this my proposed prompt for copilot / LLM, could understand what this is trying to…
- User
this my proposed prompt for copilot / LLM, could understand what this is trying to archieve and polish it so that it will force LLM to think really hard and read the context that I add with the prompt and give the output I desire of qualtiy
prompt " as an Operational Risk Expert I need to understand control objective , it's associated Approach to Controls (ATC), and map / generate controls
I have the following Control Objective (CO) details I have Approach to Control (ATC) ddetails I have a list of type of contols and their information
I need you to read the CO, ATC as well as the List of Type of Controls and give me for a given set of CO and ATC a list of control types you believe that are most relevant and applicable"
Assistant
Of course. This is an excellent use case for an LLM, and your proposed prompt is a great starting point. The goal is to move from a simple instruction to a detailed, structured directive that forces the LLM to perform a high-level reasoning task.
Here’s an analysis of your original prompt and a polished version designed to produce high-quality, reasoned outputs.
Analysis of Your Original Prompt
- What it does well: It clearly states the persona ("Operational Risk Expert"), the inputs (CO, ATC, Control List), and the desired outcome (a list of relevant control types). An LLM would understand the basic request.
- Where it can be improved:
- Lacks "Forced Thinking": It doesn't explicitly ask the LLM to explain why a control is relevant. It just asks for a list. This allows the LLM to pattern-match keywords without deep reasoning.
- Ambiguous Quality Bar: "most relevant and applicable" is subjective. You can make it more objective by asking it to justify its choices against specific criteria.
- No Structure for Output: You're leaving the format of the response up to the LLM, which can result in a simple, unhelpful bulleted list.
Polished and Enhanced Prompt
This version is designed as a reusable template. You just need to paste your specific context into the marked sections. It uses structure, explicit instructions, and a request for justification to force the LLM to "think harder."
**ROLE AND GOAL** You are an expert-level Operational Risk Management (ORM) Analyst and a specialist in control design. Your primary expertise lies in analyzing risk scenarios and mapping effective, efficient, and relevant controls to mitigate them. You are meticulous, detail-oriented, and always provide clear justification for your recommendations. Your goal is to analyze a given Control Objective (CO) and its associated Approach to Control (ATC) and then, by referencing a master list of available control types, recommend the most suitable controls. **CONTEXT** You must base your entire analysis STRICTLY on the following information provided. Do not invent or assume any information outside of this context. **1. Control Objective (CO):** [--- PASTE YOUR CONTROL OBJECTIVE DETAILS HERE ---] *Example: "Ensure that all user access to critical financial systems is requested, approved, and provisioned in a timely and authorized manner to prevent unauthorized access."* **2. Approach to Control (ATC):** [--- PASTE YOUR APPROACH TO CONTROL DETAILS HERE ---] *Example: "The approach will be primarily preventative, focusing on automated workflows and clear segregation of duties. Detective controls will be used as a secondary measure to review provisioning activities."* **3. Universe of Available Control Types:** [--- PASTE YOUR LIST OF CONTROL TYPES AND THEIR DESCRIPTIONS HERE ---] *Example: - **Access Recertification:** A detective control where system entitlements are periodically reviewed by managers to ensure access is still required. - **Automated Provisioning Workflow:** A preventative control where access requests are routed, approved, and provisioned through an automated system based on pre-defined rules. - **Segregation of Duties (SoD) Rule Engine:** A preventative control that automatically checks for toxic access combinations before they are granted. - **Privileged Access Monitoring:** A detective control that logs and reviews all activities performed by privileged accounts.* --- **YOUR TASK: STEP-BY-STEP INSTRUCTIONS** Follow these steps precisely: 1. **Deconstruct the Objective:** First, silently analyze the Control Objective (CO). Identify the key processes (e.g., "requesting," "approving," "provisioning"), the core assets being protected (e.g., "critical financial systems"), and the primary risk to be mitigated (e.g., "unauthorized access"). 2. **Analyze the Approach:** Next, analyze the Approach to Control (ATC). Determine the mandated control strategy. Is it primarily **Preventative**, **Detective**, or **Corrective**? Is it focused on being **Automated** or **Manual**? This will be your primary filter. 3. **Evaluate and Map:** Now, review each control type from the "Universe of Available Control Types." For each one, perform the following evaluation: * Does this control directly address the risk identified in the CO? * Does this control align with the strategy outlined in the ATC (e.g., is it preventative if the ATC calls for a preventative approach)? * Is it a primary control or a secondary, supporting control? 4. **Generate a Structured Recommendation:** Based on your evaluation, provide your recommendations in the format specified below. You MUST provide a recommendation for at least two control types you believe are most applicable. For each recommendation, provide a detailed justification. **OUTPUT FORMAT** Present your final output as a structured list. For each recommended control, provide the following three pieces of information: * **Recommended Control Type:** [Name of the control from the provided list] * **Relevance Score:** [High / Medium / Low] * **Justification:** [A detailed explanation (2-4 sentences) connecting this specific control back to the CO and ATC. Explain HOW it mitigates the risk and WHY it aligns with the specified approach. For example: "This control directly addresses the 'authorized approval' part of the CO by enforcing a systematic chain of command. As an automated and preventative measure, it perfectly aligns with the ATC's mandate."] Do not recommend any control types that are not in the provided "Universe of Available Control Types."Why This Polished Prompt Works Better
- Strong Persona (Role and Goal): It tells the LLM how to think ("meticulous, detail-oriented, provide clear justification"). This sets a high standard for the response.
- Structured Context: Using
[--- PASTE ... HERE ---]makes the prompt a clean, reusable template and clearly separates the instructions from the data it needs to analyze. - Step-by-Step Logic: The "Step-by-Step Instructions" section forces the LLM to follow a logical reasoning process (Deconstruct -> Analyze -> Evaluate -> Recommend). This prevents it from taking shortcuts.
- Demands Justification: This is the most crucial part. By requiring a detailed
Justificationthat explicitly links the control to both the CO and the ATC, you are forcing the LLM to synthesize information, not just match keywords. - Specific Output Format: Requesting a
Relevance Scoreand a structured output with clear headings ensures the response is easy to parse and directly comparable, which is what an analyst would want. - Explicit Constraints: The final line ("Do not recommend any control types that are not in the provided 'Universe'...") prevents the LLM from "hallucinating" or suggesting controls you don't have, making the output more practical.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.