I analyzed a simple call with fprof: fprof:trace(start), dnftyvariable:any(),…
- User
I analyzed a simple call with fprof:
fprof:trace(start), dnf_ty_variable:any(), fprof:trace(stop), fprof:profile(), fprof:analyse(),
This is the result. What are the bottlenecks?
%% Analysis results: { analysis_options, [{callers, true}, {sort, acc}, {totals, false}, {details, true}]}.
% CNT ACC OWN
[{ totals, 311, 21.179, 7.253}]. %%%% CNT ACC OWN
[{ "<0.405.0>", 311,undefined, 7.253}]. %%{[{{debug_tests,slow_test,0}, 0, 21.118, 0.008},
{undefined, 0, 0.030, 0.021},
{{fprof,call,1}, 1, 0.013, 0.010}],
{ {fprof,just_call,2}, 1, 21.161, 0.039}, % [{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 21.110, 0.015},
{{erlang,demonitor,1}, 1, 0.009, 0.009},
{{erlang,monitor,2}, 1, 0.003, 0.003},
{suspend, 1, 0.000, 0.000}]}.{[{undefined, 0, 21.149, 0.003}],
{ {debug_tests,slow_test,0}, 0, 21.149, 0.003}, % [{{fprof,just_call,2}, 0, 21.118, 0.008},
{{fprof,trace,1}, 1, 0.028, 0.004}]}.{[{{fprof,just_call,2}, 1, 21.110, 0.015},
{{ty_tuples,any,0}, 1, 0.000, 0.012},
{{ty_rec,'-any/0-fun-0-',2}, 6, 0.000, 0.065},
{{ty_functions,any,0}, 1, 0.000, 0.011},
{{dnf_ty_variable,any,0}, 1, 0.000, 0.012},
{{dnf_ty_list,any,0}, 1, 0.000, 0.013}],
{ {error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 11, 21.110, 0.128}, % [{{error_handler,ensure_loaded,1}, 11, 20.666, 0.086},
{{dnf_ty_variable,any,0}, 1, 18.435, 0.007},
{{ty_rec,any,0}, 1, 16.288, 0.004},
{{ty_tuples,any,0}, 1, 2.033, 0.006},
{{ty_functions,any,0}, 1, 1.991, 0.007},
{{dnf_ty_list,any,0}, 1, 1.517, 0.006},
{{erlang,function_exported,3}, 11, 0.032, 0.032},
{{dnf_ty_tuple,any,0}, 1, 0.008, 0.005},
{{dnf_ty_function,any,0}, 1, 0.008, 0.005},
{{ty_bool,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003},
{{dnf_ty_predefined,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003},
{{dnf_ty_interval,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003},
{{dnf_ty_atom,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 11, 20.666, 0.086}],
{ {error_handler,ensure_loaded,1}, 11, 20.666, 0.086}, % [{{code,ensure_loaded,1}, 11, 20.544, 0.197},
{{erlang,whereis,1}, 11, 0.036, 0.036}]}.{[{{error_handler,ensure_loaded,1}, 11, 20.544, 0.197}],
{ {code,ensure_loaded,1}, 11, 20.544, 0.197}, % [{{code,call,1}, 22, 14.595, 0.081},
{{code,ensure_prepare_loading,3}, 11, 5.575, 0.043},
{{code,get_mode,0}, 11, 0.145, 0.044},
{{erlang,module_loaded,1}, 11, 0.032, 0.032}]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 18.435, 0.007}],
{ {dnf_ty_variable,any,0}, 1, 18.435, 0.007}, % [{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.000, 0.012}]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 16.288, 0.004}],
{ {ty_rec,any,0}, 1, 16.288, 0.004}, % [{{ty_rec,map,2}, 1, 16.284, 0.010}]}.{[{{ty_rec,any,0}, 1, 16.284, 0.010}],
{ {ty_rec,map,2}, 1, 16.284, 0.010}, % [{{lists,foldl,3}, 1, 16.225, 0.008},
{{lists,zip,2}, 1, 0.036, 0.004},
{{lists,seq,2}, 1, 0.013, 0.003}]}.{[{{ty_rec,map,2}, 1, 16.225, 0.008}],
{ {lists,foldl,3}, 1, 16.225, 0.008}, % [{{lists,foldl_1,3}, 1, 14.660, 0.008},
{{ty_rec,'-map/2-fun-0-',4}, 1, 1.557, 0.011}]}.{[{{lists,foldl_1,3}, 5, 14.619, 0.046},
{{lists,foldl,3}, 1, 1.557, 0.011}],
{ {ty_rec,'-map/2-fun-0-',4}, 6, 16.176, 0.057}, % [{{ty_rec,'-any/0-fun-0-',2}, 6, 16.089, 0.031},
{{erlang,setelement,3}, 6, 0.030, 0.030}]}.{[{{ty_rec,'-map/2-fun-0-',4}, 6, 16.089, 0.031}],
{ {ty_rec,'-any/0-fun-0-',2}, 6, 16.089, 0.031}, % [{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 6, 0.000, 0.065}]}.{[{{lists,foldl,3}, 1, 14.660, 0.008},
{{lists,foldl_1,3}, 5, 0.000, 0.033}],
{ {lists,foldl_1,3}, 6, 14.660, 0.041}, % [{{ty_rec,'-map/2-fun-0-',4}, 5, 14.619, 0.046},
{{lists,foldl_1,3}, 5, 0.000, 0.033}]}.{[{{code,ensure_loaded,1}, 22, 14.595, 0.081}],
{ {code,call,1}, 22, 14.595, 0.081}, % [{{code_server,call,1}, 22, 14.514, 0.397}]}.{[{{code,call,1}, 22, 14.514, 0.397}],
{ {code_server,call,1}, 22, 14.514, 0.397}, % [{suspend, 22, 13.926, 0.000},
{{erlang,monitor,2}, 22, 0.096, 0.096},
{{erlang,demonitor,2}, 22, 0.095, 0.095}]}.{[{{code_server,call,1}, 22, 13.926, 0.000},
{{fprof,just_call,2}, 1, 0.000, 0.000}],
{ suspend, 23, 13.926, 0.000}, % [ ]}.{[{{code,ensure_loaded,1}, 11, 5.575, 0.043}],
{ {code,ensure_prepare_loading,3}, 11, 5.575, 0.043}, % [{{erlang,prepare_loading,2}, 11, 5.532, 0.048}]}.{[{{code,ensure_prepare_loading,3}, 11, 5.532, 0.048}],
{ {erlang,prepare_loading,2}, 11, 5.532, 0.048}, % [{{erlang,prepare_loading_1,2}, 11, 5.484, 0.091}]}.{[{{erlang,prepare_loading,2}, 11, 5.484, 0.091}],
{ {erlang,prepare_loading_1,2}, 11, 5.484, 0.091}, % [{{erts_internal,prepare_loading,2}, 11, 5.393, 5.393}]}.{[{{erlang,prepare_loading_1,2}, 11, 5.393, 5.393}],
{ {erts_internal,prepare_loading,2}, 11, 5.393, 5.393}, % [ ]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 2.033, 0.006}],
{ {ty_tuples,any,0}, 1, 2.033, 0.006}, % [{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.000, 0.012}]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 1.991, 0.007}],
{ {ty_functions,any,0}, 1, 1.991, 0.007}, % [{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.000, 0.011}]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 1.517, 0.006}],
{ {dnf_ty_list,any,0}, 1, 1.517, 0.006}, % [{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.000, 0.013}]}.{[{{code,ensure_loaded,1}, 11, 0.145, 0.044}],
{ {code,get_mode,0}, 11, 0.145, 0.044}, % [{{code_server,get_mode,0}, 11, 0.101, 0.065}]}.{[{{code,get_mode,0}, 11, 0.101, 0.065}],
{ {code_server,get_mode,0}, 11, 0.101, 0.065}, % [{{persistent_term,get,1}, 11, 0.036, 0.036}]}.{[{{code_server,call,1}, 22, 0.096, 0.096},
{{fprof,just_call,2}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}],
{ {erlang,monitor,2}, 23, 0.099, 0.099}, % [ ]}.{[{{code_server,call,1}, 22, 0.095, 0.095}],
{ {erlang,demonitor,2}, 22, 0.095, 0.095}, % [ ]}.{[{{error_handler,ensure_loaded,1}, 11, 0.036, 0.036},
{{fprof,call,1}, 1, 0.004, 0.004}],
{ {erlang,whereis,1}, 12, 0.040, 0.040}, % [ ]}.{[{{code_server,get_mode,0}, 11, 0.036, 0.036}],
{ {persistent_term,get,1}, 11, 0.036, 0.036}, % [ ]}.{[{{ty_rec,map,2}, 1, 0.036, 0.004}],
{ {lists,zip,2}, 1, 0.036, 0.004}, % [{{lists,zip,3}, 1, 0.032, 0.009}]}.{[{{lists,zip,2}, 1, 0.032, 0.009},
{{lists,zip,3}, 6, 0.000, 0.023}],
{ {lists,zip,3}, 7, 0.032, 0.032}, % [{{lists,zip,3}, 6, 0.000, 0.023}]}.{[{{code,ensure_loaded,1}, 11, 0.032, 0.032}],
{ {erlang,module_loaded,1}, 11, 0.032, 0.032}, % [ ]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 11, 0.032, 0.032}],
{ {erlang,function_exported,3}, 11, 0.032, 0.032}, % [ ]}.{[{{ty_rec,'-map/2-fun-0-',4}, 6, 0.030, 0.030}],
{ {erlang,setelement,3}, 6, 0.030, 0.030}, % [ ]}.{[{{debug_tests,slow_test,0}, 1, 0.028, 0.004}],
{ {fprof,trace,1}, 1, 0.028, 0.004}, % [{{fprof,call,1}, 1, 0.024, 0.007}]}.{[{{fprof,trace,1}, 1, 0.024, 0.007}],
{ {fprof,call,1}, 1, 0.024, 0.007}, % [{{fprof,just_call,2}, 1, 0.013, 0.010},
{{erlang,whereis,1}, 1, 0.004, 0.004}]}.{[{{ty_rec,map,2}, 1, 0.013, 0.003}],
{ {lists,seq,2}, 1, 0.013, 0.003}, % [{{lists,seq_loop,3}, 1, 0.010, 0.004}]}.{[{{lists,seq,2}, 1, 0.010, 0.004},
{{lists,seq_loop,3}, 2, 0.000, 0.006}],
{ {lists,seq_loop,3}, 3, 0.010, 0.010}, % [{{lists,seq_loop,3}, 2, 0.000, 0.006}]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.003, 0.003},
{{dnf_ty_tuple,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003},
{{dnf_ty_function,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}],
{ {ty_bool,any,0}, 3, 0.009, 0.009}, % [ ]}.{[{{fprof,just_call,2}, 1, 0.009, 0.009}],
{ {erlang,demonitor,1}, 1, 0.009, 0.009}, % [ ]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.008, 0.005}],
{ {dnf_ty_tuple,any,0}, 1, 0.008, 0.005}, % [{{ty_bool,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.008, 0.005}],
{ {dnf_ty_function,any,0}, 1, 0.008, 0.005}, % [{{ty_bool,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}],
{ {dnf_ty_predefined,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}, % [ ]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}],
{ {dnf_ty_interval,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}, % [ ]}.{[{{error_handler,undefined_function,3}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}],
{ {dnf_ty_atom,any,0}, 1, 0.003, 0.003}, % [ ]}.{[ ], { undefined, 0, 0.000, 0.000}, % [{{debug_tests,slow_test,0}, 0, 21.149, 0.003},
{{fprof,just_call,2}, 0, 0.030, 0.021}]}. Assistant
Based on the fprof analysis, the primary bottlenecks are code loading and error handling overhead caused by the call to
dnf_ty_variable:any(). Here's a breakdown of the key issues:
1. Error Handling for Undefined Functions
- Key Functions Involved:
{error_handler, undefined_function, 3}(11 calls, ACC = 21.110){error_handler, ensure_loaded, 1}(11 calls, ACC = 20.666)
- What's Happening:
- The system repeatedly checks if the module containing
dnf_ty_variable:any()is loaded. - If the module is not found, it triggers error handling (e.g.,
undefined_functionchecks), which is expensive. - This suggests the module might not be properly compiled or available in the code path.
- The system repeatedly checks if the module containing
2. Code Loading Overhead
- Key Functions Involved:
{code, ensure_loaded, 1}(11 calls, ACC = 20.544){code, ensure_prepare_loading, 3}(11 calls, ACC = 5.575){erts_internal, prepare_loading, 2}(11 calls, ACC = 5.393)
- What's Happening:
- The system attempts to load the module multiple times, which involves checking for dependencies, preparing the module, and handling errors.
- This is likely due to the module not being preloaded or being missing from the code path.
3. List and Data Structure Processing
- Key Functions Involved:
{lists,foldl,3}(ACC = 14.660){ty_rec,map,2}(ACC = 16.284){ty_rec,'-map/2-fun-0-',4}(ACC = 16.089)
- What's Happening:
- These functions are part of the internal logic of
dnf_ty_variable:any()(or its dependencies). - While their individual ACC values are lower than the error/loading overhead, they contribute to the total runtime.
- These functions are part of the internal logic of
4. Process Monitoring and Synchronization
- Key Functions Involved:
{erlang, monitor, 2}(22 calls, ACC = 0.096){erlang, demonitor, 2}(22 calls, ACC = 0.095)
- What's Happening:
- The system uses process monitoring (e.g.,
monitor/2) for code loading or error handling, which adds overhead.
- The system uses process monitoring (e.g.,
Root Cause
The primary bottleneck is the system attempting to load a module that is either missing or not properly compiled, triggering repeated error checks and code-loading operations. The actual
dnf_ty_variable:any()function itself appears to be lightweight (ACC = 0.000), but the surrounding infrastructure (error handling, code loading) is the real performance drag.
Recommendations
- Ensure the Module is Preloaded:
- Compile and load the
dnf_ty_variablemodule explicitly before callingany(). - Use
code:ensure_loaded/1orerlang:load_module/2if necessary.
- Compile and load the
- Check for Module Availability:
- Verify that the module is in the Erlang code path (
CODEPATH).
- Verify that the module is in the Erlang code path (
- Optimize Error Handling:
- If the function is expected to fail, handle errors explicitly rather than relying on the system's default error handling.
- Profile the Module:
- Run fprof on the
dnf_ty_variablemodule directly to isolate its internal logic (e.g.,lists:foldingorty_rec:map).
- Run fprof on the
Summary of Bottlenecks
Category Function Calls ACC Notes Error Handling error_handler:undefined_function/311 21.110 Repeated checks for missing module Code Loading code:ensure_loaded/111 20.544 Module loading overhead Internal Logic lists:foldl/31 14.660 Data structure processing Process Monitoring erlang:monitor/222 0.096 Synchronization overhead The error handling and code loading are the dominant performance issues here. Addressing these will likely resolve the bottlenecks.
- Key Functions Involved:
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.