Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

Authors who claimed that the Father died on the cross

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding’s answer.
  1. User

    Authors who claimed that the Father died on the cross

  2. Gemini Assistant

    The claim that God the Father died on the cross is known as Patripassianism (from Latin Pater, "Father", and passio, "suffering").[[1]][[2]][[4]] This view is considered a heresy within mainstream Christianity, which teaches that only God the Son, Jesus Christ, suffered and died on the cross in his human nature.[[3]][[6]]

    Patripassianism is closely associated with Modalism (also known as Sabellianism), which denies the distinct persons within the Trinity (Father, Son, Holy Spirit) and teaches that these are merely different "modes" or manifestations of the one God.[[1]][[4]][[8]] If there is no real distinction between the Father and the Son, then the suffering and death of the Son would imply the suffering and death of the Father.

    The main figures associated with promoting these views in the early Church (late 2nd and early 3rd centuries) were:

    1. Praxeas: He was an opponent of Montanism who taught in Rome and Carthage around the late 2nd/early 3rd century. The early Church theologian Tertullian wrote a work titled Against Praxeas (Adversus Praxean) specifically to refute his teachings.[[9]] Tertullian famously summarized Praxeas's view with the accusation that Praxeas "put the Holy Spirit to flight and crucified the Father".[[4]] Praxeas taught a Monarchian doctrine, emphasizing the unity of God to the point that Tertullian viewed it as identifying the Father and the Son as the same person, meaning the Father suffered on the cross.[[9]]
    2. Noetus of Smyrna: A contemporary of Praxeas, possibly from Ephesus or Smyrna. He also taught that the Father suffered.[[1]][[5]][[10]] Hippolytus of Rome wrote against him. Some sources suggest Praxeas might have been a disciple of Noetus.[[9]][[11]][[12]] Noetus was eventually excommunicated by a council of presbyters in Smyrna.
    3. Sabellius: A priest active in Rome in the early 3rd century (around 217-220 AD), after whom Sabellianism (Modalism) is named. While his exact teachings are debated because his writings were destroyed, he taught that the Godhead is a monad expressing itself in three operations or modes: Father in creation, Son in redemption, and Spirit in sanctification. This view implies Patripassianism, as it collapses the distinction between the Father and the Son.[[3]][[4]] Sabellius was excommunicated by Pope Callixtus I around 220 AD.[[8]][[10]]

    It's important to note that our knowledge of these figures often comes from the writings of their opponents (like Tertullian and Hippolytus), who were refuting what they considered heresy. While these authors are historically identified as proponents of Patripassianism or views implying it, direct writings from them confirming this explicitly may be scarce. The mainstream Church condemned these views early on, affirming the orthodox doctrine of the Trinity: one God existing eternally as three distinct persons – Father, Son, and Holy Spirit – with only the Son becoming incarnate and dying on the cross.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.