Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
grok-3-mini-high· xAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I Underpronate. Looking for new low cut hiking shoes. Water proof. What are some good ones

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralmistral-small-3.1-24b-instruct-2503’s answer.
  1. User

    I Underpronate. Looking for new low cut hiking shoes. Water proof. What are some good ones

  2. Assistant

    I understand that you underpronate (also known as supination), which means your feet don't roll inward enough during movement, potentially leading to less shock absorption and more stress on your feet and legs. For hiking shoes, this means prioritizing models with good cushioning, stability, and support to help compensate. Since you're looking for low-cut shoes (which offer more flexibility and less ankle support compared to mid- or high-cut options) and they need to be waterproof, I'll focus on recommendations that include a waterproof membrane like Gore-Tex or equivalent.

    Waterproof hiking shoes typically use materials like Gore-Tex to keep water out while allowing some breathability, but they can sometimes feel less ventilated, so consider that for warmer hikes. Low-cut shoes are great for lighter trails and faster movement but may not be ideal for rugged, uneven terrain where ankle support is key.

    Based on your needs, here are some solid recommendations from reputable brands. I've selected options that emphasize cushioning (to address underpronation) and are widely praised for comfort, durability, and waterproofing. Prices can vary, but I'll give approximate ranges based on current market trends (in USD). Always try on shoes in person if possible, or use retailers with good return policies, as fit is crucial—especially for underpronation, where you might benefit from shoes with a neutral or slightly cushioned midsole.

    Top Recommendations for Low-Cut Waterproof Hiking Shoes

    1. Salomon X Ultra 3 GTX

      • Why it's good for you: Salomon shoes are known for their excellent cushioning and responsive feel, which can help absorb shock for underpronators. The X Ultra series has a low-cut design for agility, and the Gore-Tex membrane ensures reliable waterproofing. It also features a grippy outsole for traction on various terrains.
      • Key features: Cushioned EVA midsole, breathable mesh upper with Gore-Tex, lightweight (around 12-14 oz per shoe), and good stability.
      • Pros: Versatile for day hikes, quick-drying, and comfortable for long wears. Many users with supination report good support.
      • Cons: Can feel a bit stiff initially, and the fit might run narrow, so size up if you have wider feet.
      • Price range: 120–120–160
      • Where to buy: REI, Amazon, or Salomon's website. Check for sales, as Salomon often has good deals.
    2. Merrell Moab 2 Waterproof

      • Why it's good for you: This is a budget-friendly classic with solid cushioning from its EVA midsole, which helps with shock absorption for underpronators. The low-cut design provides flexibility, and the waterproof membrane (not always Gore-Tex, but effective) keeps feet dry. It's a neutral shoe that works well for most foot types.
      • Key features: Cushioned footbed, breathable synthetic leather upper with waterproof coating, lightweight (about 2 lbs per pair), and a Vibram outsole for grip.
      • Pros: Affordable, durable, and comfortable right out of the box. Great for moderate hikes and all-day wear.
      • Cons: Less premium waterproofing than Gore-Tex options, and it might not be as breathable in hot weather.
      • Price range: 100–100–130
      • Where to buy: Widely available at Dick's Sporting Goods, REI, or Amazon. Merrell's site often has discounts.
    3. Keen Targhee III Low Waterproof

      • Why it's good for you: Keen shoes often have excellent arch support and cushioning, which can benefit underpronators by providing stability and shock absorption. The low-cut Targhee III is waterproof with a reliable membrane (Keen's own or Gore-Tex in some versions), and it's designed for comfort on varied terrain.
      • Key features: Cushioned EVA midsole, protective toe cap, breathable leather upper with waterproof lining, and a contoured footbed for support (around 14-16 oz per shoe).
      • Pros: Very comfortable with a roomy fit (good for wider feet), excellent traction, and eco-friendly materials in some versions. Keen is known for durability.
      • Cons: Can be a bit heavier than some competitors, and the waterproofing might trap heat in warmer conditions.
      • Price range: 130–130–160
      • Where to buy: Keen.com, REI, or outdoor retailers. Look for the "WP" (waterproof) version.

    Additional Tips for Choosing Hiking Shoes with Underpronation

    • Focus on cushioning and support: Look for shoes with ample EVA foam or similar materials in the midsole to absorb impact. Avoid overly minimalist shoes that lack cushioning, as they might exacerbate underpronation issues.
    • Fit considerations: Underpronators often benefit from a neutral shoe with good arch support. Aim for a snug heel and midfoot with some room in the toe box. If possible, get a gait analysis at a running or hiking store to confirm the fit.
    • Waterproofing trade-offs: While waterproof shoes are great for wet conditions, they can reduce breathability. If you hike in hot or humid areas, consider hybrid options or shoes with mesh panels for better airflow.
    • Budget and terrain: If you're on a tighter budget, the Merrell Moab 2 is a great entry point. For more technical hikes, Salomon might be better. Also, consider the weight—lighter shoes can reduce fatigue.
    • Other options to explore: If these don't appeal, check out the Columbia Facet or Newton Ridge series (low-cut waterproof models), or Vasque Breeze LT GTX for additional cushioning and support. Brands like Hoka One One have hiking-inspired shoes with max cushioning, but they're less traditional for hiking.

    If you provide more details (like your budget, typical terrain, or any other preferences), I can refine these suggestions further. Happy hiking—staying dry and comfortable will make a big difference! 😊

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.