I am a game master and DM for commercial tabletop RPG games club. I need a profiling…
- User
I am a game master and DM for commercial tabletop RPG games club. I need a profiling framework for new players so I can quickly evaluate their sthyle of play and their wishes rom the game. Do you know any good solutions?
- Assistant
Here are some established player profiling frameworks that work well for tabletop RPGs:
Bartle's Player Types (adapted for TTRPGs) Originally for video games, but translates well:
- Achievers: Want to complete quests, level up, optimize builds
- Explorers: Love discovering lore, new locations, game mechanics
- Socializers: Focus on roleplay, character relationships, group dynamics
- Killers: Enjoy combat, competition, overcoming challenges
Robin's Laws of Good Game Mastering player types:
- Power Gamer: Optimizes character builds, seeks mechanical advantages
- Butt-Kicker: Wants action and combat
- Tactician: Enjoys strategic planning and problem-solving
- Storyteller: Focuses on narrative and character development
- Method Actor: Deep roleplay, stays in character
- Casual Gamer: Just wants to hang out and have fun
The 8 Kinds of Fun (MDA Framework):
- Sensation (game as sense-pleasure)
- Fantasy (game as make-believe)
- Narrative (game as drama)
- Challenge (game as obstacle course)
- Fellowship (game as social framework)
- Discovery (game as uncharted territory)
- Expression (game as self-discovery)
- Submission (game as pastime)
For practical implementation, I'd suggest creating a simple intake questionnaire that covers:
- Preferred combat-to-roleplay ratio
- Interest in character optimization vs. narrative choices
- Comfort level with character death
- Preferred session length and pacing
- Topics they want to avoid
- Previous TTRPG experience
You could also use tools like the "Same Page Tool" or "Session Zero checklist" which help establish expectations upfront. These are particularly useful for commercial games where you need to quickly match players with compatible groups and GMs.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.