Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Googlegemma-3n-e4b-it· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

what are reviews about The Old Guard 2

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Coherecommand-a-03-2025’s answer.
  1. User

    what are reviews about The Old Guard 2

  2. Google Assistant

    Okay, here's a breakdown of the reviews for "The Old Guard: Resurrection," the sequel to the 2020 film. It's been a pretty mixed bag, leaning towards negative overall.

    General Sentiment:

    • Widely Negative: The overwhelming consensus is that "Resurrection" is a significant step down from the original "The Old Guard." Many critics and viewers found it to be a disappointing and underwhelming sequel.
    • Lack of Originality: A common criticism is that the film feels derivative and doesn't offer anything new or exciting compared to the first movie. It's seen as rehashing familiar tropes without adding much depth.
    • Weak Plot & Character Development: Many reviewers found the plot convoluted, predictable, and lacking in compelling character arcs. The new characters, in particular, were often criticized for being underdeveloped and unmemorable.
    • Visuals & Action: While the action sequences are still present, some critics felt they weren't as impactful or creative as in the first film. The visual effects were also not universally praised.
    • Tone Shift: Some viewers felt the film shifted away from the original's more grounded and character-driven tone, opting for a more generic action-movie approach.

    Here's a summary from various sources:

    • Rotten Tomatoes:
      • Critics: 23% approval rating. The consensus reads: "Resurrection fails to recapture the magic of the original, delivering a convoluted plot and lackluster action."
      • Audience: 64% approval rating. This is a bit higher than the critics' score, suggesting some viewers still found something to enjoy, but it's still not a strong endorsement.
    • Metacritic: The film has a Metascore of 35, indicating "generally unfavorable reviews."
    • Common Sense Media: Gives it a 2-star rating, citing violence and some mature themes, but also noting the film's lack of originality and weak storytelling.

    Specific Criticisms Often Mentioned:

    • The Villain: The antagonist was widely considered weak and uninspired.
    • New Characters: The introduction of new immortal characters didn't resonate with many viewers. They felt they were poorly developed and didn't add anything meaningful to the story.
    • Plot Holes: Several plot inconsistencies and logical gaps were pointed out.
    • Pacing: The film's pacing was often criticized as being uneven, with some scenes dragging on while others felt rushed.
    • Emotional Impact: Many viewers felt the film lacked the emotional depth and connection that made the first movie so engaging.

    What People Did Like (though less common):

    • Charlize Theron: Charlize Theron's performance as the central character, Andy, was generally praised as being a strong point of the film.
    • Action Sequences (to some extent): Some viewers still enjoyed the action sequences, even if they weren't as groundbreaking as in the first film.
    • Visuals: Some found the visuals to be decent, although not exceptional.

    In Conclusion:

    "The Old Guard: Resurrection" is generally considered a disappointment compared to its predecessor. While it has some redeeming qualities (like Theron's performance and some action), the weak plot, underdeveloped characters, and lack of originality have led to overwhelmingly negative reviews. If you enjoyed the first film, you might be disappointed by this sequel.

    You can find more detailed reviews on sites like:

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.