Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Amazon Novaamazon-nova-experimental-chat-05-14· AmazonHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

you are an expert security analyst, find this company's instrinsic value…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-sonnet-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    you are an expert security analyst, find this company's instrinsic value

    BreakdownTTM12/31/202412/31/202312/31/202212/31/2021

    Total Revenue 415,777,000 424,232,000 439,337,000 234,121,000 354,727,000 Total Premiums Earned 88,587,000 88,257,000 83,403,000 74,576,000 69,460,000 Net Investment Income 38,540,000 49,297,000 69,144,000 -63,120,000 77,341,000 Net Realized Gain Loss on Investments 5,948,000 3,502,000 5,711,000 -4,779,000 1,201,000 Interest Income 23,119,000 21,825,000 15,764,000 10,263,000 7,465,000

    Fee Revenue & Other Income 259,583,000 261,351,000 265,315,000 217,181,000 199,260,000 Fees And Commissions 204,979,000 207,251,000 211,876,000 162,842,000 151,204,000 Other Income Expense 54,604,000 54,100,000 53,439,000 54,339,000 48,056,000

    Total Expenses 315,959,000 313,856,000 319,171,000 264,621,000 242,866,000

    Loss Adjustment Expense 61,365,000 60,044,000 61,216,000 62,889,000 55,788,000 Net Policyholder Benefits And Claims 61,365,000 60,044,000 61,216,000 62,889,000 55,788,000 Underwriting Expenses 17,423,000 16,808,000 15,270,000 11,706,000 12,559,000 Fees & Commission Expense 161,401,000 163,642,000 169,281,000 124,319,000 114,138,000

    Selling General and Administrative 35,047,000 32,711,000 31,495,000 25,056,000 23,044,000

    General & Administrative Expense 35,047,000 32,711,000 31,495,000 25,056,000 23,044,000 Other G and A 35,047,000 32,711,000 31,495,000 25,056,000 23,044,000 Selling & Marketing Expense

    25,642,000 25,458,000 19,506,000 18,843,000

    Net Non Operating Interest Income Expense -5,141,000 -5,200,000 -5,003,000 -4,352,000 -4,172,000 Interest Expense Non Operating 5,141,000 5,200,000 5,003,000 4,352,000 4,172,000 Income from Associates & Other Participating Interests 1,474,000 1,841,000 1,973,000 1,863,000 886,000

    Special Income Charges

    --

    0 0 Impairment of Capital Assets

    --

    0 0 Other Operating Expenses 37,056,000 37,292,000 38,879,000 38,162,000 34,051,000 Pretax Income 99,818,000 110,376,000 120,166,000 -30,500,000 111,861,000 Tax Provision 18,417,000 20,815,000 23,019,000 -8,502,000 20,912,000

    Net Income Common Stockholders 80,896,000 88,995,000 96,223,000 -22,759,000 89,937,000

    Net Income 80,896,000 88,995,000 96,223,000 -22,759,000 89,937,000

    Net Income Including Non-Controlling Interests 81,401,000 89,561,000 97,147,000 -21,998,000 90,949,000 Net Income Continuous Operations 81,401,000 89,561,000 97,147,000 -21,998,000 90,949,000 Minority Interests -505,000 -566,000 -924,000 -761,000 -1,012,000 Diluted NI Available to Com Stockholders 80,896,000 88,995,000 96,223,000 -22,759,000 89,937,000 Basic EPS 56.27k 61.90k 66.41k -15.49k 59.55k Diluted EPS 56.27k 61.90k 66.41k -15.49k 59.55k Basic Average Shares 1,437.43 1,437.72 1,448.88 1,468.88 1,510.18 Diluted Average Shares 1,438.22 1,437.72 1,448.88 1,468.88 1,510.18 Net Income from Continuing & Discontinued Operation 80,896,000 88,995,000 96,223,000 -22,759,000 89,937,000 Normalized Income 80,896,000 88,995,000 96,223,000 -22,759,000 89,937,000 Rent Expense Supplemental 7,265,000 7,069,000 6,037,000 5,550,000 4,201,000 EBIT 104,959,000 115,576,000 125,169,000 -26,148,000 116,033,000 Reconciled Depreciation 12,952,000 12,855,000 12,486,000 10,899,000 10,718,000 Net Income from Continuing Operation Net Minority Interest 80,896,000 88,995,000 96,223,000 -22,759,000 89,937,000 Total Unusual Items Excluding Goodwill

    --

    0 0 Total Unusual Items

    --

    0 0 Tax Rate for Calcs 0 0 0 0 0 Tax Effect of Unusual Items 0 0 0 0 0 Interest Expense 5,141,000 5,200,000 5,003,000 4,352,000 4,172,000

    Breakdown12/31/202412/31/202312/31/202212/31/2021

    Total Assets 1,153,881,000 1,069,978,000 948,465,000 958,784,000

    Total Liabilities Net Minority Interest 502,226,000 499,208,000 466,784,000 443,854,000

    Policy Holders Liabilities 206,721,000 207,994,000 202,667,000 180,214,000 Unpaid Loss & Loss Reserve 158,297,000 157,274,000 154,257,000 134,420,000 Unearned Premiums 30,808,000 30,507,000 28,657,000 23,512,000 Future Policy Benefits 17,616,000 20,213,000 19,753,000 22,282,000

    Payables And Accrued Expenses 12,769,000 0 49,816,000 46,072,000

    Payables 12,769,000

    --

    Other Payable 12,769,000

    --

    Current Debt And Capital Lease Obligation 2,438,000 5,335,000 2,429,000 2,351,000

    Current Debt 2,438,000 5,335,000 2,429,000 2,351,000 Other Current Borrowings 2,438,000 5,335,000 2,429,000 2,351,000

    Long Term Debt And Capital Lease Obligation 122,324,000 122,936,000 120,315,000 111,911,000 Long Term Debt 122,324,000 122,936,000 120,315,000 111,911,000 Security Sold Not Yet Repurchased

    -- 6,820,000 5,849,000

    Non Current Deferred Liabilities 85,870,000 93,009,000 77,368,000 90,243,000 Non Current Deferred Taxes Liabilities 85,870,000 93,009,000 77,368,000 90,243,000 Other Liabilities 72,104,000 69,934,000 64,005,000 59,135,000

    Total Equity Gross Minority Interest 651,655,000 570,770,000 481,681,000 514,930,000

    Stockholders' Equity 649,368,000 561,273,000 473,424,000 506,199,000

    Capital Stock 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000 Common Stock 8,000 8,000 8,000 8,000 Additional Paid in Capital 35,665,000 34,480,000 35,167,000 35,592,000 Retained Earnings 696,218,000 607,350,000 511,127,000 534,421,000 Treasury Stock 78,939,000 76,802,000 67,826,000 59,795,000

    Gains Losses Not Affecting Retained Earnings -3,584,000 -3,763,000 -5,052,000 -4,027,000 Other Equity Adjustments -3,584,000 -3,763,000 -5,052,000 -4,027,000 Minority Interest 2,287,000 9,497,000 8,257,000 8,731,000 Total Capitalization 771,692,000 684,209,000 593,739,000 618,110,000 Common Stock Equity 649,368,000 561,273,000 473,424,000 506,199,000 Net Tangible Assets 530,850,000 440,763,000 366,118,000 403,838,000 Invested Capital 774,130,000 689,544,000 596,168,000 620,461,000 Tangible Book Value 530,850,000 440,763,000 366,118,000 403,838,000 Total Debt 124,762,000 128,271,000 122,744,000 114,262,000 Net Debt 77,033,000 90,249,000 86,933,000 26,078,000 Share Issued 1,658.10 1,658.10 1,658.10 1,658.10 Ordinary Shares Number 1,438.22 1,441.48 1,459.73 1,477.43 Treasury Shares Number 219.87 216.61 198.36 180.67

    BreakdownTTM12/31/202412/31/202312/31/202212/31/2021

    Operating Cash Flow 30,929,000 30,592,000 49,196,000 37,350,000 39,427,000

    Cash Flow from Continuing Operating Activities 30,929,000 30,592,000 49,196,000 37,350,000 39,427,000 Net Income from Continuing Operations 81,401,000 89,561,000 97,147,000 -21,998,000 90,949,000

    Operating Gains Losses -5,948,000 -3,502,000 -5,711,000 4,779,000 -1,201,000 Gain Loss On Investment Securities -5,948,000 -3,502,000 -5,711,000 4,779,000 -1,201,000

    Depreciation & amortization 12,952,000 12,855,000 12,486,000 10,899,000 10,718,000 Depreciation 11,148,000 11,060,000 10,658,000 9,666,000 9,466,000

    Amortization 1,804,000 1,795,000 1,828,000 1,233,000 1,252,000 Amortization of Intangibles 1,804,000 1,795,000 1,828,000 1,233,000 1,252,000 Other non-cash items 1,567,000 -892,000 -513,000 -3,074,000 -3,382,000 Amortization of Securities -12,570,000 -11,349,000 -5,510,000 -1,132,000

    Unrealized Gain Loss On Investment Securities -38,540,000 -49,297,000 -69,144,000 63,120,000 -76,375,000

    Change in working capital -7,933,000 -6,784,000 20,441,000 -15,244,000 18,718,000

    Change in Receivables -3,138,000 626,000 -1,949,000 -5,621,000 -5,864,000 Changes in Account Receivables

    --

    -- -5,834,000 Change in Loss And Loss Adjustment Expense Reserves 3,271,000 2,173,000 2,628,000 4,057,000 4,194,000 Change in Unearned Premiums 333,000 376,000 1,854,000 1,861,000 2,306,000 Change in Other Current Assets -604,000 -206,000 98,000 -5,157,000 -1,708,000 Change in Other Current Liabilities 1,907,000 -2,288,000 2,570,000 1,719,000 2,658,000 Change in Other Working Capital -9,702,000 -7,465,000 15,240,000 -12,103,000 17,132,000

    Investing Cash Flow -23,485,000 -10,287,000 -32,663,000 -87,601,000 29,392,000

    Cash Flow from Continuing Investing Activities -23,485,000 -10,287,000 -32,663,000 -87,601,000 29,392,000

    Net Investment Purchase And Sale -4,722,000 9,280,000 -5,335,000 -61,782,000 42,354,000 Purchase of Investment -592,126,000 -536,079,000 -251,469,000 -251,852,000 -161,085,000 Sale of Investment 587,404,000 545,359,000 246,134,000 190,070,000 203,439,000

    Net Proceeds Payment for Loan

    --

    -- 473,000 Proceeds from Loans

    --

    -- 561,000 Payment for Loans

    --

    -- -88,000

    Net PPE Purchase And Sale -18,864,000 -18,976,000 -19,409,000 -15,464,000 -13,276,000 Purchase of PPE -18,864,000 -18,976,000 -19,409,000 -15,464,000 -13,276,000

    Net Business Purchase And Sale

    -396,000 -8,604,000 -10,594,000 -456,000 Purchase of Business

    -396,000 -8,604,000 -10,594,000 -456,000 Net Other Investing Changes 497,000 -195,000 685,000 239,000 770,000

    Financing Cash Flow -505,000 -10,360,000 -14,405,000 -1,662,000 -28,508,000

    Cash Flow from Continuing Financing Activities -505,000 -10,360,000 -14,405,000 -1,662,000 -28,508,000

    Net Issuance Payments of Debt 2,952,000 -1,820,000 -1,087,000 8,171,000 -752,000

    Net Long Term Debt Issuance 3,814,000 1,239,000 -3,494,000 8,767,000 -128,000 Long Term Debt Issuance 10,455,000 13,186,000 7,817,000 12,695,000 6,920,000 Long Term Debt Payments -6,641,000 -11,947,000 -11,311,000 -3,928,000 -7,048,000 Net Short Term Debt Issuance -862,000 -3,059,000 2,407,000 -596,000 -624,000

    Net Common Stock Issuance -356,000 -2,918,000 -9,171,000 -7,854,000 -27,061,000 Common Stock Payments -356,000 -2,918,000 -9,171,000 -7,854,000 -27,061,000 Net Other Financing Charges -3,101,000 -5,622,000 -4,147,000 -1,979,000 -695,000

    End Cash Position 43,099,000 48,376,000 38,643,000 36,399,000 88,706,000 Changes in Cash 6,939,000 9,945,000 2,128,000 -51,913,000 40,311,000 Effect of Exchange Rate Changes -244,000 -212,000 116,000 -394,000 -1,000 Beginning Cash Position 36,160,000 38,643,000 36,399,000 88,706,000 48,396,000 Capital Expenditure -18,864,000 -18,976,000 -19,409,000 -15,464,000 -13,276,000 Issuance of Debt 10,455,000 13,186,000 7,817,000 12,695,000 6,920,000 Repayment of Debt -6,641,000 -11,947,000 -11,311,000 -3,928,000 -7,048,000 Repurchase of Capital Stock -356,000 -2,918,000 -9,171,000 -7,854,000 -27,061,000 Free Cash Flow 12,065,000 11,616,000 29,787,000 21,886,000 26,151,000

    12/31/2021 - 3/17/1980 Upgrade to begin using 40 years of financial statements and get so much more. Perform in-depth fundamental analysis with decades of income statements, balance sheets, and cash flows — all exportable.

    Upgrade

  2. Amazon Nova Assistant

    To determine the intrinsic value of a company, various methods can be used, such as Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis, comparable company analysis, or precedent transactions. Given the financial data provided, we'll use the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis method, which is one of the most common and thorough ways to estimate a company's intrinsic value.

    Step-by-Step DCF Analysis

    1. Project Free Cash Flows (FCF)

    Free Cash Flow (FCF) is calculated as: [ \text{FCF} = \text{Operating Cash Flow} - \text{Capital Expenditures} ]

    From the provided data:

    • 2024 FCF: 30,929,000−30,929,000 - 18,864,000 = $12,065,000
    • 2023 FCF: 30,592,000−30,592,000 - 18,976,000 = $11,616,000
    • 2022 FCF: 49,196,000−49,196,000 - 19,409,000 = $29,787,000
    • 2021 FCF: 37,350,000−37,350,000 - 15,464,000 = $21,886,000

    We will project the FCF for the next 5 years. Assuming a conservative growth rate of 3% annually:

    • 2025 FCF: 12,065,000∗1.03=12,065,000 * 1.03 = 12,427,950
    • 2026 FCF: 12,427,950∗1.03=12,427,950 * 1.03 = 12,799,889
    • 2027 FCF: 12,799,889∗1.03=12,799,889 * 1.03 = 13,193,886
    • 2028 FCF: 13,193,886∗1.03=13,193,886 * 1.03 = 13,600,703
    • 2029 FCF: 13,600,703∗1.03=13,600,703 * 1.03 = 14,022,724

    2. Determine the Discount Rate

    The discount rate is typically the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC). For simplicity, let's assume a WACC of 8%.

    3. Discount the Projected FCFs

    Discount each projected FCF back to present value using the WACC.

    [ \text{PV of FCF} = \frac{\text{FCF}}{(1 + \text{WACC})^n} ]

    • 2025 PV: ( \frac{12,427,950}{(1.08)^1} = 11,507,361 )
    • 2026 PV: ( \frac{12,799,889}{(1.08)^2} = 10,984,803 )
    • 2027 PV: ( \frac{13,193,886}{(1.08)^3} = 10,494,077 )
    • 2028 PV: ( \frac{13,600,703}{(1.08)^4} = 10,033,983 )
    • 2029 PV: ( \frac{14,022,724}{(1.08)^5} = 9,603,319 )

    Sum of PV of FCFs: ( 11,507,361 + 10,984,803 + 10,494,077 + 10,033,983 + 9,603,319 = 52,623,543 )

    4. Calculate the Terminal Value

    The terminal value assumes the business will continue to generate cash flows beyond the projection period. We'll use the Gordon Growth Model to calculate the terminal value.

    [ \text{Terminal Value} = \frac{\text{FCF}_{2029} \times (1 + \text{Terminal Growth Rate})}{\text{WACC} - \text{Terminal Growth Rate}} ]

    Assuming a terminal growth rate of 2%:

    [ \text{Terminal Value} = \frac{14,022,724 \times 1.02}{0.08 - 0.02} = \frac{14,293,178}{0.06} = 238,219,633 ]

    Discount the terminal value back to present value:

    [ \text{PV of Terminal Value} = \frac{238,219,633}{(1.08)^5} = 162,076,113 ]

    5. Calculate the Total Enterprise Value

    Sum the present value of the projected FCFs and the present value of the terminal value:

    [ \text{Enterprise Value} = 52,623,543 + 162,076,113 = 214,699,656 ]

    6. Adjust for Net Debt

    To find the equity value, subtract net debt from the enterprise value. Net debt as of 12/31/2024 is $77,033,000.

    [ \text{Equity Value} = 214,699,656 - 77,033,000 = 137,666,656 ]

    7. Calculate the Intrinsic Value per Share

    Divide the equity value by the number of shares outstanding. The number of ordinary shares as of 12/31/2024 is 1,438.22.

    [ \text{Intrinsic Value per Share} = \frac{137,666,656}{1,438.22} = 95,735 ]

    Conclusion

    Based on the DCF analysis, the intrinsic value per share of the company as of 12/31/2024 is approximately $95,735.

    Please note that this is a simplified analysis and actual valuation may require more detailed assumptions and adjustments.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.