern Flavor Profiles & Quick Assembly Ideas

    1. Brown Butter & Miso Caramel with Sesame Cookies

    Ingredients (Asda/Tesco):

    • Cookies: Substitute with Lotus Biscoff biscuits (Tesco) or make quick sesame cookies using Asda’s gluten-free flour, tahini, and honey.
    • Ice Cream: Tesco Finest Madagascan Vanilla + 1 tbsp white miso paste (Asda) stirred in.
    • Filling: Asda’s caramel sauce mixed with browned butter (heat butter in a saucepan until nutty).
    • Roll in: Crushed black sesame seeds (Tesco World Foods aisle).

    Prep:

    • Air-fry Lotus Biscoff for 2 mins at 160°C to warm.
    • Sandwich miso-vanilla ice cream between cookies, drizzle with caramel, and roll in sesame.

    2. Matcha White Chocolate & Yuzu Curd

    Ingredients:

    • Cookies: Tesco’s white chocolate chip cookies (or air-fry Pillsbury dough with matcha powder).
    • Ice Cream: Asda’s coconut ice cream + 1 tsp matcha powder (Tesco).
    • Filling: Yuzu marmalade (Tesco World Foods) or lemon curd mixed with lime zest.
    • Roll in: Freeze-dried raspberries (Tesco).

    Prep:

    • Spread yuzu curd on cookies, add matcha-coconut ice cream, and press. Roll in raspberry dust.

    3. Smoked Salt & Dark Chocolate Ganache

    Ingredients:

    • Cookies: Tesco’s dark chocolate digestives.
    • Ice Cream: Asda’s Belgian chocolate ice cream + pinch of smoked salt (Tesco).
    • Filling: Melted dark chocolate (70%+) + splash of double cream.
    • Roll in: Crushed cocoa nibs (Tesco Free From aisle).

    Prep:

    • Air-fry digestives for 3 mins at 160°C to crisp. Layer ganache and smoked chocolate ice cream.

    Ultra-Quick Hacks (Ready-to-Eat)

    • TikTok Air-Fry Hack: Use Tesco’s cookie dough wraps to encase pre-made ice cream sandwiches, air-fry 5 mins at 200°C for a warm-crisp shell.
    • Deconstructed: Crush Tesco’s ginger nut biscuits over Asda’s mango sorbet, drizzle with chili-infused honey.

    Substitutes for Hard-to-Find Ingredients

    • Miso Paste: Substitute with soy sauce + sugar reduction.
    • Yuzu: Lime + orange zest.
    • Matcha: Spinach powder (for color, not flavor) or green tea bags (ground).

    These combinations draw from 2025 Michelin trends like umami-sweet balance (miso), Japanese-European fusion (matcha/yuzu), and textured contrasts (smoked salt). Minimal prep, maximal impact.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.