Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro-exp-03-25-grounding· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Search Arena 24K

What study showed that people's happiness increases with money up to a point, then…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.0-flash-grounding’s answer.
  1. User

    What study showed that people's happiness increases with money up to a point, then plateaus?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    The most well-known study that concluded people's happiness increases with income up to a certain point and then plateaus is a 2010 paper by Nobel laureates Daniel Kahneman and Angus Deaton[1][2][3].

    Here's a breakdown of that study and subsequent research:

    1. Kahneman and Deaton (2010):

      • Finding: This influential study analyzed survey data from 450,000 Americans[2]. It distinguished between two types of well-being[1][4][7]:
        • Emotional Well-being (Happiness): Refers to the frequency and intensity of daily experiences like joy, stress, sadness, anger, and affection. This study found that emotional well-being increased with income but plateaued around an annual income of **75,000∗∗(in2010USdollars,roughly75,000** (in 2010 US dollars, roughly 108,000 today). Beyond this point, higher income didn't significantly increase day-to-day happiness[1][7][8].
        • Life Evaluation (Life Satisfaction): Refers to a person's overall assessment of their life[1]. The study found that life evaluation continued to rise steadily with income, even beyond $75,000, with no plateau observed[2][7].
      • Theory: The researchers suggested the plateau in emotional well-being occurs because incomes below $75,000 are associated with more daily challenges (stress, poor health, less leisure time) that negatively impact happiness[2]. Above that threshold, money might become less of a factor in daily mood compared to things like relationships and health.
    2. Matthew Killingsworth (2021):

      • Finding: Using a different method (real-time experience sampling via a smartphone app), this study found that both emotional well-being (happiness) and life satisfaction continued to rise steadily with income, well beyond $75,000, with no evidence of a plateau[2]. It suggested a linear relationship between happiness and log(income)[4][5].
    3. Kahneman, Killingsworth, and Mellers (2023) - Adversarial Collaboration:

      • Finding: Kahneman and Killingsworth collaborated, with Barbara Mellers as an arbiter, to reconcile their conflicting findings[2][6][7]. They re-analyzed the data and found a more nuanced picture:
        • For the majority of people (around 80-85%), happiness does continue to rise with income well beyond 75,000,consistentwithKillingsworth′sfindings[9].Forthehappiestgroup,therelationshipevenacceleratedabove75,000, consistent with Killingsworth's findings[9]. For the happiest group, the relationship even accelerated above 100,000[6].
        • However, there is an unhappy minority (around 15-20%) for whom happiness increases with income but does plateau, typically around **100,000∗∗(roughlyequivalenttotheinflation−adjusted100,000** (roughly equivalent to the inflation-adjusted 75,000 from the 2010 study)[2]. Beyond this point, more money did little to alleviate the unhappiness for this specific group, possibly due to other overriding life circumstances like bereavement or depression[8].
      • Resolution: The original 2010 study's measurement scale was better at detecting variations in unhappiness than levels of happiness, leading it to pick up on the plateau effect for the least happy individuals. Killingsworth's continuous scale captured the ongoing rise for the majority.
    4. Further Killingsworth Research (2024):

      • Looking at even higher incomes and wealth, Killingsworth found that the positive association between money and happiness continues far up the economic ladder, even comparing wealthy individuals to those earning over $500,000 per year[10].

    In summary, while the Kahneman and Deaton (2010) study is famous for identifying the $75,000 happiness plateau for emotional well-being, more recent collaborative research indicates this plateau primarily applies to the least happy segment of the population. For most people, happiness generally continues to increase with income well beyond that level, although the rate of increase might diminish (a logarithmic relationship)[5].

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.