Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

explain the difference between the cross entropy loss and perplexity when it comes to…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-mini-beta’s answer.
  1. User

    explain the difference between the cross entropy loss and perplexity when it comes to evaluating llms specifically on pretraining

  2. Assistant

    Quick Intuition

    • Cross-entropy loss tells you “how surprised the model is—on average—by the next token.”
    • Perplexity re-expresses that surprise as “how many equally-likely choices the model is acting as if it had.”

    Mathematically they’re almost the same number; the only difference is that perplexity is an exponential rescaling of cross-entropy. Still, each plays a distinct role in LLM pre-training.


    1. Formal Definitions (per token)

    Let

    • x₁ … x_T be the training sequence
    • p_θ(x_t | x_{<t}) the model’s predicted distribution
    • log can be natural (nats) or base-2 (bits)

    Cross-entropy loss
    [ \mathcal{L}{CE} = -\frac{1}{T}\sum{t=1}^T \log p_θ(x_t \mid x_{<t}) ]

    Perplexity
    [ \text{PP} = \exp(\mathcal{L}{CE}) \quad\text{(nats)} ] or
    [ \text{PP} = 2^{\mathcal{L}
    {CE}} \quad\text{(bits)} ]


    2. Why Two Metrics Instead of One?

    AspectCross-Entropy LossPerplexity
    What it measuresAverage negative log-likelihood (in bits/nats)Effective “branching factor”
    ScaleLinear in log-prob (–log p)Exponential; easier to read (≥1)
    Differentiable?Yes → used directly for gradient updatesIt’s exp() of CE → gradients are identical up to a constant, but in practice we optimize CE
    Human interpretability“1.73 nats/token” is abstract“≈5 choices on average” is intuitive
    Reporting normsDuring training loops (loss curves)Final evaluation, papers, benchmarks
    Tokenization sensitivitySame caveat: BPE vs word tokens changes magnitudeSame, but change feels more dramatic because of exponentiation

    3. Example

    Suppose on a validation set your model’s average loss is 1.5 nats/token.
    Perplexity = e^{1.5} ≈ 4.48.

    Interpretation: The model behaves as if for every next token it narrows the possibilities to about 4–5 equally likely options.


    4. Practical Tips for LLM Pre-Training

    1. Train on cross-entropy, not perplexity.
      Optimizers handle the log domain better; gradients are numerically stable.

    2. Convert to perplexity only for logging.
      loss.item().exp() (or 2**loss_bits) is all you need.

    3. Compare apples to apples.
      Tokenization, casing, and dataset domain all shift both metrics. Quoting a single perplexity number without context can mislead.

    4. Watch the base!
      • PyTorch/TF CrossEntropyLoss uses natural logs → nats.
      • Some older NLP code uses base-2 → bits.

    5. Interpret deltas carefully.
      Because PP is exponential, a small loss reduction can look huge in PP:
      ΔCE = –0.1 nats = ΔPP ≈ –9%.


    5. One-Sentence Takeaway

    During pre-training, you optimize cross-entropy because it’s the differentiable log-likelihood; you report perplexity (exp of that loss) because it turns “average surprise” into an intuitive “choices left” scale—lower is better for both.

  3. User

    cross entropy loss in llms is never computed in base 2 in real life

  4. Assistant

    You’re basically right that in mainstream LLM-training code we never see a loss computed with a log₂(·) call. Every deep-learning framework’s cross-entropy primitive (nn.CrossEntropyLoss, torch.nn.functional.log_softmax, TensorFlow’s tf.nn.softmax_cross_entropy_with_logits, JAX’s optax.softmax_cross_entropy, …) works in natural log space.

    Why practitioners stick to natural logs (“nats”):

    1. Built-in numerics
      • logsumexp and softmax are derived with ln; the same constants appear in the backward pass, so staying in the same base avoids an extra divide by ln 2.
      • Tooling (mixed precision kernels, Tensor Cores, etc.) is tuned for ln.

    2. Gradients are identical up to a constant factor
      CE_bits = CE_nats / ln 2. Scaling the whole loss and gradient by 1/ln 2 changes neither the optimizer’s search direction nor the final model—it only forces you to retune the learning-rate schedule. Why bother?

    3. Historical inertia
      The DL community inherited ln from information theory / maximum-likelihood conventions. Early PyTorch/TensorFlow tutorials cemented the norm.

    So in practice:

    ‣ Train = natural-log cross-entropy (nats/token).
    ‣ Report = convert to perplexity with torch.exp(loss) (or sometimes stick with the raw nat loss).

    But “never” is a bit strong—there are still a few corners of NLP/ML where base-2 shows up:

    • Bits-per-character (BPC) / bits-per-byte (BPB) metrics in neural compression papers.
    • Classical LM benchmarks prior to 2015 (e.g., Penn Treebank word-level work) often quoted “bits per word”.
    • Speech recognition uses “bits-per-frame” here and there.

    Even there, authors typically compute in nats internally and convert at the end:

    loss_nats = F.cross_entropy(logits, targets, reduction='mean')  # natural
    loss_bits = loss_nats / math.log(2.0)                          # optional
    

    Summary • Real-world LLM pre-training optimizes natural-log cross-entropy.
    • Switching to base 2 would yield the same model but complicates learning-rate tuning and wastes a divide, so nobody bothers.
    • If you see “bits”, it’s almost always post-hoc loss_nats / ln 2.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.