Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-lite-preview-06-17-thinking· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What happens if I blow up $\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2)$ at its unique closed point?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514’s answer.
  1. User

    What happens if I blow up Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2) at its unique closed point?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Let X=Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)X = \operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2). Let R=k[x]/(x2)R = k[x]/(x^2).

    1. Identify the scheme and the point: The ring R=k[x]/(x2)R = k[x]/(x^2) has only one prime ideal, m=(x)/(x2)\mathfrak{m} = (x)/(x^2). This corresponds to the unique point pp in the topological space X=Spec⁡RX = \operatorname{Spec} R. Since m\mathfrak{m} is the only prime ideal, it must also be the nilradical of RR. The quotient ring R/m≅(k[x]/(x2))/((x)/(x2))≅k[x]/(x2,x)≅k[x]/(x)≅kR/\mathfrak{m} \cong (k[x]/(x^2))/((x)/(x^2)) \cong k[x]/(x^2, x) \cong k[x]/(x) \cong k, which is a field. Therefore, m\mathfrak{m} is a maximal ideal, and the point pp is a closed point.

    2. The Blow-Up Construction: The blow-up of a scheme XX at a point pp is defined using the ideal sheaf I\mathcal{I} corresponding to pp. If X=Spec⁡RX = \operatorname{Spec} R, the blow-up along the ideal I⊂RI \subset R is given by Bl⁡I(X)=Proj⁡R(I)\operatorname{Bl}_I(X) = \operatorname{Proj} \mathcal{R}(I), where R(I)=⨁n≥0Intn\mathcal{R}(I) = \bigoplus_{n \ge 0} I^n t^n is the Rees algebra of II, viewed as a graded subalgebra of R[t]R[t]. In our case, X=Spec⁡RX = \operatorname{Spec} R and the ideal is I=m=(x)I = \mathfrak{m} = (x). We need to compute the Rees algebra R(m)\mathcal{R}(\mathfrak{m}). The powers of m\mathfrak{m} are:

      • m0=R=k[x]/(x2)\mathfrak{m}^0 = R = k[x]/(x^2)
      • m1=m=(x)\mathfrak{m}^1 = \mathfrak{m} = (x)
      • m2=(x2)=(0)\mathfrak{m}^2 = (x^2) = (0) in RR.
      • mn=(0)\mathfrak{m}^n = (0) for all n≥2n \ge 2. The Rees algebra is R(m)=R⊕mt=k[x,t]/(x2,xt)\mathcal{R}(\mathfrak{m}) = R \oplus \mathfrak{m}t = k[x, t]/(x^2, xt). Let A=k[x,t]/(x2,xt)A = k[x, t]/(x^2, xt). The blow-up is Bl⁡m(X)=Proj⁡A\operatorname{Bl}_{\mathfrak{m}}(X) = \operatorname{Proj} A.
    3. Analyzing Proj A: To compute Proj⁡A\operatorname{Proj} A, we need to consider AA as a graded ring. We can assign degrees to xx and tt. Let's try assigning deg⁡x=1\deg x = 1 and deg⁡t=1\deg t = 1. A=k[x,t]/(x2,xt)A = k[x, t]/(x^2, xt). The graded components are:

      • A0=kA_0 = k (degree 0)
      • A1=kx⊕ktA_1 = kx \oplus kt (degree 1)
      • A2=kx2⊕kxt⊕kt2A_2 = kx^2 \oplus kxt \oplus kt^2? Since x2=0x^2=0 and xt=0xt=0 in AA, A2=kt2A_2 = kt^2.
      • A3=kx2t⊕kxt2=0⊕0=0A_3 = kx^2t \oplus kxt^2 = 0 \oplus 0 = 0.
      • An=0A_n = 0 for all n≥3n \ge 3. So A=k⊕(kx⊕kt)⊕kt2A = k \oplus (kx \oplus kt) \oplus kt^2. The Proj construction typically applies to standard graded rings, usually polynomial rings or quotients thereof. Let's try another grading: deg⁡x=2,deg⁡t=1\deg x = 2, \deg t = 1. A=k[x,t]/(x2,xt)A = k[x, t]/(x^2, xt).
      • A0=kA_0 = k
      • A1=ktA_1 = kt
      • A2=kx2⊕kt2⊕kxtA_2 = kx^2 \oplus kt^2 \oplus kxt? Since x2=0,xt=0x^2=0, xt=0. A2=kt2A_2 = kt^2.
      • A3=kx2t⊕kt3⊕kxt2A_3 = kx^2t \oplus kt^3 \oplus kxt^2? A3=kt3A_3 = kt^3.
      • An=ktnA_n = kt^n for n≥1n \ge 1. So A=k⊕kt⊕kt2⊕⋯≅k[t]A = k \oplus kt \oplus kt^2 \oplus \dots \cong k[t]. The Proj of k[t]k[t] is Proj⁡k[T]\operatorname{Proj} k[T] (where T=tT=t), which corresponds to a single point (it's essentially Spec⁡k[T0/T1]\operatorname{Spec} k[T_0/T_1] for T0=1,T1=tT_0=1, T_1=t, the coordinate ring is k[t]k[t]).
    4. Alternative perspective using the Normal Cone: For a local ring (R,m)(R, \mathfrak{m}), the blow-up Bl⁡m(Spec⁡R)\operatorname{Bl}_{\mathfrak{m}}(\operatorname{Spec} R) is often described as Proj⁡(gr⁡m(R))\operatorname{Proj}(\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R)), where gr⁡m(R)=⨁n≥0mn/mn+1\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R) = \bigoplus_{n \ge 0} \mathfrak{m}^n / \mathfrak{m}^{n+1} is the associated graded ring. In our case, R=k[x]/(x2)R=k[x]/(x^2) and m=(x)\mathfrak{m}=(x). We have m2=(0)\mathfrak{m}^2=(0). So gr⁡m(R)=R/m⊕m/m2=k⊕(x)/0≅k⊕k\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R) = R/\mathfrak{m} \oplus \mathfrak{m}/\mathfrak{m}^2 = k \oplus (x)/0 \cong k \oplus k. Let V=m/m2V = \mathfrak{m}/\mathfrak{m}^2. V≅kV \cong k. The symmetric algebra S(V)≅k[T]S(V) \cong k[T], where TT corresponds to the class of xx in m/m2\mathfrak{m}/\mathfrak{m}^2. Proj⁡(S(V))=Proj⁡(k[T])\operatorname{Proj}(S(V)) = \operatorname{Proj}(k[T]). As we saw, this represents a single point. This approach is consistent with the result obtained from the Rees algebra under a suitable grading.

    5. Interpretation: The scheme X=Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)X = \operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2) is essentially a single point pp, but with non-trivial infinitesimal information captured by the nilpotent element xx such that x2=0x^2=0. Blowing up the point pp means replacing pp with the projectivized tangent space (or more accurately, the projectivized normal cone). The normal cone is P(m/m2)=P(k)\mathbb{P}(\mathfrak{m}/\mathfrak{m}^2) = \mathbb{P}(k), which is P0\mathbb{P}^0, representing a single point. So, the blow-up operation replaces the point pp with another point. The resulting scheme is still just a single point, isomorphic to the original scheme XX.

    Conclusion: If you blow up Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2) at its unique closed point, the resulting scheme is still Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2), which is just a single point. The blow-up map is the identity map on this point. The infinitesimal structure (x2=0x^2=0) remains.

  3. User

    Are you sure? I'm thinking I actually get the empty scheme. Which of us is incorrect?

  4. Gemini Assistant

    You raise a very good point, and it's important to be sure about this. Let's re-examine the process carefully.

    The scheme is X=Spec⁡RX = \operatorname{Spec} R, where R=k[x]/(x2)R = k[x]/(x^2). The unique point pp corresponds to the maximal ideal m=(x)⊂R\mathfrak{m} = (x) \subset R. We know R/m≅kR/\mathfrak{m} \cong k. The powers of the maximal ideal are m=(x)\mathfrak{m} = (x) and m2=(x2)=(0)\mathfrak{m}^2 = (x^2) = (0).

    The Blow-Up Construction

    The standard way to construct the blow-up of XX at the point pp (corresponding to the ideal m\mathfrak{m}) is Bl⁡m(X)=Proj⁡(⨁n≥0mntn)\operatorname{Bl}_{\mathfrak{m}}(X) = \operatorname{Proj}(\bigoplus_{n \ge 0} \mathfrak{m}^n t^n), where tt is a formal variable. This graded ring is called the Rees algebra, denoted R(m)\mathcal{R}(\mathfrak{m}).

    Let's compute the Rees algebra R(m)\mathcal{R}(\mathfrak{m}) for R=k[x]/(x2)R = k[x]/(x^2) and m=(x)\mathfrak{m}=(x): R(m)=m0⊕m1t⊕m2t2⊕…\mathcal{R}(\mathfrak{m}) = \mathfrak{m}^0 \oplus \mathfrak{m}^1 t \oplus \mathfrak{m}^2 t^2 \oplus \dots R(m)=R⊕(x)t⊕(0)t2⊕…\mathcal{R}(\mathfrak{m}) = R \oplus (x)t \oplus (0)t^2 \oplus \dots R(m)=k[x]/(x2)⊕(x)t\mathcal{R}(\mathfrak{m}) = k[x]/(x^2) \oplus (x)t This can be represented as the ring k[x,t]/(x2,xt)k[x, t] / (x^2, xt). Let A=k[x,t]/(x2,xt)A = k[x, t] / (x^2, xt).

    To compute Proj⁡A\operatorname{Proj} A, we need to give AA a standard grading. The natural grading comes from assigning degree 1 to both xx and tt: deg⁡x=1\deg x = 1, deg⁡t=1\deg t = 1. Then x2x^2 has degree 2, and xtxt has degree 2. The ideal (x2,xt)(x^2, xt) is homogeneous in this grading. The graded components of AA are: A0=kA_0 = k (constants) A1=kx⊕ktA_1 = kx \oplus kt (linear terms) A2=kt2A_2 = kt^2 (since x2=0x^2=0 and xt=0xt=0 in AA) An=ktnA_n = kt^n for n≥2n \ge 2 (since x2=0x^2=0 and xt=0xt=0)

    The Proj construction Proj⁡A\operatorname{Proj} A is typically defined as the set of homogeneous prime ideals of AA other than the irrelevant ideal A+=⨁n>0AnA_+ = \bigoplus_{n>0} A_n. The homogeneous prime ideals of A=k[x,t]/(x2,xt)A = k[x, t]/(x^2, xt) are (t)(t) and (x,t)(x,t). The irrelevant ideal is A+=(x,t,t2,t3,… )=(x,t)A_+ = (x, t, t^2, t^3, \dots) = (x, t). So, Proj⁡A=Spec⁡A∖{(x,t)}\operatorname{Proj} A = \operatorname{Spec} A \setminus \{ (x,t) \}. The prime ideal (t)(t) corresponds to the ring A/(t)=k[x]/(x2)A/(t) = k[x]/(x^2), which is isomorphic to RR. The prime ideal (x,t)(x,t) corresponds to the ring A/(x,t)=kA/(x,t) = k.

    Therefore, Proj⁡A=Spec⁡A/(x,t)=Spec⁡(A/(t))=Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Proj} A = \operatorname{Spec} A / (x,t) = \operatorname{Spec} (A/(t)) = \operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2). The resulting scheme is Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2), which is isomorphic to the original scheme XX. It is still just a single point.

    Alternative Approach: Normal Cone

    Another common definition or intuition for the blow-up at a point pp of X=Spec⁡RX=\operatorname{Spec} R involves the normal cone, which is Proj⁡(gr⁡m(R))\operatorname{Proj}(\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R)), where gr⁡m(R)=⨁n≥0mn/mn+1\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R) = \bigoplus_{n \ge 0} \mathfrak{m}^n / \mathfrak{m}^{n+1} is the associated graded ring.

    Let's compute gr⁡m(R)\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R): m0=R=k[x]/(x2)\mathfrak{m}^0 = R = k[x]/(x^2) m1=m=(x)\mathfrak{m}^1 = \mathfrak{m} = (x) m2=(0)\mathfrak{m}^2 = (0) mn=(0)\mathfrak{m}^n = (0) for n≥2n \ge 2.

    gr⁡m(R)=m0/m1⊕m1/m2⊕m2/m3⊕…\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R) = \mathfrak{m}^0/\mathfrak{m}^1 \oplus \mathfrak{m}^1/\mathfrak{m}^2 \oplus \mathfrak{m}^2/\mathfrak{m}^3 \oplus \dots gr⁡m(R)=(k[x]/(x2))/(x)⊕(x)/(0)⊕(0)/(0)⊕…\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R) = (k[x]/(x^2)) / (x) \oplus (x)/(0) \oplus (0)/(0) \oplus \dots gr⁡m(R)=k⊕k\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R) = k \oplus k

    Let tt be the generator of the second factor kk (corresponding to the class of xx in m/m2\mathfrak{m}/\mathfrak{m}^2). The multiplication rule in the associated graded ring is (a(modmi+1))⋅(b(modmj+1))=ab(modmi+j+1)(a \pmod{\mathfrak{m}^{i+1}}) \cdot (b \pmod{\mathfrak{m}^{j+1}}) = ab \pmod{\mathfrak{m}^{i+j+1}}. So, t⋅tt \cdot t corresponds to the class of x⋅x=x2x \cdot x = x^2 in m2/m3\mathfrak{m}^2/\mathfrak{m}^3. Since x2=0x^2=0, this class is 00. Thus, gr⁡m(R)≅k[t]/(t2)\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R) \cong k[t]/(t^2), where deg⁡t=1\deg t = 1.

    Now we compute Proj⁡(gr⁡m(R))=Proj⁡(k[t]/(t2))\operatorname{Proj}(\operatorname{gr}_{\mathfrak{m}}(R)) = \operatorname{Proj}(k[t]/(t^2)). Let S=k[t]/(t2)S = k[t]/(t^2). S0=kS_0 = k, S1=ktS_1 = kt, Sn=0S_n=0 for n≥2n \ge 2. The Proj construction considers Spec⁡S(f)\operatorname{Spec} S_{(f)} for non-zero homogeneous elements f∈Sf \in S. The only non-zero homogeneous elements are the non-zero constants in S0=kS_0 = k. Let's choose f=1f=1. S(1)S_{(1)} is the localization of SS by powers of 11, which is just SS itself. So, Proj⁡(k[t]/(t2))=Spec⁡(k[t]/(t2))\operatorname{Proj}(k[t]/(t^2)) = \operatorname{Spec}(k[t]/(t^2)). This scheme is again isomorphic to Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2).

    Conclusion and Addressing Your Doubt

    Both standard methods show that the blow-up of Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2) at its unique closed point results in a scheme isomorphic to the original scheme, Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2). This scheme consists of a single point.

    Why you might think it's the empty scheme:

    The empty scheme corresponds to the zero ring. Our original scheme Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2) corresponds to the non-zero ring k[x]/(x2)k[x]/(x^2). Blowing up a point replaces that point with the projectivized normal cone. The normal cone is P(m/m2)\mathbb{P}(\mathfrak{m}/\mathfrak{m}^2). In our case, m/m2≅k\mathfrak{m}/\mathfrak{m}^2 \cong k. This is a 1-dimensional vector space over kk. The projectivization is P(k)=P0\mathbb{P}(k) = \mathbb{P}^0, which is a single point (representing the lines through the origin in a 1D vector space). Since the normal cone is not empty (it's P0\mathbb{P}^0), the blow-up replaces the original point with another point. The resulting scheme is not empty.

    Perhaps there's confusion with blowing up the entire variety along an ideal II. If I=RI=R (the whole ring), the Rees algebra ⨁Intn=⨁Rtn=R[t]\bigoplus I^n t^n = \bigoplus R t^n = R[t]. Then Proj⁡R[t]=Spec⁡R\operatorname{Proj} R[t] = \operatorname{Spec} R. This is still not empty. Maybe the confusion comes from some edge case or a different operation?

    Based on the standard definitions of blow-ups in algebraic geometry, the result is not the empty scheme. It is isomorphic to the original scheme Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2).

  5. User

    More generally, I think blowing up any nilpotent ideal sheaf gives an empty scheme.

  6. Gemini Assistant

    That's an interesting claim, and it touches on a subtle point about blow-ups and the empty scheme. Let's carefully analyze it.

    The blow-up of a scheme XX along an ideal sheaf I\mathcal{I} is given by Bl⁡I(X)=Proj⁡(R(I))\operatorname{Bl}_{\mathcal{I}}(X) = \operatorname{Proj}(\mathcal{R}(\mathcal{I})), where R(I)=⨁n≥0Intn\mathcal{R}(\mathcal{I}) = \bigoplus_{n \ge 0} \mathcal{I}^n t^n is the Rees algebra of I\mathcal{I}. The scheme Proj⁡(A)\operatorname{Proj}(A) is empty if and only if the ideal A+=⨁n>0AnA_+ = \bigoplus_{n>0} A_n contains the unit element 11. This happens if and only if the degree 0 component A0A_0 is zero.

    In our case, A=R(I)A = \mathcal{R}(\mathcal{I}), so A0=I0=OXA_0 = \mathcal{I}^0 = \mathcal{O}_X. Therefore, Proj⁡(R(I))\operatorname{Proj}(\mathcal{R}(\mathcal{I})) is empty if and only if OX=0\mathcal{O}_X = 0, which means XX itself is the empty scheme.

    This implies that if you start with a non-empty scheme XX, blowing up any ideal sheaf I\mathcal{I} (nilpotent or not) will result in a non-empty scheme.

    Let's revisit your specific example: X=Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)X = \operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2). The unique closed point pp corresponds to the maximal ideal m=(x)\mathfrak{m}=(x). This ideal m\mathfrak{m} is nilpotent, since m2=(x2)=(0)\mathfrak{m}^2 = (x^2) = (0).

    We computed the Rees algebra for m\mathfrak{m} as A=R(m)=k[x,t]/(x2,xt)A = \mathcal{R}(\mathfrak{m}) = k[x, t]/(x^2, xt). The degree 0 part of this algebra is A0=kA_0 = k. Since k≠0k \neq 0, Proj⁡(A)\operatorname{Proj}(A) is not empty. As we found, it is isomorphic to Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2), the original scheme.

    Where your statement might seem correct (The Special Case):

    Consider the simplest non-empty scheme: X=Spec⁡kX = \operatorname{Spec} k, where kk is a field. This scheme consists of a single point. The only ideal in kk is the zero ideal I=(0)I=(0). Is I=(0)I=(0) a nilpotent ideal? Yes, because I1=(0)I^1 = (0). Let's blow up Spec⁡k\operatorname{Spec} k at the ideal I=(0)I=(0). The Rees algebra is R((0))=⨁n≥0(0)ntn=(0)0⊕(0)1t⊕(0)2t2⊕⋯=k⊕0t⊕0t2⊕…\mathcal{R}((0)) = \bigoplus_{n \ge 0} (0)^n t^n = (0)^0 \oplus (0)^1 t \oplus (0)^2 t^2 \oplus \dots = k \oplus 0t \oplus 0t^2 \oplus \dots. So, R((0))=k\mathcal{R}((0)) = k. Now we compute Proj⁡(k)\operatorname{Proj}(k). The graded ring A=kA=k has only one homogeneous prime ideal, which is (0)(0). The irrelevant ideal is A+=⨁n>0An=0A_+ = \bigoplus_{n>0} A_n = 0. The definition of Proj⁡(A)\operatorname{Proj}(A) is the set of homogeneous prime ideals PP such that P⊉A+P \not\supseteq A_+. In this case, the only homogeneous prime ideal is P=(0)P=(0), and A+=0A_+=0. Since (0)⊇0(0) \supseteq 0, this ideal PP is excluded. Thus, Proj⁡(k)\operatorname{Proj}(k) is the empty set.

    So, you are correct that blowing up Spec⁡k\operatorname{Spec} k at the zero ideal (0)(0) results in the empty scheme. The zero ideal (0)(0) is indeed a nilpotent ideal.

    Why your general statement is incorrect:

    The critical difference lies in the degree 0 component of the Rees algebra.

    1. When blowing up Spec⁡k\operatorname{Spec} k at I=(0)I=(0), the Rees algebra is R((0))=k\mathcal{R}((0))=k. Here, A0=kA_0=k, but all AnA_n for n>0n>0 are 00. So A+=0A_+ = 0. The only prime ideal (0)(0) is contained in A+A_+, making Proj⁡(k)\operatorname{Proj}(k) empty.
    2. When blowing up Spec⁡k[x]/(x2)\operatorname{Spec} k[x]/(x^2) at I=(x)I=(x), the Rees algebra is A=k[x,t]/(x2,xt)A = k[x,t]/(x^2,xt). Here, A0=kA_0=k, A1=kx⊕ktA_1=kx \oplus kt, A2=kt2A_2=kt^2, etc. The irrelevant ideal A+=A1⊕A2⊕…A_+ = A_1 \oplus A_2 \oplus \dots is not the whole ring AA, because A0=kA_0=k is not contained in A+A_+. Hence, Proj⁡(A)\operatorname{Proj}(A) is not empty.

    The statement "blowing up any nilpotent ideal sheaf gives an empty scheme" is false. The condition for the blow-up Proj⁡(R(I))\operatorname{Proj}(\mathcal{R}(\mathcal{I})) to be empty is precisely that the base scheme XX itself is empty (OX=0\mathcal{O}_X = 0), regardless of the ideal sheaf I\mathcal{I}. The only case where a nilpotent ideal leads to an empty blow-up is when the starting scheme is Spec⁡k\operatorname{Spec} k and the ideal is (0)(0).

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.