Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

i want a link to be indexed on google but without being seen atm, if a use a hidden href…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralmistral-small-2506’s answer.
  1. User

    i want a link to be indexed on google but without being seen atm, if a use a hidden href will that work

  2. Gemini Assistant

    No, using a hidden href is not a good idea and is considered a Black Hat SEO tactic.

    Here's why and what you should do instead:

    Why Hidden href is a Bad Idea:

    1. Spammy Tactic: Google's algorithms are incredibly sophisticated. They render web pages almost exactly like a user's browser. If a link (or text) is hidden using display: none;, visibility: hidden;, positioning off-screen (left: -9999px;), or matching text color to the background, Google will detect it.
    2. Penalties: This practice is a violation of Google's Webmaster Guidelines. If caught, your site could face a manual penalty (a direct action taken by Google against your site), which can severely impact your search rankings, or even lead to de-indexing.
    3. Ineffective for Indexing: Even if you avoid a penalty, Google might simply ignore the hidden link for indexing purposes because it's not meant for users. Google wants to index what users see and interact with.

    What to Do Instead (Safe & Effective Methods):

    If you want a link/page to be indexed by Google but not immediately prominent or visible to all users, consider these legitimate strategies:

    1. Google Search Console (GSC) - The Most Direct Way:

      • Submit an XML Sitemap: Create an XML sitemap that includes the URL of the page you want indexed. Submit this sitemap to Google Search Console. This is the most common and effective way to tell Google about all your pages.
      • URL Inspection Tool: In GSC, use the "URL Inspection" tool, paste the URL, and then click "Request Indexing." This directly tells Google to crawl and consider the page for indexing.
      • Benefit: This allows you to get the page indexed without needing to put a public link on your site immediately.
    2. Link from a Less Prominent, but Visible, Location:

      • Place a standard, visible link to the page from a part of your website that is less frequently visited or less prominent. Examples:
        • In your website's footer.
        • On a dedicated "Resources" or "Sitemap" page (that isn't a robot-generated XML sitemap).
        • Within an older blog post that's still live but not promoted.
        • On a "Beta" or "Coming Soon" section that's publicly accessible but not highlighted.
      • Key: The link must be genuinely visible and clickable to a human user if they were to navigate to that specific page.
    3. Temporary noindex on the Target Page (If content isn't ready):

      • If the content on the target page isn't ready for public consumption but you want Google to discover the URL, you can:
        • Place a regular, visible link to the page.
        • Add a meta name="robots" content="noindex" tag in the <head> section of the target page itself.
      • Result: Google will crawl the page, discover the URL, but will not show it in search results due to the noindex tag.
      • Crucial: Remember to remove the noindex tag when the content is ready for prime time, and then request indexing again in GSC.

    In summary: Always aim for transparent and user-friendly methods. Google's goal is to provide the best search results, and that means understanding and ranking content that is genuinely valuable and accessible to users. Hidden elements work against that goal.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.