If I want to commit changes to enrich a project github wiki page, but I have not…
- User
If I want to commit changes to enrich a project github wiki page, but I have not permission(non-contributor), should I create a issue or disscussion?
Assistant
If you want to contribute to a GitHub project's wiki but don't have write access (i.e., you're not a contributor), the best approach depends on the project's workflow and your intended changes:
1. Create an Issue (Recommended for most cases)
- When to use: If your changes are straightforward (e.g., fixing typos, adding small clarifications) or if the wiki is tightly controlled by maintainers.
- How to do it:
- Go to the Issues tab of the repository.
- Click New Issue.
- Clearly describe the changes you'd like to make (you can even paste the corrected text).
- Ask if a maintainer can apply your changes or grant you temporary access.
- Pros:
- Issues are more commonly monitored by maintainers.
- Good for small, actionable improvements.
2. Start a Discussion (If enabled)
- When to use: If the project has Discussions enabled and your changes are more substantial (e.g., restructuring, adding new sections) or require community input.
- How to do it:
- Go to the Discussions tab (if available).
- Start a new discussion under "Ideas," "Q&A," or "General."
- Explain your proposed changes and ask for feedback.
- Pros:
- More collaborative; good for gathering opinions before making changes.
- Less formal than an issue.
Alternative: Fork the Wiki (If it's a separate repo)
- Some wikis are stored in a separate repository (e.g.,
project.wiki.git). - If that's the case, you can:
- Fork the wiki repo.
- Make your changes.
- Submit a Pull Request (if allowed) or link your fork in an issue/discussion.
Which One Should You Choose?
- Small fixes? → Issue (fastest way to get attention).
- Big changes or need feedback? → Discussion (if available).
- Wiki is a separate repo? → Fork + PR (if possible).
Would you like help drafting a message for the issue/discussion?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.