explain the difference between the cross entropy loss and perplexity when it comes to…
- User
explain the difference between the cross entropy loss and perplexity when it comes to evaluating llms specifically on pretraining
- Assistant
Quick Intuition
• Cross-entropy loss tells you “how surprised the model is—on average—by the next token.”
• Perplexity re-expresses that surprise as “how many equally-likely choices the model is acting as if it had.”Mathematically they’re almost the same number; the only difference is that perplexity is an exponential rescaling of cross-entropy. Still, each plays a distinct role in LLM pre-training.
1. Formal Definitions (per token)
Let
x₁ … x_Tbe the training sequencep_θ(x_t | x_{<t})the model’s predicted distributionlogcan be natural (nats) or base-2 (bits)
Cross-entropy loss
[ \mathcal{L}{CE} = -\frac{1}{T}\sum{t=1}^T \log p_θ(x_t \mid x_{<t}) ]Perplexity
[ \text{PP} = \exp(\mathcal{L}{CE}) \quad\text{(nats)} ] or
[ \text{PP} = 2^{\mathcal{L}{CE}} \quad\text{(bits)} ]
2. Why Two Metrics Instead of One?
Aspect Cross-Entropy Loss Perplexity What it measures Average negative log-likelihood (in bits/nats) Effective “branching factor” Scale Linear in log-prob (–log p) Exponential; easier to read (≥1) Differentiable? Yes → used directly for gradient updates It’s exp()of CE → gradients are identical up to a constant, but in practice we optimize CEHuman interpretability “1.73 nats/token” is abstract “≈5 choices on average” is intuitive Reporting norms During training loops (loss curves) Final evaluation, papers, benchmarks Tokenization sensitivity Same caveat: BPE vs word tokens changes magnitude Same, but change feels more dramatic because of exponentiation
3. Example
Suppose on a validation set your model’s average loss is 1.5 nats/token.
Perplexity =e^{1.5} ≈ 4.48.Interpretation: The model behaves as if for every next token it narrows the possibilities to about 4–5 equally likely options.
4. Practical Tips for LLM Pre-Training
-
Train on cross-entropy, not perplexity.
Optimizers handle the log domain better; gradients are numerically stable. -
Convert to perplexity only for logging.
loss.item().exp()(or2**loss_bits) is all you need. -
Compare apples to apples.
Tokenization, casing, and dataset domain all shift both metrics. Quoting a single perplexity number without context can mislead. -
Watch the base!
• PyTorch/TFCrossEntropyLossuses natural logs → nats.
• Some older NLP code uses base-2 → bits. -
Interpret deltas carefully.
Because PP is exponential, a small loss reduction can look huge in PP:
ΔCE = –0.1nats =ΔPP ≈ –9%.
5. One-Sentence Takeaway
During pre-training, you optimize cross-entropy because it’s the differentiable log-likelihood; you report perplexity (exp of that loss) because it turns “average surprise” into an intuitive “choices left” scale—lower is better for both.
- User
cross entropy loss in llms is never computed in base 2 in real life
- Assistant
You’re basically right that in mainstream LLM-training code we never see a loss computed with a
log₂(·)call. Every deep-learning framework’s cross-entropy primitive (nn.CrossEntropyLoss,torch.nn.functional.log_softmax, TensorFlow’stf.nn.softmax_cross_entropy_with_logits, JAX’soptax.softmax_cross_entropy, …) works in natural log space.Why practitioners stick to natural logs (“nats”):
-
Built-in numerics
•logsumexpandsoftmaxare derived withln; the same constants appear in the backward pass, so staying in the same base avoids an extra divide byln 2.
• Tooling (mixed precision kernels, Tensor Cores, etc.) is tuned forln. -
Gradients are identical up to a constant factor
CE_bits = CE_nats / ln 2. Scaling the whole loss and gradient by 1/ln 2 changes neither the optimizer’s search direction nor the final model—it only forces you to retune the learning-rate schedule. Why bother? -
Historical inertia
The DL community inheritedlnfrom information theory / maximum-likelihood conventions. Early PyTorch/TensorFlow tutorials cemented the norm.
So in practice:
‣ Train = natural-log cross-entropy (nats/token).
‣ Report = convert to perplexity withtorch.exp(loss)(or sometimes stick with the raw nat loss).But “never” is a bit strong—there are still a few corners of NLP/ML where base-2 shows up:
• Bits-per-character (BPC) / bits-per-byte (BPB) metrics in neural compression papers.
• Classical LM benchmarks prior to 2015 (e.g., Penn Treebank word-level work) often quoted “bits per word”.
• Speech recognition uses “bits-per-frame” here and there.Even there, authors typically compute in nats internally and convert at the end:
loss_nats = F.cross_entropy(logits, targets, reduction='mean') # natural loss_bits = loss_nats / math.log(2.0) # optionalSummary • Real-world LLM pre-training optimizes natural-log cross-entropy.
• Switching to base 2 would yield the same model but complicates learning-rate tuning and wastes a divide, so nobody bothers.
• If you see “bits”, it’s almost always post-hocloss_nats / ln 2. -
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.