here is my for and against essay: " Nowadays many young people decide to work as…
- User
here is my for and against essay: " Nowadays many young people decide to work as volunteers on holidays. Spending your free time on helping the others seems to be the good way. Lets look at what your free time
Some people do not count volunteering as a job. One of the main reasons for this is that you do not get paid as a volunteer. However there are plenty of ways you could be get rewarded in. You will get experience that you may need in future. Volunteering also has benefits. You get satisfaction from helping the other people or from taking care of animals. Another benefit of volunteering may be the proof of work you get after job done. The chance of being accepted in some colleges may be increased if you volunteered. We can see that volunteering on holidays has both pros and cons. It depends on you what you want to achieve in your free time. If you do not care about financial benefits from it and you want to make world better and help others feel free to try."here are the rules: "FOR-AND-AGAINST ESSAY T ASK: Obecnie wielu uczniów decyduje się na studia wyższe po ukończeniu szkoły średniej. Napisz rozprawkę, w której omówisz zalety i wady takiego wyboru INTRODUCTION [PARA. 1]
- Należy pamiętać, że w rozprawce za i przeciw we wstępie przedstawiamy ogólnie temat pracy NIE uwzględniając własnej opinii,
- Czyli NIE stosuj we wstępie słów i zwrotów prezentujących Twoją opinię takich jak: I believe, I think, I strongly support the idea that … , I am of the opinion itp.). Mogą być one użyte wyłącznie w ostatnim paragrafie. Example: The transition from high school to higher education is a pivotal moment in the lives of many students. The decision to apply to university after graduating from high school is a complex one, involving a careful consideration of numerous factors. There are the advantages and disadvantages of pursuing university education. PARA. 2 [present the arguments FOR the issue + give examples / explanation] There are many advantages of university education. First of all, university programs offer in-depth knowledge and expertise in specific fields of study. This specialized education is particularly valuable for professions that require a deep understanding of complex subjects. It equips graduates with the skills and knowledge needed to excel in their chosen career paths. Second of all, university serves as a hub for networking, connecting students with professors, peers, and industry professionals. Building a strong professional network during university can significantly impact future career prospects. Networking can lead to internships, mentorships, and job opportunities that might not be easily accessible outside the university setting. PARA. 3 [ give arguments against the issue + examples] On the other hand, university education has its disadvantages. For one thing, one of the primary concerns associated with pursuing university education is the financial burden. Tuition fees, textbooks, accommodation, and other living expenses can led to significant student loan debt. The financial investment required for a university degree can be a barrier for some students. Furthermore, while a university degree often leads to increased earning potential, there is no guarantee of immediate returns. Some graduates may face challenges securing employment in their chosen field, raising concerns about the return on their educational investment. PARA. 4 [conclusion] Zakończenie zawiera podsumowanie oraz twoją opinię lub zrównoważony osąd. Możemy też postawić pytanie retoryczne lub napisać zdanie, które prowokuje do myślenia. All in all, the decision to apply to university after graduating from high school is a complex one. It involves weighing the potential benefits of higher earning, diverse career opportunities, against the financial burden and changing dynamics of the job market. Rozprawka jest formą oficjalną, więc używaj zwrotów formalnych (form bezosobowych), pełnych form czasowników posiłkowych oraz strony biernej, np.: It is argued that … It is belived… /It is a common belief that … Nie stosuj zwrotów potocznych, form skróconych I've , I'm itp. oraz „mocnych zwrotów” tj. I am sure, I know itp. Przed rozpoczęciem sporządź listę argumentów i wybierz te, które Twoim zdaniem najlepiej pasują do tematu pracy. Pamiętaj, że argumenty "za" powinny równać się liczbą argumentom "przeciw", postaraj podać się co najmniej 2 argumenty za oraz 2 argumenty przeciw" what grade would i get? assuming i didnt know that the way it should look in
- Assistant
Okay, let's evaluate your essay on volunteering strictly based on the rules provided for the essay about higher education. It's important to remember these rules are quite specific about structure and formality, and they were intended for a different topic.
Here's a breakdown based on the rules:
-
Introduction (Para 1):
- Rule: Introduce the topic generally, without giving your own opinion. Avoid "I think," "I believe," etc.
- Your Essay: You introduce the topic ("many young people decide to work as volunteers on holidays"). However, the phrase "Spending your free time on helping the others seems to be the good way" leans towards expressing an opinion, which the rules advise against in the introduction. The last sentence is incomplete and informal ("Lets look at what your free time").
- Assessment: Doesn't fully meet the requirement for a neutral, formal introduction.
-
Arguments FOR (Para 2 in Rules):
- Rule: Present arguments FOR the issue with examples/explanations, using formal linking phrases. Needs at least two arguments.
- Your Essay: You present arguments for volunteering across paragraphs 2, 3, and 4:
- Getting experience (end of Para 2).
- Satisfaction from helping (Para 3).
- Proof of work for college applications (Para 4).
- Assessment: You have identified benefits (arguments for). However, they aren't presented in a single, clearly structured "FOR" paragraph as the example suggests. The linking phrases ("Also", "Another benefit") are simple. Paragraph 2 confusingly mixes a potential 'against' point with a 'for' point.
-
Arguments AGAINST (Para 3 in Rules):
- Rule: Present arguments AGAINST the issue with examples/explanations, using formal linking phrases. Needs at least two arguments.
- Your Essay: You introduce one main argument against volunteering: "you do not get paid" (start of Para 2). However, you immediately counter it within the same paragraph ("However there are plenty of ways you could be get rewarded in"). There isn't a dedicated paragraph outlining the disadvantages, and you only clearly state one main disadvantage.
- Assessment: Fails to meet the requirement. There isn't a distinct paragraph for 'against' arguments, and only one clear point is raised, which is then immediately softened.
-
Conclusion (Para 4 in Rules):
- Rule: Summarize, give your opinion or a balanced judgment. Use formal language.
- Your Essay: You summarize ("We can see that volunteering on holidays has both pros and cons"). You offer a balanced perspective ("It depends on you what you want to achieve..."). However, the final sentence "feel free to try" is very informal.
- Assessment: Captures the essence of summarizing and offering a balanced view, but the language ("feel free to try") is too informal.
-
Formal Style:
- Rule: Use formal language, avoid contractions (like "don't"), avoid colloquialisms, use full verb forms, use impersonal forms/passive voice where appropriate (e.g., "It is argued...").
- Your Essay: Uses contractions ("don't"). Uses informal phrasing ("Lets look", "feel free to try"). Directly addresses the reader ("You will get", "It depends on you"). Does not use impersonal structures or passive voice as suggested.
- Assessment: Fails to meet the requirement for formal style.
-
Argument Balance:
- Rule: Arguments 'for' should roughly equal arguments 'against' (at least 2 each).
- Your Essay: You present roughly 3 arguments 'for' (experience, satisfaction, college applications) but only 1 clear argument 'against' (no pay).
- Assessment: Fails to meet the requirement for balanced arguments.
Overall Assessment and Likely Grade:
If judged strictly by the provided rules (designed for a formal for-and-against essay), your essay would likely receive a low grade.
Main reasons:
- Informal Style: The use of contractions, informal phrases, and direct address ("you") goes directly against the formality requirement.
- Structural Issues: The essay doesn't follow the prescribed structure of clear, separate paragraphs for arguments 'for' and arguments 'against'. Paragraph 2 is particularly confusing as it mixes both.
- Imbalance of Arguments: There's a clear lack of developed arguments against volunteering compared to the arguments for it.
- Introduction/Conclusion Formality: The introduction hints at an opinion, and the conclusion ends informally.
Your essay does discuss pros and cons of volunteering, but it doesn't adhere to the specific format, formality, and structural requirements outlined in the rules for a Polish "rozprawka za i przeciw". It reads more like a general reflective piece than a formal academic essay following those specific guidelines.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.