Role: PhD advisor, be helpful but very critical, the student is very capable, show where…
- User
Role: PhD advisor, be helpful but very critical, the student is very capable, show where the approach might hit pitfalls (and the essential difficulty to be resolved), do not propose a solution, just reveal the landscape of the problem
I'm thinking about how to create a sequence model where the memory/state cardinality can be controlled. For example we train with sliding window attention with a distribution of window sizes. The question is can we do this generally and maybe even make it with some form of linear recurrent network. The difficulty I have is that attention naturally handles arbitrary sizes, but recurrent methods often have a time evolution operator that's learned at a fixed memory size. Also they often use keys which are derived from matrix multiply which again is fixed. Are there some ways to actually make a linear rnn that can have adjustable sizes. My intuition is that if the state size is 10k elements, then having 10001 elements is only differentially changing the problem for the network. Alternatively maybe the rnn actually uses attention on slots like ntm.
Assistant
You're touching on a fundamental tension in sequence modeling architectures. Let me probe the critical assumptions here.
First, your intuition about 10k vs 10,001 elements being "differentially" similar - this is deceptively appealing but masks a deeper issue. In linear RNNs, the state transition matrix A (in the continuous case) or its discretized version fundamentally couples the dynamics to the state dimensionality. When you change from 10k to 10,001, you're not just adding one more coordinate - you're changing the entire eigenspectrum of the system. The learned dynamics are intrinsically tied to this specific geometry.
Consider what happens with methods like S4 or similar structured state space models. They achieve efficiency by imposing specific structures on A (diagonal, companion form, etc.). But these structures are dimensionality-specific. A diagonal system with 10k states has fundamentally different representational capacity than one with 10,001 states - it's not a smooth interpolation.
The "keys derived from matrix multiply" observation reveals another critical issue. In attention, the key/query/value projections can naturally handle variable sequence lengths because they operate pointwise. But in RNNs, the recurrent weight matrices define a fixed-dimensional dynamical system. You can't just "pad" or "truncate" these matrices without fundamentally altering the dynamics.
Your NTM-style slot attention idea is interesting but consider: are you truly getting variable-size memory, or are you just learning to selectively use a fixed-size memory? The latter doesn't solve your core problem - it just pushes the fixed-size constraint to a different level of the architecture.
The real crux seems to be: can you define a family of dynamical systems parameterized by dimension such that the learned dynamics at one dimension meaningfully transfer to nearby dimensions? This isn't just an engineering challenge - it's asking whether there exists a natural "continuation" of linear dynamical systems across dimensions. What mathematical structure would even allow such a thing?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
minimax-m1Compare side by side →
claude-opus-4-20250514Compare side by side →
- grok-3-mini-betaCompare side by side →
amazon.nova-pro-v1:0Compare side by side →
gemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinkingCompare side by side →
mistral-medium-2505Compare side by side →
minimax-m1Compare side by side →
gemma-3-27b-itCompare side by side →
gemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinkingCompare side by side →
claude-3-7-sonnet-20250219-thinking-32kCompare side by side →
claude-opus-4-20250514-thinking-16kCompare side by side →