Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinking· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Try again, there is a provable solution

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    Try again, there is a provable solution

  2. Gemini Assistant

    You are absolutely right to push back! My apologies. My previous response was too quick to assume the standard context of the Collatz conjecture, which is usually stated for positive integers. The prompt says "Given an integer n", which includes zero and negative integers. This is the key to a provable solution for infinitely many non-good numbers.

    Let's re-examine the problem allowing for any integer n.

    The function is: f(x)=x/2f(x) = x/2 if xx is even f(x)=3x+1f(x) = 3x+1 if xx is odd

    A number n is good if its sequence eventually reaches 1. A number n is non-good if its sequence never reaches 1.

    Proof that there are infinitely many non-good integers:

    The crux of the matter lies in the behavior of the function f(x) for negative integers and zero.

    Case 1: The Integer 0

    1. Start with n=0n = 0.
    2. f(0)f(0): Since 0 is even, f(0)=0/2=0f(0) = 0/2 = 0.
    3. The sequence generated is 0,0,0,0,…0, 0, 0, 0, \ldots.
    4. The set SS for n=0n=0 is {0}\{0\}.
    5. The number 1 is never reached in this sequence.
    6. Therefore, n=0n=0 is a non-good integer.

    Case 2: Negative Integers

    The Collatz conjecture is primarily concerned with positive integers. The behavior for negative integers is quite different and includes cycles and divergence to negative infinity. Crucially, there is a known cycle that does not include 1.

    Consider the sequence starting with n=−1n = -1:

    1. n=−1n = -1 (odd)   ⟹  f(−1)=3(−1)+1=−2\implies f(-1) = 3(-1) + 1 = -2.
    2. n=−2n = -2 (even)   ⟹  f(−2)=−2/2=−1\implies f(-2) = -2 / 2 = -1.

    The sequence starting from −1-1 is −1,−2,−1,−2,…-1, -2, -1, -2, \ldots. This sequence enters the cycle {−1,−2}\{-1, -2\}. Since 1 is never reached, −1-1 is a non-good integer.

    Now, let's construct an infinite family of non-good integers using this observation:

    Consider the integers of the form nk=−2kn_k = -2^k for k≥1k \geq 1.

    • For k=1k=1, n1=−21=−2n_1 = -2^1 = -2. The sequence is −2,−1,−2,−1,…-2, -1, -2, -1, \ldots. This sequence enters the {−1,−2}\{-1, -2\} cycle and never reaches 1. So, −2-2 is non-good.

    • For k=2k=2, n2=−22=−4n_2 = -2^2 = -4. The sequence is: f(−4)=−4/2=−2f(-4) = -4 / 2 = -2 f(−2)=−2/2=−1f(-2) = -2 / 2 = -1 f(−1)=3(−1)+1=−2f(-1) = 3(-1) + 1 = -2 The sequence for −4-4 is −4,−2,−1,−2,−1,…-4, -2, -1, -2, -1, \ldots. It reaches the {−1,−2}\{-1, -2\} cycle and never reaches 1. So, −4-4 is non-good.

    • For k=3k=3, n3=−23=−8n_3 = -2^3 = -8. The sequence is: f(−8)=−8/2=−4f(-8) = -8 / 2 = -4 f(−4)=−4/2=−2f(-4) = -4 / 2 = -2 f(−2)=−2/2=−1f(-2) = -2 / 2 = -1 f(−1)=3(−1)+1=−2f(-1) = 3(-1) + 1 = -2 The sequence for −8-8 is −8,−4,−2,−1,−2,−1,…-8, -4, -2, -1, -2, -1, \ldots. It reaches the {−1,−2}\{-1, -2\} cycle and never reaches 1. So, −8-8 is non-good.

    Generalization:

    For any integer k≥1k \geq 1, let nk=−2kn_k = -2^k. Since −2k-2^k is negative and even for k≥1k \geq 1, the first step is f(−2k)=−2k/2=−2k−1f(-2^k) = -2^k / 2 = -2^{k-1}. Repeating this process kk times, we get: −2k→−2k−1→−2k−2→⋯→−21=−2-2^k \to -2^{k-1} \to -2^{k-2} \to \cdots \to -2^1 = -2. Once the sequence reaches −2-2, it then enters the cycle {−2,−1}\{-2, -1\}, as shown above. Therefore, for every k≥1k \geq 1, the number −2k-2^k is a non-good integer because its sequence eventually enters the {−1,−2}\{-1, -2\} cycle and never reaches 1.

    The set {−2,−4,−8,−16,−32,…}\{ -2, -4, -8, -16, -32, \ldots \} is an infinite set of non-good integers.

    Conclusion:

    By considering the domain of "any integer n" (which includes zero and negative numbers) as stated in the problem, we can easily prove the existence of infinitely many non-good integers by identifying numbers whose sequences fall into cycles or never reach 1. The set of negative powers of two {−2k∣k≥1}\{ -2^k \mid k \geq 1 \} provides an infinite family of such numbers.

    This is a clever framing of the problem that circumvents the unsolved nature of the Collatz conjecture for positive integers!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.