Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding· Google LMArena Search Arena 24K

Authors who acknowledge that God is perfect, but its actions are arbitrary

  1. User

    Authors who acknowledge that God is perfect, but its actions are arbitrary

  2. Assistant

    Okay, let's look for authors and thinkers who grapple with the complex idea of a God considered perfect, yet whose actions might appear arbitrary or incomprehensible from a human standpoint. This tension often arises in discussions about divine sovereignty, free will, the problem of evil, and the nature of morality.

    It appears you're asking about thinkers who explore the tension between God's perfection (often understood as omnibenevolent, omnipotent, omniscient) and the apparent arbitrariness or inscrutability of God's actions or commands from a human perspective.[[1]] This is a complex theological and philosophical issue often addressed in several contexts:

    1. Divine Command Theory (DCT):

      • Core Idea: DCT posits that an action's moral status (right or wrong) is determined by God's commands.[[3]][[4]][[6]] Something is right because God commands it.[[7]]
      • Tension: Critics argue this makes morality arbitrary – if God commanded cruelty, would it become good? Proponents often counter this by linking God's commands to His perfect nature (e.g., omnibenevolence). So, God wouldn't command cruelty because it's contrary to His perfect, loving nature. However, the ultimate source of morality remains God's will/command, which can seem arbitrary if detached from understandable reasons.[[5]]
      • Thinkers associated with variations of DCT:
        • William of Ockham (c. 1287–1347): Emphasized God's absolute freedom and power. Some interpretations suggest he held that God could command actions contrary to what we normally consider good, and they would become obligatory, highlighting divine will over fixed rational principles.
        • John Duns Scotus (c. 1265–1308): Argued that while God cannot command something logically contradictory (like hating Himself), He has freedom regarding contingent moral laws (like those beyond the first two commandments). His emphasis on divine will over intellect can lead to interpretations where God's choices seem less bound by inherent rationality and thus potentially arbitrary from a human view.[[1]]
        • Robert Merrihew Adams (Contemporary): Proposed a "Modified Divine Command Theory," suggesting an action is wrong if and only if it's contrary to the commands of a loving God.[[4]] This attempts to solve the arbitrariness problem by grounding commands in God's perfect (loving) nature, though the commands themselves still define obligation.
    2. Søren Kierkegaard (1813–1855):

      • Key Work: Fear and Trembling.[[8]][[9]][[10]]
      • Concept: Explores the story of Abraham being commanded by God to sacrifice his son Isaac.[[3]] From a purely ethical standpoint (the "universal"), this command is monstrous and irrational. Abraham's faith requires a "teleological suspension of the ethical," meaning he must obey God's command even though it violates universal moral laws.[[9]]
      • Tension: God, presumed perfect, issues a command that appears ethically arbitrary and horrifying. Faith involves trusting God absolutely, even when His commands are incomprehensible or seem ethically wrong from a human perspective. Kierkegaard highlights the paradoxical nature of faith where the individual's relationship with God transcends universal ethics.[[9]]
    3. The Book of Job (Biblical Text):

      • Scenario: Job, described as a righteous and blameless man, suffers immense loss and physical affliction, seemingly without cause.[[11]]
      • Tension: Job questions why a just and perfect God would allow such suffering for someone righteous. God's eventual response doesn't give Job specific reasons but emphasizes His own vast power, wisdom, and sovereignty over creation, highlighting the inscrutability of His ways from a limited human viewpoint. Job ultimately submits to God's wisdom, acknowledging his inability to comprehend God's grand purposes, which can appear arbitrary when unexplained.
    4. Ash'arite Theology (School within Sunni Islam, founded by Al-Ash'ari c. 874–936):

      • Core Idea: Emphasizes God's absolute omnipotence and will.[[11]] God creates all actions, including human actions, though humans "acquire" responsibility for them (kasb/iktisab).[[12]][[13]] Events occur not due to necessary cause-and-effect but because God wills them moment by moment (occasionalism).
      • Tension: God's actions and decrees are not bound by human conceptions of rationality or justice. While God is perfect, His will is absolute and may appear arbitrary because He is not constrained by any external standard or even His own previous "custom" ('adah). Obedience is a criterion for reward arbitrarily decreed by God, not a necessary cause.
    5. Discussions on God's Sovereignty and Inscrutability:

      • Many theologians, particularly within traditions like Calvinism, emphasize God's absolute sovereignty and decree. While affirming God's perfection and wisdom, they stress that His ultimate reasons for specific events (especially suffering or election) are often hidden ("inscrutable") to humans.
      • Thinkers (in various ways): John Calvin, Martin Luther (on God's hidden will), contemporary philosophers grappling with the Problem of Evil (who might appeal to "skeptical theism" – the idea that we are in no position to judge whether God has good reasons for allowing evil).
      • Tension: God is perfect and acts according to His perfect wisdom, but His reasons transcend human understanding, making His actions appear arbitrary or baffling from our limited perspective. Paul expresses this in Romans 11:33: "Oh, the depth of the riches and wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are his judgments and how inscrutable his ways!"

    In summary, while these thinkers affirm God's perfection, they engage with scenarios or doctrines where God's actions or commands challenge human understanding of reason, ethics, or justice, leading to discussions about apparent arbitrariness, divine freedom, and the limits of human comprehension in the face of divine mystery.[[12]]

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt