Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What's the best pizza in Ohio

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking’s answer.
  1. User

    What's the best pizza in Ohio

  2. Assistant

    Ohio has an underrated but vibrant pizza scene, with many styles represented—from Columbus-style thin crust to traditional Neapolitan, New York slices, and inventive artisan pies. Here's a list of some of the best and most beloved pizza spots in Ohio, based on local acclaim, national awards, and fan favorites:


    🍕 Best Pizza in Ohio (Top Picks by City/Region)

    1. Mikey’s Late Night Slice – Columbus

    • Style: Columbus-style meets creative artisan
    • What to try: "Spicy Ass Pepperoni" and "Cheezus Crust"
    • Why it’s great: Famous for its bold, irreverent attitude and flavors. Open late. Locals love the sauce bar.

    2. Mama Santa's – Cleveland (Little Italy)

    • Style: Classic Italian-American
    • What to try: Plain cheese or sausage pizza
    • Why it’s great: Old-school charm in Cleveland's Little Italy. Often considered one of the best for traditional pies.

    3. Harvest Pizzeria – Columbus / Cincinnati

    • Style: Artisan, farm-to-table
    • What to try: Spicy Yuma or the Ohio Double Bacon
    • Why it’s great: Seasonal ingredients, creative topping combos, elevated flavors.

    4. Dewey’s Pizza – Cincinnati (several locations)

    • Style: Gourmet American-style pizza
    • What to try: Ryan’s Inferno, Edgar Allan Poe
    • Why it’s great: Consistently high quality, inventive topping combos — a local favorite.

    5. Bricco – Akron

    • Style: Brick-oven, gourmet artisan
    • What to try: Mini Goat Cheese or Prosciutto Arugula
    • Why it’s great: A standout in Akron’s food scene—artisan toppings and fresh crust.

    6. Gatto's – Toledo

    • Style: New York-style
    • What to try: Large cheese slice or Margherita
    • Why it’s great: Thin, chewy crust; huge slices. Locals claim it's the best slice in northwest Ohio.

    7. Ohio Pizza Nation Favorite: “Tommy’s Pizza” – Columbus

    • Style: Columbus-style (thin cracker crust, edge-to-edge toppings)
    • What to try: Pepperoni or Deluxe
    • Why it’s great: An Ohio institution. If you’ve never tried Columbus-style, this is the place to start.

    🏆 Nationally Recognized:

    Angelo’s Pizza – Lakewood (Cleveland area)

    • Featured on Food Network’s "Best Thing I Ever Ate"
    • Famous for their deep-dish & specialty pizzas
    • Veggie Pizza and White Pizza are fan favorites

    Honorable Mentions:

    • Piazza Pizza – Youngstown (a Mahoning Valley staple)
    • Pizzafiore – Dayton (Neapolitan-style)
    • Old Scratch Pizza – Dayton (wood-fired Neapolitan, craft beer vibe)

    🔥 What Makes Ohio Pizza Unique?

    • Columbus-Style Pizza: Thin, crispy, square-cut
    • Diversity of Styles: Ohio represents Midwest innovation + East Coast traditions
    • Strong local pride: Many pizzerias have been family-run for generations

    👑 So… What’s “The Best”?

    If you want a classic Ohio experience, try the original Tommy’s Pizza (Columbus).

    For gourmet lovers, Harvest Pizzeria is hard to beat statewide.

    For New York-style, hit up Gatto’s (Toledo) or Angelo’s (Lakewood) for a deeper, heartier experience.


    Want a personalized recommendation based on your location or favorite pizza style? Let me know! 🍕

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.