if I have a million dollars in an S&P index fund, 400k in thrift savings, I receive a…
- User
if I have a million dollars in an S&P index fund, 400k in thrift savings, I receive a military retirement of 3000 per month, I’m 55 years old and my wife is 45. When I hit social security age I will be close to maximum benefit. If I quit working today, approximately how much per month would my wife and I have to spend each month (in todays dollars)?
- Assistant
Below is one way to “back‐of‐the‐envelope” estimate. Of course, the answer depends on your assumptions (about how long the money must last, real market returns, exactly how much Social Security you get, etc.) but many analysts in your situation tend to conclude that—with
• about $1.0 million in a low‐cost S&P index account plus $400,000 in your Thrift (total “portfolio” of roughly $1.4 million), • a guaranteed military retirement of $3,000/month now, • and (by the time you hit Social Security age) benefits “near the maximum” (for example, an assumed $3,000/month for you and perhaps a spousal benefit so that the couple might get something like $3,000–$4,500/month in Social Security), • along with a planning horizon of 30–40 years—
a “sustainable” level of total monthly spending in today’s dollars comes out in the neighborhood of $6,000–$7,000 per month.
Let me describe one rough approach:
-
Your Guaranteed Income.
Right away (from age 55) you get $3,000/month from your military retirement. Then, once you reach Social Security age (say about age 67), you expect to add Social Security. (One common assumption is that the primary earner might get about $3,000/month at full retirement and a spousal benefit might add another $1,500–$1,500/month; the numbers vary widely, however.) For one set of assumptions you might have:- Age 55–67: $3,000/month guaranteed.
- Age 67 onward: perhaps $3,000 (your SS) + an extra $3,000 from SS or spousal benefits, plus your $3,000 military retirement = about $6,000–$7,000/month guaranteed.
-
The Role of the Portfolio.
Since if you “retire now” (at 55) your Social Security isn’t “on” yet, you must “fill the gap” from your portfolio. For example, if you target a constant lifestyle spending of, say, $7,000/month in today’s dollars, then:- From age 55–67 your portfolio must “cover” the difference of about $4,000/month ($7,000 – $3,000). Over 12 years that is roughly $48,000 per year. On a $1.4 million nest egg (in today’s dollars) that is about a 3.4% withdrawal rate in today’s dollars—a level that many would consider sustainable if real returns run around 4% per year.
- After age 67, with Social Security in hand (bringing total guaranteed income perhaps to around $6,000/month or more) the portfolio “withdrawal gap” is much lower (perhaps only $1,000/month).
-
Putting It Together.
When you then “average” over a very long retirement horizon (say 40 years for a couple) one ends up with an overall “sustainable” spending level in today’s dollars in the mid‐to‐upper $70,000–$85,000 per year range. That translates to roughly $6,000–$7,000 a month.
Many planners find that with a combination of a relatively modest portfolio (in absolute dollars) plus a few streams of “guaranteed” income, a spending target in the $6–7K/month range (in today’s dollars) is a plausible “safe” number. (If you were to try to “spend it all” by age 85 or 90 you could technically run a bit higher—for example, some “all‐in” calculations yield numbers in the $10–11K/month range. But many retirees wish to build in a margin of safety.)
Bottom Line: Although each situation is different and many assumptions enter (including the assumed real rate of return and exact Social Security amounts), if you “quit working now” your numbers look roughly like this: Your portfolio plus your military retirement and later Social Security could support a lifestyle of about $6,000–$7,000 a month in today’s dollars.
This is only an approximate “ball‐park” figure. I would recommend working with a financial planner to run a detailed, personalized model that takes account of your longevity risk, market volatility, tax issues, and any other special circumstances you may have.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.