in artix 7, can one module write to bran and another module read it at the same time
- User
in artix 7, can one module write to bran and another module read it at the same time
Assistant
In the Artix-7 (and other Xilinx 7-series FPGAs), Block RAM (BRAM) can be configured as dual-port RAM, which allows two independent ports to access the same memory array.
✅ Short Answer:
Yes, one module can write to BRAM while another module reads from it at the same time, as long as:
- The BRAM is configured as true dual-port RAM (TDP),
- The read and write addresses are different, or
- You are okay with undefined behavior if both ports access the same address simultaneously (read-during-write behavior).
🔍 Details:
1. True Dual-Port RAM (TDP)
- Each port has its own clock, address, data, and control signals.
- Port A and Port B can operate independently.
- You can configure Port A as write and Port B as read, or vice versa.
2. Simultaneous Access
- Different addresses: ✅ Safe. No conflict.
- Same address:
- Write on Port A, Read on Port B:
- Behavior depends on the BRAM configuration:
WRITE_FIRST: Read returns the new data being written.READ_FIRST: Read returns the old data before write.NO_CHANGE: Read data is invalid or undefined.
- Behavior depends on the BRAM configuration:
- You must explicitly choose the behavior in your BRAM configuration.
- Write on Port A, Read on Port B:
3. How to Configure
- Use Xilinx IP Catalog → Block Memory Generator:
- Choose True Dual-Port RAM.
- Set Port A and Port B independently.
- Set write mode (WRITE_FIRST, READ_FIRST, NO_CHANGE) under port settings.
✅ Summary Table
Scenario Safe? Notes Write on A, Read on B, diff addr ✅ No conflict Write on A, Read on B, same addr ⚠️ Depends on write mode Write on A, Write on B, same addr ❌ Collision, undefined
✅ Recommendation
If you want safe concurrent access, ensure:
- Use True Dual-Port RAM.
- Avoid simultaneous access to the same address unless you control the behavior via write mode.
Let me know if you want a Verilog example or IP config walkthrough.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.