Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
grok-3-preview-02-24· xAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Give me another one

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking’s answer.
  1. User

    Give me another one

  2. Assistant

    The Quiet Mitzvah

    Mrs. Esther Friedman was not the type to make speeches or lead committees. In her small Brooklyn shul, she was known simply as the woman who sat in the third row of the women’s section, her siddur worn from decades of use. But what most people didn’t know was that Mrs. Friedman had been quietly changing lives for years.

    It started twenty years ago, when a young mother named Rivka moved to the neighborhood. Rivka was newly observant, overwhelmed by the demands of raising three small children while learning the ropes of a frum lifestyle. One Shabbos, after davening, Mrs. Friedman noticed Rivka struggling to carry her toddler while pushing a stroller down the shul steps. Without a word, Mrs. Friedman took the toddler’s hand and walked them home.

    The next week, Mrs. Friedman was waiting at the shul entrance after davening, ready to help again. This became their routine. Over time, Rivka confided in Mrs. Friedman about her challenges—how she felt inadequate compared to women who’d grown up frum, how she worried about teaching her children properly. Mrs. Friedman listened patiently, offering practical advice: “Start with one brachah at a time. Children learn what they see.”

    When Rivka’s oldest daughter turned three, Mrs. Friedman showed up at their apartment with a small package—a children’s siddur and a handwritten note: “For your daughter’s first tefillos. You’re doing beautifully.” Rivka cried when she read it.

    Mrs. Friedman’s quiet acts of kindness didn’t stop with Rivka. She noticed other women in the community who needed support—newlyweds unsure how to kasher a kitchen, older widows who felt forgotten, baalos teshuva navigating unfamiliar customs. She never announced her intentions or sought recognition. She simply showed up.

    One year, when a young couple couldn’t afford a proper Shabbos tablecloth, Mrs. Friedman “happened” to have an extra one, still in its packaging, which she insisted they take. When a single mother struggled to pay for her son’s bar mitzvah, Mrs. Friedman discreetly arranged for a caterer to donate food, claiming it was a “last-minute cancellation.”

    Her impact became clear at her shivah, years later. Woman after woman came forward with stories of Mrs. Friedman’s quiet help. Rivka, now a confident mother of five, spoke about how Mrs. Friedman’s encouragement had kept her going during those early, uncertain years. A widow shared how Mrs. Friedman had called every Erev Shabbos to check in, easing her loneliness. A young rebbetzin credited Mrs. Friedman with teaching her the practical skills that made her feel at home in the community.

    Mrs. Friedman’s legacy wasn’t in grand gestures or public accolades. It was in the countless small acts of chesed that built up others, one person at a time. Her example taught her community a powerful lesson: you don’t need a title or a spotlight to make a difference. Sometimes, the most inspiring mitzvos are the ones done quietly, with no expectation of reward.

  3. User

    give me another one which is a true story

  4. Assistant

    The Shabbos Clock

    When Rabbi Yitzchak Ruderman, the rosh yeshiva of Ner Israel in Baltimore, passed away in 1987, his talmidim gathered to share stories of his greatness. Among the many accounts of his Torah brilliance and leadership, one simple story stood out—a true incident that captured his extraordinary sensitivity to others, as recounted by those who witnessed it.

    One Friday afternoon, a young talmid named Dovid noticed Rabbi Ruderman walking briskly through the yeshiva dormitory, an unusual sight for the elderly rosh yeshiva. Dovid, curious, followed at a distance. Rabbi Ruderman stopped at the room of a bochur named Shmuel, a quiet student who struggled socially and often kept to himself. Shmuel wasn’t in his room, but Rabbi Ruderman entered anyway, looked around, and then did something unexpected: he adjusted the Shabbos clock on Shmuel’s desk, setting it to turn on the room’s light earlier than it had been programmed.

    Dovid, puzzled, later asked another rebbi about what he’d seen. The rebbi explained: “Shmuel has been having a hard time. The rosh yeshiva noticed that he often stays in his room on Friday nights, missing the energy of the yeshiva’s communal seudah. Last week, Rav Ruderman saw that Shmuel’s light was off early, meaning he was sitting alone in the dark. He didn’t want Shmuel to feel isolated, so he made sure the light would come on before Shabbos started, to give him some warmth and encouragement.”

    Dovid was stunned. Rabbi Ruderman, who spent his days immersed in Torah at the highest levels and guiding hundreds of students, had taken the time to notice one struggling bochur’s emotional state—and to act on it in the most discreet way possible. He didn’t call attention to Shmuel’s struggles or embarrass him by singling him out. Instead, he quietly adjusted a clock, ensuring Shmuel would have light, both literally and figuratively.

    That small act had a profound impact. Shmuel, unaware of who had adjusted his clock, began to feel a little less alone. Over time, with encouragement from rebbeim and friends, he started joining the yeshiva’s Friday night seudos, eventually becoming an active part of the community. Years later, Shmuel became a respected rebbi himself, known for his patience with students who felt out of place.

    At Rabbi Ruderman’s shivah, Dovid shared this story, and it spread among the talmidim as an example of what true gadlus looks like—not just in Torah learning, but in caring for others. Rabbi Ruderman’s greatness wasn’t only in his shiurim or his seforim; it was in his ability to see the needs of every individual, no matter how small they seemed, and to address them with humility and kindness.

    This true story, passed down by those who knew Rabbi Ruderman, reminds us that the greatest acts of inspiration often come not from grand gestures, but from the quiet, thoughtful mitzvos that uplift others when they need it most.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.