Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
DeepSeekdeepseek-r1-0528· DeepSeekHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

WHAT DOCUMENT TO BE SUBMITTED TO SOLVE THIS: However, the documents provided by…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    WHAT DOCUMENT TO BE SUBMITTED TO SOLVE THIS: However, the documents provided by themselves do not prove your ownership or directorship of the company and your supporting information offers no evidence of the nature, size and scale of its commercial activities.

  2. DeepSeek Assistant

    Based on the feedback you received, you need to submit two distinct categories of documents to address the deficiencies:

    1. Proof of Ownership/Directorship: * Official Company Register Extract: A current document from the official government business registry (e.g., Companies House in the UK, Secretary of State in the US, ASIC in Australia, equivalent elsewhere) clearly listing you as a Director and/or Shareholder/Owner. Ensure it shows your name and the relevant role(s). * Share Certificate(s): If you are a shareholder/owner, a copy of the share certificate(s) in your name, showing the number/percentage of shares you hold. * Register of Members/Directors: Internal company documents like the official Register of Members (Shareholders) and Register of Directors, signed and dated, showing your ownership stake and/or directorship. * Appointment Letter/Minutes: Minutes of the Board Meeting or Shareholder Resolution formally appointing you as a Director or confirming your shareholding. * Articles of Incorporation/Association + Memorandum: These foundational documents often list initial directors and shareholders. If you were an initial member, include these, plus evidence of current status (like the Register Extract). * Notarized Affidavit/Declaration: If official registry documents are delayed or unclear, a legally notarized affidavit where you declare your ownership percentage, directorship role, and the date you assumed the role(s), signed under penalty of perjury.

    2. Proof of Nature, Size, and Scale of Commercial Activities: * Financial Statements: Crucial Evidence. Submit: * Audited Financial Statements (Best): Profit & Loss, Balance Sheet, Cash Flow Statement for the most recent full financial year (audited if possible). * Management Accounts: Detailed Profit & Loss statements and Balance Sheets for the current year-to-date. * Business Bank Statements: 3-6 months of business bank statements showing regular trading income and business expenses (highlight key transactions). This demonstrates operational cash flow. * Tax Documents: * Recent Business Tax Returns (e.g., Corporation Tax, VAT/GST/Sales Tax returns). * Tax registration certificates. * Commercial Contracts: Copies of active, significant contracts with clients, suppliers, or distributors (redact sensitive commercial terms if necessary). These show the nature of the business. * Invoices: Examples of recent invoices issued by your company to customers and received by your company from suppliers. * Evidence of Premises/Operations: * Commercial Lease Agreement for business premises. * Business Rates/Council Tax bill for the premises. * Utility bills for the business premises. * Photos of the business premises, operations, or staff (if relevant and professional). * Marketing Materials: Company website, brochure, product catalog, active social media pages - demonstrating the nature of the business and its market presence (scale). * Organizational Chart: Showing the structure and number of employees (size). * Letter from Accountant/Banker: A professional letter on letterhead confirming the company's active trading status, core business activities, and approximate scale (e.g., annual turnover, number of employees).

    Key Recommendations:

    1. Cover Letter: Include a cover letter explicitly listing the documents provided and mapping them to the two requirements: Proof of Ownership/Directorship and Proof of Commercial Activity/Scale.
    2. Clarity: Ensure all documents are clear, legible, and complete. Highlight your name and role on registry documents.
    3. Relevance: Focus on documents from the last 1-2 years to show current status and activity.
    4. Official Sources: Prioritize documents from government registries, banks, accountants, and tax authorities. They carry the most weight.
    5. Consistency: Ensure the company name and address are consistent across all documents.
    6. Volume: Provide multiple pieces of evidence for each requirement. Don't rely on just one document per category.

    By submitting a comprehensive package addressing both the ownership/directorship proof and the evidence of active commercial operations (nature, size, scale), you directly counter the specific reasons for the previous rejection. Focus particularly on official registry documents and recent financial statements/bank records as they are the most authoritative proofs.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.