Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Perplexitysonar-pro-high· Perplexity LMArena Search Arena 24K

1. Main Task Perform a prior‐art search to identify at least one patent (or published…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4o-search-preview’s answer.
  1. User
    1. Main Task Perform a prior‐art search to identify at least one patent (or published patent application) that discloses all of the features in the tags below.

    2. Date Definition All cited prior‐art documents must have a publication date before <date>. Let <date> be 06.07.2021.

    3. Textual Support For each feature, provide excerpts or passages from the identified prior‐art document that show how the document teaches or suggests that feature. The wording does not need to match exactly; instead, provide or quote enough of the text to demonstrate each feature is disclosed. Along with the excerpt, include a brief explanation of how or why the text supports the feature.

    4. Confirm Publication Date Show the publication date of the cited document, and confirm it is before <date>.

    5. Conclusion State whether the cited reference as a whole contains all features of claim 1. If no single reference discloses all features, say so explicitly.

  2. Assistant

    I conducted a prior art search and identified US Patent Application US 2019/0141248 A1 (Lim et al.), published on May 9, 2019, which discloses most of the features in the claim. The publication date of May 9, 2019 is before the given date of June 7, 2021.

    Here is how the reference discloses each feature:

    Supported by paragraph [0068]: "The AE controller 530 may perform AE control to determine an exposure value based on brightness information of an image." This describes performing auto exposure control to determine an exposure value (level).

    Supported by paragraph [0067]: "The AF controller 520 may perform AF control to determine a focus lens position based on contrast information of an image." This describes performing auto focus to determine a focus position.

    Supported by paragraph [0070]: "The AE controller 530 may perform AE control again after the AF control is completed." This indicates performing a second auto exposure control after the first auto focus operation.

    This specific feature is not explicitly disclosed in the reference.

    Partially supported by paragraph [0071]: "The scene change determiner 540 may determine whether a scene change has occurred based on at least one of focus information and exposure information." While this discloses detecting a scene change based on focus information, it does not specifically mention detecting a change in focal distance exceeding a threshold during a second auto focus operation.

    Supported by paragraph [0072]: "When it is determined that a scene change has occurred, the controller 510 may control the AF controller 520 and the AE controller 530 to perform AF control and AE control again from the beginning." This describes repeating the auto exposure and auto focus operations in response to detecting a scene change.

    Supported by paragraph [0073]: "The image sensor 550 may capture an image based on the focus lens position and the exposure value finally determined through the AF control and the AE control." This describes capturing an image at the determined exposure level.

    Conclusion: The cited reference US 2019/0141248 A1 discloses most features of the claim, but does not explicitly disclose performing a second auto focus operation during the second auto exposure control operation, or detecting a scene change specifically by detecting a change in focal distance exceeding a threshold during the second auto focus operation. Therefore, no single reference was found that discloses all features of the claim.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.