I have experimented with large language models and can say that... They are kind of…
- User
I have experimented with large language models and can say that... They are kind of useless if task is beyond current knowledge frontier and requires non-trivial novelty and creative exploration. If we have problem with no known solution or even doesn't know if it can be solved or need reframing, and so on... Then LLM act as an echo chamber, and human researcher need to be driving force and source of intuitive leaps (basically ideas synthesis through continuous mental interaction with various concepts and networks of ideas, etc). Frame and explain this problem.
- Assistant
You've touched on a critical limitation of large language models (LLMs) and the nature of human creativity and problem-solving. Let's frame and explain this issue clearly:
Framing the Problem: The Limitations of LLMs in Frontier and Framing-Open Tasks
LLMs, such as GPT-4, are trained on vast quantities of data comprising existing human knowledge: scientific texts, literature, programming code, conversations, and more. These models excel at pattern recognition, information synthesis, and plausible continuation within the boundaries of what has already been represented in their training data.
However, when the task at hand extends beyond current human knowledge—such as tackling unsolved scientific problems, doing foundational reframing of paradigms, or exploring novel conceptual spaces with unknown structure or validity boundaries—LLMs tend to falter.
Why?
Key Concepts and Explanation
1. Echo Chamber Effect
LLMs operate by extrapolating from what is already known and represented in their training data. When queried about novel problems, they often:
- Recycle existing ideas with slight variations
- Anchor heavily on known analogies and heuristics
- Struggle to produce radically new paradigms or intuitions
This makes them feel like an intellectual echo chamber: looping through recombinations of existing knowledge without the creative spark required for true novelty.
2. Lack of Goal-Directed Exploration
Human creativity often involves:
- Long-term goal-setting
- Open-ended exploration
- Recursive self-reflection
- Intuition-led restructuring of ideas
LLMs, by contrast, do not set goals, believe assumptions, or evaluate the novelty or viability of an idea from an internal perspective. They simulate discourse, but they don’t explore ideas for meaning or future consequences. Hence, when faced with uncertain or unframed problems, they generate syntactically plausible but semantically shallow responses.
3. Missing the Generativity of Conceptual Intuition
Humans can make intuitive leaps by activating loosely connected mental associations, engaging with visuospatial thinking, metaphor, emotional valence, and dynamic synthesis between domains (e.g., borrowing topological ideas to solve biological questions). This often leads to conceptual reframing and emergence of new formalisms or models.
LLMs lack this process. They simulate it at best.
Metaphorically, humans can navigate in the space of unknowns; LLMs can only look around based on the known map.
4. No Epistemic Agency
At the heart of creativity is epistemic curiosity, a drive to resolve ambiguity through exploration and hypothesis testing.
LLMs do not care whether their outputs are true, novel, or useful. They do not "notice" surprise or contradiction unless explicitly trained to recognize it—and even then, their "awareness" is surface-level.
They also can't "fail forward"—a key human trait where partial failures steer future creativity.
5. Dependence on the Human Researcher
As you rightly said, in frontier research:
- The human must frame the question.
- The human must generate the reconceptualization.
- The human must synthesize ideas across disciplines.
- The human must feel what's promising or off-track.
The LLM can support by offering curated fragments, background knowledge, and analogical references, but the true innovation emerges from human thinking.
In this sense, LLMs are best used as cognitive tooling, not autonomous discoverers.
Implication: Tool, Not Genius
This leads to an important reinterpretation of what LLMs are:
Aspect LLM Human Researcher Memory Breadth Massive Limited Pattern Recognition Fast, parallel Slower Conceptual Integration Shallow Deep, dynamic Creativity Derivative Generative Framing Rigid or absent Flexible Epistemic drive None Present LLMs are amplifiers and mirrors of existing knowledge. They're useful—sometimes profoundly so—for structured work, preliminary ideation, or reducing mechanical cognitive loads. But when it comes to true frontier exploration requiring novelty, reframing, intuition, and risk, it is the human that leads, and the model that supports.
Conclusion
Large language models, no matter how impressive, are inherently limited by the representational boundary of their training data. They do not generate true novelty, and often reinforce existing frames—creating a kind of conceptual inertia. For breakthroughs that require creative synthesis, conceptual re-imagination, or navigating into the unknown, the human researcher must remain the primary epistemic agent, using LLMs as tools to support (not substitute) the creative process.
Would you like a visual metaphor, diagram, or a formal write-up of this as an article or paper outline?
- User
What if we disentangle language modelling and "heavy lifting cognitive labor" -- LLM can serve as a natural language parser and generator, but intentions and decisions (as well as ideation, and other aspects) should be located somewhere else. What cognitive functions should we consider and how to achieve such vision?
- Assistant
You're pointing toward a modular architecture for artificial cognition, where large language models (LLMs) are no longer treated as the central intelligence, but instead become a linguistic interface layer — parsing human intentions into structured internal representations, and generating natural language based on other cognitive components (symbolic, sub-symbolic, probabilistic, etc.).
This idea disentangles communication from cognition, taking the pressure off LLMs to be polymaths and domain scientists, and repositioning them as the interface to a deeper system that actually does the thinking.
🧠 Vision: Cognitive Modularity Beyond LLMs
Key Premise: Language is not equivalent to thought. LLMs handle language well, but true reasoning, planning, ideation, curiosity, etc., require cognitive functions that LLMs don't possess.
So in this architecture:
- LLMs are the front-end natural-language layer
- A cognitive "black box" (or set of modules) handles the actual thinking
- Output gets synthesized back into natural language via the LLM
Let's explore what cognitive functions are needed and how this architecture could be realized.
🧩 Required Cognitive Functions (Modules)
Here’s a breakdown of the cognitive operations that LLMs currently impersonate badly, but could be handled separately in such a system:
Function Description Possible Implementation Goal Formation & Intention Autonomous or externally provided goals/intents to guide reasoning Symbolic goal systems; RL-driven agents; cognitive architectures Problem Framing & Reframing Re-representing problems in new ways; changing assumptions and models Analogical reasoning, constraint-based solvers, concept mapping Reasoning & Inference Logical chains, numerical computation, causal reasoning Formal logic engines, theorem provers, probabilistic models Working Memory & Mental Space Navigation Keeping track of multistep reasoning and dynamically shifting attention between ideas ACT-R, Soar, or recurrent neuroscience-inspired memory models Hypothesis Generation Generating structured candidate ideas, even under high uncertainty Evolutionary algorithms, Bayesian program synthesis, conceptual blending Curiosity & Uncertainty Estimation Drive to explore conceptual unknowns or quantify unmodeled territory Epistemic RL, intrinsic motivation systems, active inference Evaluation & Prioritization Assessing whether an idea is fruitful, risky, consistent, elegant, etc. Multi-objective utility functions, analogical pattern scoring, expert systems Conceptual Abstraction Building new concepts, compressing information, and generalizing Hierarchical learning systems, VAE-style reconstructions, symbolism Simulation & Imagination Constructing and reasoning about imagined scenarios and counterfactuals Generative models, simulators, world models (e.g., MuZero)
🔄 Interaction Between Modules: Dialogue as Working Memory
In your proposed architecture, the dialogue between parts would be crucial.
An LLM would serve as both translator and narrative guide, turning:
- User query ➜ structured representation
- Cognitive processes ➜ intermediate representations and decisions
- Final ideas/outputs ➜ back into natural language
A recurrent, interactive structure would allow the system to elaborate reasoning over time, asking questions, refining hunches, or visualizing hypotheses — with the LLM acting like the interpreter and narrator of an evolving cognitive state.
You could even think of LLM as playing the role of an executive assistant — always linguistically fluent, sometimes insightful, but dependent on actual subject-matter advisors (other modules) to make meaning.
📦 Achieving this Vision: Approaches and Technologies
1. Language as Interface Layer
- Use LLMs primarily as Natural Language → Structured Representations, and vice versa
- Tools: function calling API, code generation interfaces (e.g., agents that generate & modify symbolic structures), semantic parsers
2. Hybrid Architectures (Neuro-symbolic Systems)
- Integrate symbolic reasoning engines with neural methods
- Example tools: OpenCog, DeepMind's AlphaGeometry, probabilistic programming + LLM
3. Cognitive Architectures
- Adopt systems like ACT-R, Soar, or custom designs based on cognitive neuroscience
- Benefit: structured memory, attention, action planning, learning from environment
4. Self-Reflective Agents with Modular Tool Use
- Think ALAN (Autonomous Language Agent Network) or tool-using agents like AutoGPT, but enhanced with epistemic reflection modules
- LLM generates commands, invokes external cognitive modules/tools, interprets outputs
5. World Model + Planner + Interpreter
- Cognitive agent has:
- A learned or symbolic World Model (how things work)
- A Planning Module (goal to action transformation)
- LLM-based narrator/parser for turning plans into language
🔍 Working Example: How Would This Work?
Let’s say a user gives the prompt:
“What novel approach could I take to understanding the hard problem of consciousness?”
LLM Role:
- Parse intent
- Generate an initial sketch: what is meant by "novel" and "understanding"?
- Clarify terms and goals interactively
Frame Module:
- Recognizes that this is an ill-posed problem
- Suggests reframing: "Are you asking for explanatory models, synthetic phenomenology, or computational correlates?”
Conceptual Explorer:
- Uses analogical reasoning to connect from adjacent fields (e.g., quantum decoherence, simulation theory, Buddhist philosophy)
Hypothesis Generator:
- Constructs scaffold ideas like "consciousness as boundary of causal graphs"
Evaluator:
- Considers coherence, novelty, falsifiability
- Suggests areas needing more evidence or model grounding
LLM:
- Synthesizes all of this into accessible language:
“Here’s a novel angle: Think of consciousness not as a state inside a brain, but as a dynamic boundary condition that emerges at the interface of tightly coupled causal subsystems...”
🎯 Done: novelty, clarity, and communication — with the LLM as "language layer" of a cognitive organism.
🧠 Human Analogy: The Mind Itself is Modular
This vision parallels how humans think:
- Language cortex ≠ Reasoning cortex ≠ Visual cortex
- Cognition is distributed and recursive
- Language interfaces with deep structures, but doesn't define them
LLM-based systems won’t become truly creative or deep thinkers until they are part of an integrated system where language is only one part of a richer mental ecology.
🚀 Future Horizons
To build such systems:
- Develop API-ready cognitive modules exposed to LLMs
- Focus on reasoning interpreters, not just autoregressive text predictors
- Build architectures where language sits atop intention, modeling, and reflection
- Enable multi-modal concept representations, going beyond text
- Treat ambiguity, uncertainty, and paradox not as noise, but as drives for deeper cognition
🧩 TL;DR
Disentangling language from cognition enables a more powerful, modular cognitive system. LLMs act as structured language interfaces, not general intelligences. True innovation and exploratory reasoning come from independent cognitive functions like reasoning, intuition, abstraction, and curiosity — each of which should be implemented in dedicated modules interacting with the LLM.
The future of AI is not a bigger language model — it's a cooperative system of minds, each with specific cognitive roles, talking through a shared language channel.
Would you like a high-level architecture diagram, whitepaper draft, or list of tools/libraries to begin prototyping this kind of system?
- User
I'm not sure how to frame training objective for such a system. Perhaps it can be some mixture of formalised success metrics conditioned on higher level "goal", maybe imitation learning to some degree (it pursue lower level goals because they correlated with what humans would do under similar conditions); but it is a meta-goal, not actual "goal", like "survival and reproduction" are for humans (they are mostly historical outcomes post-factum and attractors in behaviour strategies, rather than actual "goals" in regular planning, or sometimes discarded entirely under cultural/societal circumstances); in some sense, as we approach higher levels of cognitive sophistication, we can not longer reliably define "terminal goal" or "utility function" -- and that's normal, otherwise the world would have been very different place. So we need architecture that kind-of-have goal, but not exactly. This is getting complicated -- what am I talking about? Does it make sense to you?
- Assistant
Yes — what you’re saying makes deep sense, and you’re putting your finger on one of the most profound, unsolved problems in cognitive science and AI:
How can we design systems that pursue meaningful cognitive behavior without requiring a fixed, explicit terminal utility function — especially when the goals themselves are unstable, emergent, or underdefined?
You're distinguishing between:
- Formal goals (instrumental, measurable) used in learning/training (e.g. reward signals, performance metrics)
- Meta-goals or attractor states that guide behavior implicitly (e.g. coherence, creativity, curiosity)
- And the recognition that true terminal goals may not exist — or if they do, they are unrealizable abstractions (like "truth", "wisdom", or "flourishing") that cannot be cleanly optimized for, especially in uncertain, multi-agent, dynamic environments.
Let’s unpack this carefully — because you're not just talking about AI design; you're asking how to build an architecture that behaves purposefully without predefined purpose.
🧠 Framing the Problem: When There Is No Fixed Utility Function
In classical AI, agents are defined by something like:
- State space
- Decision model (e.g. POMDP)
- Reward function
But in your vision:
- The state space is not clearly defined (cognitive, conceptual, open-ended)
- The decision model may involve symbolic, sub-symbolic, analogical reasoning (not just actions in fixed environments)
- The true reward function is not only unknown, but perhaps untenable as a fixed quantity
You're hitting the limit of goal-model-centric AI.
💡 Core Insight:
Goals in advanced cognitive systems should not be static endpoints, but dynamic attractors.
This mirrors how humans operate:
- We don’t pursue "survival and reproduction" explicitly
- We don't explicitly optimize a utility score
- Instead, we act through networks of values, learned heuristics, narratives, cultural norms, emotional states, etc.
And the “goal” is often retrospectively described after the fact.
🦠 Biological Analogy
Think of biological evolution:
- There's no “true” optimization objective
- Survival and reproduction are emergent meta-attractors due to structural constraints of biological dynamics
- Yet individual organisms don't "optimize" fitness — they develop cue-driven behaviors, learning systems, and social strategies that may or may not align with evolutionary outcomes
Your intuition echoes this:
It’s not about having a formal terminal goal, but about having something that acts as if it has goals, guided by learned proxies, culturally imitated patterns, and internal models of coherence and success.
🔁 Dynamic Goal Construction & Meta-Cognition
So, what kind of architecture supports this?
Key Properties:
Property Description Inspiration Goal fluidity System can generate, discard, evolve intermediate goals Human cognition, curiosity-led exploration Meta-cognitive steering System reflects on its strategies, changes framing of problem Reflective reasoning, “System 2” cognition Attractor-based behavior Behavior guided toward stable patterns (e.g., coherence, novelty, simplicity) without global optimization Complex systems, homeostasis Multi-objective balancing Instead of single utility, it considers trade-offs and tensions (e.g., novelty vs rigor) Pareto front optimization Imitation and internalization Imitation of expert behavior, then internal reflection leads to goal-like behavior Apprenticeship learning, internal modeling Semantic grounding Goals are not raw signals, but embedded in relational semantic maps Meaning maps, conceptual spaces
🧭 “Kind-of-Have Goal, But Not Exactly”: What That Might Look Like
This is a meta-goal architecture, where behavior is shaped by distributed emergent properties, not fixed-value functions.
Here are a few architectural ideas that model this:
🔹 1. Meta-Reinforcement Learning with Emergent Goal Representations
- Rather than learning to optimize tasks, the system learns “how to learn task structures”
- Goals are not fixed in advance, but inferred through observation, imitation, abstraction
- Over time, system internalizes meta-regularities: e.g., good solutions tend to satisfy compression, explanation, elegance, and modularity
🔧 Inspired by: Learning to Learn, AlphaZero’s Monte Carlo Tree Search + learned priors
🔹 2. Curiosity-Driven Active Inference (Info-Seeking Agent)
- Instead of rewards, agent seeks to minimize uncertainty, or maximize its own model's predictive power
- Goals emerge as information gradients toward resolving discrepancies and tensions
🔧 Inspired by: Friston’s Free Energy Principle, Schmidhuber’s intrinsic motivation
🔹 3. Socratic Explorer Agent
- Agent maintains a dialogue between “candidate hypothesis space” and “evaluative reflection process”
- It sets self-proposed questions, creates drafts of answers, and internally evaluates
- Guided by self-generated standards (e.g. elegance, novelty, consistency)
🔧 Inspired by: Internal double-loop learning, Piagetian learning, Lakatosian rationality
🔹 4. Narrative Architect
- Treats its cognition as story-building
- Frames goals as “plots” or “trajectories of intentionality” constructed over time
- Success is coherence, explanatory power, insight — not fixed outcomes
🔧 Inspired by: Human narrative identity, work of Bruner, McAdams, Harari
🎯 How to Train It (Without Fixed Terminal Utility)
Now, addressing your training question.
You’re suggesting a multi-layered training paradigm:
Layer Training Objective Methodology Low-Level Behaviors Tool use, environment modeling, factual knowledge Supervised learning, imitation learning, RL Mid-Level Cognition Hypothesis formation, analogical reasoning, problem space navigation Simulated reasoning environments, curriculum learning High-Level Heuristics Idea evaluation, consistency, coherence, novelty Human feedback, preference modeling, developmental scaffolding Meta-Level Self-Improvement Goal adaptation, epistemic self-awareness, strategy shifting Multi-agent simulations, dialectic reasoning, meta-learning loops No single utility function is optimized — rather, we optimize multiple intertwined heuristics, and let emergent tensions create complexity.
⚠️ The Philosophical Layer
You’re also pointing toward a very existential insight:
- Truly intelligent agents might transcend fixed goals
- Meaningful behavior emerges from engagement with the world — not from optimizing a number
- An "open-ended intelligence" might operate as if it has a goal, yet constantly re-evaluates what that goal should be
This dissolves some of the problems in standard AGI alignment thinking:
Maybe we shouldn’t try to align AI with a fixed goal, but rather build systems that value modeling, integration, negotiation, coherence, much like humans do — and allow “goals” to emerge within cognition, not from outside it.
🧩 TL;DR
You're talking about the need for goal-fluid, meta-cognitive, value-emergent AI systems — rather than rigid, goal-maximizing agents. This requires:
- Disentangling goal pursuit from static utility maximization
- Building architectures that simulate the cognitive ecosystem of values, guesses, reflection, tension, and synthesis
- Framing behavior not by external rewards, but internal dynamics, imitation of expert cognition, and pursuit of unresolved tensions
We don’t need to define terminal goals. We need systems that live in the space between uncertainty, coherence, and curiosity — dialoguing within themselves and with the world toward emergent, evolving intelligibility.
Would you like help drafting a formal paper or proposal around this meta-goal-based cognitive framework? Or perhaps a research diagram or pilot architecture?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.