Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

why does youtube allow those weird shorts with people in the corner that contribute…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking’s answer.
  1. User

    why does youtube allow those weird shorts with people in the corner that contribute nothing to the video

  2. Gemini Assistant

    That's an excellent question, and you've pinpointed a type of content that frustrates many YouTube users. The phenomenon of split-screen Shorts with a person in the corner contributing nothing is a perfect storm of creator incentives, platform algorithms, and copyright loopholes.

    Here’s a breakdown of why YouTube allows these videos, looking at it from every angle.

    1. The Creator's Perspective: Why They Make Them

    This is the "supply" side of the equation, and the motivations are very clear:

    • Low-Effort, High-Reward: It is arguably the easiest way to create content. The creator doesn't need to come up with an original idea, write a script, or do complex editing. They simply find a popular or engaging video, record themselves looking at it, and post.
    • Piggybacking on Virality: The main video (the satisfying clip, movie scene, fail video, etc.) is already proven to be engaging. By using it, the creator is essentially hijacking its viral potential. The algorithm sees that people are watching the clip and promotes the Short, benefiting the "reactor."
    • Gaming the Algorithm: YouTube's Shorts algorithm prioritizes watch time and engagement. Since the core content is something people are likely to watch to the end, these videos perform well on paper. The algorithm doesn't (or can't) effectively judge the quality or originality of the contribution, it just sees that users are watching.
    • Rapid Channel Growth: For channels trying to quickly gain subscribers and meet monetization requirements (like the YouTube Partner Program), this is a shortcut. By churning out dozens of these low-effort shorts, they can accumulate views and subscribers much faster than if they were creating original content from scratch.

    2. The Platform's Perspective: Why YouTube Allows Them

    This is the core of your question. YouTube isn't a person making a judgment call; it's a massive company driven by metrics and legal frameworks.

    • Engagement is King: YouTube's primary goal is to keep users on the platform for as long as possible to show them more ads. These shorts, while low-quality, are effective at this. They are short, easily digestible, and the endless scroll keeps people watching. From a purely data-driven perspective, the content is "working."
    • The Copyright Gray Area (Fair Use): This is the most important legal reason. Taking someone else's content is typically copyright infringement. However, the legal doctrine of "Fair Use" allows for the use of copyrighted material without permission under certain circumstances, such as for commentary, criticism, or parody.
      • By adding a "reaction" (even a silent, useless one), creators are attempting to frame their video as transformative. They are technically adding something new, which they can argue falls under "commentary."
      • While a silent nod hardly seems transformative, it's enough to create a legal gray area that makes automated enforcement difficult.
    • The Impossibility of Scale: YouTube has billions of videos, with hundreds of hours of content uploaded every minute. It is physically impossible for human moderators to review every video. The platform relies on automated systems like Content ID to detect copyrighted material. These creators often bypass Content ID by mirroring the video, cropping it, or adding the reaction box, which can fool the system.
    • Competition with TikTok: YouTube Shorts was created to compete directly with TikTok. In the early days of a new feature, platforms often have looser rules to encourage a massive influx of content and creators. They needed to populate Shorts quickly, and this low-effort format was an easy way to do it. They are still playing catch-up and refining their policies.

    3. The Viewer's Perspective: Why People Watch Them

    While many find these annoying, they wouldn't be so prevalent if no one watched them.

    • Content Curation: Some viewers follow these channels not for the reactor, but because the channel is a reliable source of a specific type of content (e.g., "best gaming fails," "satisfying factory machines"). The reactor is just part of the channel's branding.
    • The Illusion of a Shared Experience: On a subconscious level, seeing another human face react to a video can make the viewing experience feel less isolated. It mimics watching TV with a friend, even if that "friend" is a stranger silently nodding in a box.
    • Passive Consumption: It's "junk food" content. It requires zero mental effort to watch and provides a quick, mild hit of entertainment.

    Conclusion

    YouTube allows these "weird shorts" because they exist in a perfect loophole:

    • Creators use them as a low-effort way to game the algorithm.
    • The Algorithm sees them as engaging content because people watch them.
    • The Policies can't easily ban them because they hide behind a weak claim of "Fair Use," and the sheer scale of uploads makes manual enforcement impossible.

    While YouTube's policies on "Reused Content" are meant to prevent this, the Shorts ecosystem is still a bit of a wild west. It's likely that as the platform matures, YouTube will continue to refine its algorithm and policies to better distinguish between genuine transformative content and low-effort freebooting.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.