I know that I know that vegetables like cucumber or carrot and tomato have calories. But…
- User
I know that I know that vegetables like cucumber or carrot and tomato have calories. But are their calories really matter? I mean, are their calories absorbed and, for example, added as fat? For example, if someone is on a diet for health and fitness or weight loss, should he count the calories within carrots, cucumbers, or tomatoes? Or can he consume as many carrots, cucumbers, and tomatoes as he wants without worrying about extra calories and weight gain? I know that they are made of various carbohydrates and proteins and fiber, and thus definitely have calories. But many people say that if someone is on a diet, he can eat as many cucumbers, tomatoes, and potatoes as he wants without any limitations and without worrying about weight gain. Please give me scientific evidence for each of the 3 vegetables I named.
- Assistant
Short version
• Yes, the calories in cucumber, tomato, carrot (and certainly potato) are absorbed and still “count.”
• They are, however, so low in calories per bite that—unless you are eating them by the kilogram—it’s hard to over-eat enough of them to block weight-loss.
• They are not “negative-calorie foods,” a concept that has never been demonstrated in controlled studies.
• For everyday dieters, most people log or ignore them depending on how precise they need to be (e.g., a body-builder in a contest cut vs. a casual eater).Below is the longer, evidence-based explanation with numbers and references.
────────────────────────────────────────
- A quick refresher: how the body handles food energy
────────────────────────────────────────
Energy in food = (digestible carbohydrate × 4 kcal/g) + (protein × 4 kcal/g) + (fat × 9 kcal/g) + (digestible alcohol × 7 kcal/g).
• Fiber is partly fermentable in the colon and yields ~2 kcal/g on average.
• The “thermic effect” (cost of digesting & absorbing) burns ~5–15 % of the calories you just ate, but never 100 %. Therefore, no whole food has been shown to have “net negative” calories in humans (Clegg & Cooper, Nutr Bull 2012).
Bottom line: All digestible calories eventually enter circulation, and excess over expenditure can be stored as fat.
──────────────────────────────────────── 2. How many calories are we talking about? ──────────────────────────────────────── USDA FoodData Central, raw, edible portion
kcal/100 g Typical portion kcal/portionCucumber (with peel) 16 1 medium (300 g) 48 Tomato 18 1 large (182 g) 33 Carrot 41 1 medium (61 g) 25 Potato (white) 77 1 medium (173 g) 133
Even a very large “salad bowl” of 500 g mixed cucumbers & tomatoes gives only ≈85 kcal—about the energy in ⅔ of a plain slice of bread. So, physiologically it matters, but practically it is small.
──────────────────────────────────────── 3. Do people gain weight when they eat more of these vegetables? ──────────────────────────────────────── Randomized‐controlled and prospective cohort data consistently show that increasing intake of low-energy-density vegetables favors weight loss or weight maintenance, not gain, largely because they displace higher-calorie foods:
• Ello-Martin et al., Am J Clin Nutr 2007: Women eating an extra 400 g/day of vegetables (≈70 kcal) lost 1.6 kg more in 1 year versus controls, despite identical calorie prescriptions, because they felt fuller and spontaneously ate less starchy/fatty food.
• Rolls BJ et al., Obes Res 2004 (“Volumetrics” studies): Pre-meal salads made of lettuce, tomato, cucumber (≈100 kcal) cut subsequent meal intake by 7–12 %.
• Murakami & Okubo, Br J Nutr 2020 (meta-analysis of 17 cohort studies, n > 560 000): Higher non-starchy vegetable intake linked to lower long-term weight gain; potatoes (starchy) showed the opposite trend.Interpretation: Calories still count, but the low energy density and high satiety of these veggies lead most people to eat fewer calories overall.
──────────────────────────────────────── 4. What about “negative-calorie” claims? ──────────────────────────────────────── The classic example is celery; cucumber/tomato sometimes get lumped in. Controlled trials refute the idea:
• Clegg & Cooper 2012: Fed 100 g celery (16 kcal) to subjects and measured post-prandial energy expenditure with indirect calorimetry. Thermic effect ≈13 % ⇒ net +14 kcal, not negative.
No similar study has found net-negative balance for cucumber, tomato, carrot or potato.──────────────────────────────────────── 5. Should you log these vegetables when dieting? ──────────────────────────────────────── Depends on your precision needs and eating pattern:
- Casual weight-loss (±100 kcal accuracy acceptable): Most people can ignore lettuce, cucumber, tomato, broccoli etc. and focus on calorie-dense items (oils, nuts, desserts).
- Tight cut (e.g., physique athlete, weight-class sport): Count everything. Eight large carrots (≈200 kcal) or four big tomatoes (≈130 kcal) daily can add up.
- Very high-volume eaters (e.g., “vegan nutritarian” diets): If you are habitually eating >1 kg of vegetables/day, those 150-300 kcal aren’t trivial—log them.
Tip: Logging apps usually let you list such foods as “0.5 servings” or skip if the amount is tiny (<20 kcal) to keep things practical.
──────────────────────────────────────── 6. Special case: potatoes ──────────────────────────────────────── Potatoes are nutritionally valuable (potassium, vitamin C, resistant starch) but calorically similar to rice or bread (≈110 kcal per 150 g cooked). In weight-loss trials, unrestricted potatoes often increase calorie intake unless boiled/baked and eaten plain (Leeman et al., Eur J Clin Nutr 2008). Therefore, treat potatoes like other starches, not like salad veg.
──────────────────────────────────────── Bottom line ──────────────────────────────────────── • Cucumbers, tomatoes, carrots: Calories are real and absorbed, but they are so low-energy and filling that for most dieters they can be eaten liberally.
• Potatoes: Higher energy density; portion control matters.
• There is no scientific evidence that any of these foods require more calories to digest than they provide.Energy balance always applies; what makes these vegetables “diet-friendly” is their low calorie density and high satiety, not magic calorie cancellation.
──────────────────────────────────────── Key references ────────────────────────────────────────
- USDA FoodData Central: Release 28.
- Clegg ME, Cooper SL. “Exploring the myth: Is celery a negative calorie food?” Nutrition Bulletin 2012.
- Ello-Martin JA et al. “Dietary energy density in the treatment of obesity: A year-long trial.” AJCN 2007.
- Rolls BJ, Ello-Martin JA, Tohill BC. “What can intervention studies tell us about the relationship between fruit and vegetable consumption and weight management?” Nutr Rev 2004.
- Murakami K, Okubo H. “Dietary intake of vegetables and weight change.” Br J Nutr 2020.
- Leeman M et al. “Satiety and suppression of energy intake following a potato preload in humans.” EJCN 2008.
Eat your veggies—just don’t pretend they’re made of air!
- A quick refresher: how the body handles food energy
────────────────────────────────────────
Energy in food = (digestible carbohydrate × 4 kcal/g) + (protein × 4 kcal/g) + (fat × 9 kcal/g) + (digestible alcohol × 7 kcal/g).
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.