Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash-preview-04-17· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

is it possible to detect ir by just lighting an led, turn it off, and measuring how much…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o4-mini-2025-04-16’s answer.
  1. User

    is it possible to detect ir by just lighting an led, turn it off, and measuring how much time it takes to loose charge ?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, let's clarify this idea. Your proposed method of "lighting an LED, turning it off, and measuring how much time it takes to lose charge" is a real, albeit less common, technique for using a standard LED as a light sensor.

    Here's how that specific method works, and why it can potentially detect IR (though not efficiently like a dedicated receiver):

    1. The LED as a Capacitor and Photodiode: A standard LED's internal p-n junction has junction capacitance. When you forward-bias it (light it up), you effectively charge this capacitance (and inject carriers). When you turn off the voltage source and let the pin float or connect it to a high-impedance input, this capacitance will discharge. Crucially, a p-n junction also acts as a photodiode when reverse-biased or at zero bias – meaning it generates a tiny current when hit by photons with enough energy.

    2. The Measurement Method (Capacitive Discharge):

      • You briefly charge the LED's junction capacitance (e.g., set a microcontroller pin connected to the LED high).
      • You then switch the pin to a high-impedance input (or configure it as an input with a pull-up and measure when it drops).
      • The charged capacitance starts to discharge, primarily through internal leakage paths.
      • Crucially: If light hits the LED during this discharge phase, the photodiode effect generates a tiny photocurrent. This photocurrent adds to the internal leakage current, causing the capacitor to discharge faster.
      • You measure the time it takes for the voltage across the LED (the capacitor voltage) to drop below a certain threshold (like the input-low threshold of your microcontroller pin).
    3. How Light Affects the Time:

      • No light: The capacitor discharges slowly due to internal leakage. The discharge time is long.
      • With light: The photocurrent from the light provides an additional discharge path. The capacitor discharges faster. The discharge time is shorter.
      • Therefore, a shorter discharge time indicates more light hitting the LED during the measurement window.
    4. Detecting IR with a Standard LED using this Method:

      • Most silicon-based LEDs (even visible light ones, especially red or clear types) have some sensitivity in the near-infrared spectrum (around 940 nm) because the bandgap of silicon allows absorption of these wavelengths.
      • So, if you shine a strong IR source (like a remote control LED) onto a standard LED and use this charge/discharge timing method, the IR light can cause a detectable change in the discharge time compared to when the IR source is off.

    In summary:

    • Yes, the specific method you described (charging a standard LED and measuring its discharge time) is a known technique to use an LED as a light sensor.
    • It works by measuring how much faster the LED's junction capacitance is discharged by a light-induced photocurrent.
    • Standard LEDs can detect IR light using this method, though they are much less sensitive to IR than a dedicated IR photodiode or the integrated IR receiver modules we discussed previously. They are typically most sensitive to the wavelength they emit when used as a detector.

    However, this is NOT how a dedicated IR Receiver Module Works:

    The dedicated IR receiver modules (the ones that output the clean digital pulses) are sophisticated ICs. They don't just measure a simple charge decay. They contain:

    • A specialized IR photodiode optimized for the IR wavelength.
    • Amplifiers to boost the tiny photocurrent.
    • Automatic gain control (AGC) to handle varying signal strengths.
    • A band-pass filter tuned to the carrier frequency (e.g., 38 kHz).
    • A demodulator to strip off the carrier and recover the data pulses.
    • An output stage to provide a clean digital signal.

    While your described method is a clever way to use a basic LED as a simple light detector (including potentially detecting strong IR sources), it's fundamentally different from the complex signal processing performed by a dedicated IR receiver module. The module directly detects the modulated pattern of IR light, not just the presence of steady IR.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.