Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What is the cheapest and best email software using AI in the category of Suerhuman and…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-sonnet-4-20250514-thinking-32k’s answer.
  1. User

    What is the cheapest and best email software using AI in the category of Suerhuman and Readdle Spark?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Excellent question. You're looking for an email client in a very specific, high-performance category. The core tension in your question is between "cheapest" and "best," as these two are often at odds in this space.

    Here’s a breakdown of the top contenders, including Superhuman and Spark, with a clear verdict at the end.

    The Main Contenders

    FeatureSuperhumanReaddle SparkShortwave
    Price$30 / month (No free tier)Free (Core features)$4.99 / month (Billed Annually for Premium AI)Free (90-day history limit)$7.50 / month (Billed Annually for Pro)
    Core PhilosophySpeed. Achieve "Inbox Zero" through a blazing-fast, keyboard-driven workflow.Focus. Tame your inbox with a "Smart Inbox" and screen new senders with a "Gatekeeper".Organization. Automatically bundle and summarize your email to make it feel like a to-do list.
    Key AI Features- AI Triage: Summarizes a long thread with one click.- AI Compose: Write entire emails from a short prompt.- AI Editing: Instantly fix tone, spelling, and grammar.- Spark + AI: Summarize threads, generate quick replies, rephrase text, proofread, and change tone.- AI Summaries: This is its killer feature. Automatically summarizes bundled emails (e.g., newsletters, notifications).- AI Compose & Editing.- AI Translation.
    Best ForExecutives, power users, and anyone who lives in their inbox and values speed above all else.The average user or team looking for a massive upgrade over default email apps without a high price tag.Gmail users who are overwhelmed by volume and want AI to automatically organize and summarize their inbox for them.
    Platform SupportMac, Windows, iOS, Android, WebMac, Windows, iOS, AndroidWeb, iOS, Android (No dedicated desktop app, but web app is excellent)
    Killer FeatureBlazing Speed & Keyboard Shortcuts. Nothing else feels as fast.Gatekeeper. Decide "yes" or "no" for every new sender, keeping your inbox clean forever.Automatic Bundling & Summaries. It fundamentally changes how you process non-urgent email.
    WeaknessExtremely Expensive. The price is a major barrier for most people.Not quite as "magically fast" as Superhuman. Most powerful AI is in Premium.Gmail/Google Workspace only. The 90-day search history on the free plan can be a limitation.

    Detailed Breakdown

    1. Superhuman - The "Best" (If Money is No Object)

    Superhuman is the benchmark for a reason. It's built for speed. The entire experience is designed around keyboard shortcuts that allow you to fly through your inbox. Its AI features are seamlessly integrated into this workflow, letting you summarize a 30-email thread or draft a reply without touching your mouse.

    • Best Part: The feeling of speed and control is unmatched.
    • Worst Part: The $30/month price is non-negotiable and inaccessible for many.

    2. Readdle Spark - The Best All-Around Value

    Spark is the most direct competitor to Superhuman and offers 90% of the power for a fraction of the cost. Its "Smart Inbox" intelligently sorts mail into People, Notifications, and Newsletters. The killer feature, Gatekeeper, acts like a bouncer for your inbox, preventing spam before it ever gets in. Its AI features are robust and included in the very affordable Premium tier.

    • Best Part: The combination of a powerful free version, an affordable premium plan, the Gatekeeper feature, and full cross-platform support makes it an incredible value.
    • Worst Part: While fast, it doesn't have the same instantaneous, "magical" feel as Superhuman.

    3. Shortwave - The "Cheapest" with the Smartest AI

    Shortwave is the dark horse and a fantastic choice, especially if you use Gmail. It was founded by ex-Google employees and its approach is different. It automatically bundles related emails (like all your Amazon notifications or newsletters) and then uses AI to write a one-sentence summary of the entire bundle. This is a game-changer for inbox clutter.

    Its free tier is incredibly generous, offering all core features and AI with the only major limitation being a 90-day search history. For many, this is more than enough.

    • Best Part: The AI-powered bundling and summaries are brilliant and a core part of the experience, even on the free plan.
    • Worst Part: It only works with Gmail/Google accounts, and the lack of a dedicated desktop app might bother some.

    Final Verdict: The Cheapest and Best

    This comes down to your primary goal.

    • If your priority is "BEST" (and you can afford it): Superhuman is still the king of speed and polished power-user experience.

    • If your priority is "CHEAPEST" (without sacrificing quality): Shortwave is the clear winner. Its free tier is the most powerful and AI-centric on the market. You get a truly innovative, AI-driven experience without paying a dime, as long as you use Gmail and can live with the 90-day history limit.

    • For the Best Balance of Price, Power, and Platforms: Readdle Spark is the champion. It strikes the perfect balance. Its free tier is excellent, and its Premium plan is a bargain for the AI features and cross-platform support you get. The Gatekeeper feature alone is worth the price of admission for many.

    Recommendation: Start with the free version of Readdle Spark or Shortwave.

    • If you use Gmail and are overwhelmed with clutter, try Shortwave first.
    • If you use multiple account types (Gmail, Outlook, etc.) or want the best all-around traditional-but-smarter email client, start with Spark.

    You will likely find one of these two is more than "good enough," saving you the $360/year that Superhuman costs.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.