My sister gets really controlling sometimes and just got angry at me for having a tiny…
- User
My sister gets really controlling sometimes and just got angry at me for having a tiny snack before lunch. She's roasting a chicken but I'm visiting from a different time zone and used to eating earlier than this, and lunch was later than we expected. I took a small tin of mackerel and put it on 2 small slices of bread. She tried to tell me to eat a small pot of yogurt instead because mackerel contains too much oil and will have too many calories and make me full. I know myself - it really won't make me full. I just finished eating it and I'm still hungry. She's still angry at me. AITA??
- Assistant
It sounds like your sister’s reaction was a bit over the top, especially since you were just trying to manage your hunger in a way that works for you. You’re visiting from a different time zone, so your eating schedule is naturally different, and having a small snack before lunch is totally reasonable.
Your sister’s concerns about oil and calories might come from a place of wanting you to eat “healthier” or to save room for the main meal, but ultimately, you know your own body best. If the mackerel snack didn’t make you full and you’re still hungry, that’s valid. It’s also important for family members to respect each other’s needs and choices, especially when it comes to something as personal as food.
So, NTA here. You’re not wrong for eating a small snack that suits your needs, and your sister’s anger seems disproportionate. It might help to have a calm conversation later about respecting each other’s eating habits and being more understanding of your different schedules.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.