Where is the noise generated?
- User
Where is the noise generated?
- Assistant
Great question! When we talk about CNG (Comfort Noise Generation) in VoIP (Voice over IP), the comfort noise is generated on the receiving side — not by the person who is silent, but by the device or software of the person listening to the silence.
🔊 Where Is the Noise Generated?
Short Answer:
Comfort noise is generated locally at the receiver's end during silent periods in a conversation.
🧠 Why Generate It Locally?
During a call:
- The sender's microphone captures real background noise along with speech.
- If there's no one talking for a few seconds, the sender’s phone might stop sending voice packets entirely (to save bandwidth) using VAD (Voice Activity Detection).
- To avoid an uncomfortable silence, the receiver's phone or app generates artificial background noise that mimics what was heard earlier.
This makes it feel like the line is still active and prevents callers from thinking the connection has dropped.
📦 How Does It Work Step-by-Step?
-
Noise Characterization (Sender Side):
- When someone is speaking, the sender’s phone also analyzes the background noise.
- It sends small "noise parameters" (not full audio) periodically during silence.
-
Transmission of Silence Descriptor:
- These parameters are sent in SID (Silence Insertion Descriptor) packets.
- SID packets are tiny and only sent occasionally during silence.
-
Noise Generation (Receiver Side):
- The receiver uses the SID data to generate synthetic background noise that matches the original environment.
- This is CNG — comfort noise generated locally, based on past conditions.
🎛️ Example
Imagine you're on a call from a coffee shop (with café chatter in the background). When you stop talking:
- Your phone detects silence and stops sending voice packets (saves bandwidth).
- It sends a few SID packets describing the café noise.
- The person you're talking to hears a gentle hum that sounds like your café background — even though you're not talking anymore.
✅ Benefits of Local CNG
Benefit Description Bandwidth Savings No need to send silence; only send noise descriptors. Natural Feel Listeners don’t perceive sudden silence, which can be disconcerting. Low Latency Since the noise is generated locally, it avoids network delays.
📚 Standards That Define CNG
- G.711 Appendix II – Defines CNG for use with G.711 codec
- G.729 Annex B – Adds CNG to G.729 codec
- AMR (Adaptive Multi-Rate) – Includes built-in VAD and CNG support
- RFC 3389 – Defines how comfort noise is handled in RTP packets (used in SIP-based VoIP)
🧰 Real-World Examples
- VoIP Phones (Cisco, Polycom, Yealink): All modern IP phones include CNG support.
- Softphones (Zoom, Teams, Linphone): Use local CNG to simulate natural pauses.
- Mobile Calls (VoLTE): Also use CNG to improve perceived call quality.
❌ Common Misconception
“If I hear background noise during silence, it must mean the other person is still making noise.”
Not true! In many cases, especially in VoIP, that sound is being generated locally by your own device to make the silence more comfortable.
Summary
Question Answer Where is comfort noise generated? On the receiving side (the listener’s device or softphone). Why not send real silence? To save bandwidth and prevent awkward pauses. What does CNG mimic? The background noise environment of the speaker before they stopped talking. Let me know if you'd like to explore how CNG is configured or disabled in specific systems (e.g., Asterisk, Cisco, or WebRTC)!
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.