Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.0-flash-thinking-exp-01-21· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

In Elixir, is there a library (standard lib or hex package) that allows me to: - Start a…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326’s answer.
  1. User

    In Elixir, is there a library (standard lib or hex package) that allows me to:

    • Start a given executable with commandline args and modified ENV variables (e.g. "PORT=1138")
    • Stop the executable again if it is still running (as if pressing CTRL+C in a terminal)
    • Read STDOUT and STDERR of the executable while it is running
  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, you're describing a common pattern in Elixir/Erlang for interacting with external programs that run for a potentially long time and produce streaming output.

    The core mechanism in the Elixir/Erlang standard library for this is the Port module.

    Port allows the BEAM VM to communicate with external processes (written in any language) by opening a communication channel. The BEAM process that opens the port becomes the "controlling process" and receives messages from the external process's standard output and standard error, and can send messages to its standard input.

    While Port is the low-level tool, it's typically wrapped in an OTP process (like a GenServer) to manage its lifecycle, handle incoming data asynchronously, and provide a clean API.

    There isn't one single "library" function like System.run_and_stream, but using Port within a GenServer is the standard Elixir pattern.

    Here's how you'd typically implement this using the standard library (Port and GenServer):

    Conceptual Implementation using Port and GenServer

    You'd create a GenServer module that does the following:

    1. Starts the Process: In its init callback, it uses Port.open/2 with the :spawn_executable option, providing the command, arguments, and the :env option for environment variables.
    2. Receives Output: It implements handle_info/2 to listen for messages from the port. Data from STDOUT and STDERR (which are often merged by default unless configured otherwise) arrive as {:data, {port_identifier, binary_data}} messages.
    3. Handles Termination: It also listens for {:exit, {port_identifier, reason}} messages, which indicate the external process has terminated (either normally or due to an error/signal).
    4. Provides a Stop Mechanism: It exposes a client function (e.g., stop/1) which calls GenServer.call/2 to send a message to the GenServer. The GenServer's corresponding callback (e.g., handle_call/3) then calls Port.close/1 on the port identifier. Port.close/1 attempts to shut down the external process gracefully (often equivalent to sending SIGINT or closing pipes).
    5. Manages Lifecycle: Sets Process.flag(:trap_exit, true) in init so that if the controlling process crashes, the GenServer's terminate/2 callback is called, allowing it to close the port cleanly.

    Example GenServer Implementation

    defmodule ExternalProcessAgent do
      use GenServer
    
      # Client API
    
      @doc """
      Starts a supervised external process agent.
      `command`: The executable path or name (if in PATH).
      `args`: List of strings for command-line arguments.
      `env`: List of `{"KEY", "value"}` tuples for environment variables.
      `opts`: GenServer options and `:on_output` callback.
              `:on_output` should be an MFA (Module, Function, Args) or a function
              that accepts one argument (the output binary). Defaults to printing to IO.
      """
      def start_link(command, args \\ [], env \\ [], opts \\ []) when is_list(args) and is_list(env) do
        GenServer.start_link(__MODULE__, {command, args, env, opts}, opts)
      end
    
      @doc """
      Stops the external process managed by the agent.
      """
      def stop(pid) when is_pid(pid) do
        GenServer.call(pid, :stop, :infinity) # Use a reasonable timeout in production
      end
    
      # GenServer Callbacks
    
      @impl true
      def init({command, args, env, opts}) do
        # Options for Port.open
        # :binary ensures output is received as binaries
        # :args provides command line arguments
        # :env provides environment variables specific to this process
        # :stderr_to_stdout (default) merges stderr into the same output stream as stdout
        port_options = [:binary, {:args, args}, {:env, env}]
    
        # Start the external process via the port
        case Port.open({:spawn_executable, command}, port_options) do
          {:ok, port} ->
            IO.puts("Started external process: #{command} #{Enum.join(args, " ")}")
            # Trap exits so terminate/2 is called if our linked parent dies
            Process.flag(:trap_exit, true)
            on_output_mfa = Keyword.get(opts, :on_output, {IO, :write, []})
            {:ok, %{port: port, command: command, args: args, on_output: on_output_mfa}}
    
          {:error, reason} ->
            IO.error("Failed to start external process '#{command}': #{inspect(reason)}")
            {:stop, {:error, reason}} # Stop the GenServer if port creation fails
        end
      end
    
      @impl true
      def handle_info({:data, {port, data}}, state = %{port: port, on_output: on_output_mfa}) do
        # Received data from the external process's STDOUT/STDERR
        try do
          case on_output_mfa do
            {mod, fun, fun_args} -> apply(mod, fun, [data | fun_args])
            func when is_function(func, 1) -> func.(data)
            _ -> IO.write(data) # Default
          end
        rescue
          e -> IO.error("Error in on_output callback: #{inspect(e)}")
        end
        {:noreply, state}
      end
    
      @impl true
      def handle_info({:exit, {port, reason}}, state = %{port: port, command: command}) do
        # The external process exited
        IO.puts("External process '#{command}' (#{inspect(port)}) exited with reason: #{inspect(reason)}")
        # Now that the external process is done, stop the GenServer
        {:stop, :normal, state}
      end
    
      # Handle unexpected messages from the port or elsewhere
      @impl true
      def handle_info(msg, state) do
        IO.warn("ExternalProcessAgent received unexpected message: #{inspect(msg)}")
        {:noreply, state}
      end
    
      @impl true
      def handle_call(:stop, _from, state = %{port: port, command: command}) do
        IO.puts("Received stop signal for '#{command}'. Closing port.")
        # Request the port (and thus the external process) to close.
        # This will typically cause the process to exit, triggering the {:exit, ...} handle_info.
        Port.close(port)
        # Reply immediately, the {:exit, ...} message will handle the actual GenServer termination.
        {:reply, :ok, state}
      end
    
      @impl true
      def handle_call(request, _from, state) do
        IO.warn("ExternalProcessAgent received unexpected call: #{inspect(request)}")
        {:reply, :error, state} # Or {:noreply, state} depending on desired behavior
      end
    
      @impl true
      def terminate(reason, %{port: port, command: command}) do
        # This is called when the GenServer is shutting down (e.g., due to stop call, exit message)
        IO.puts("Terminating agent for '#{command}' (#{inspect(port)}) with reason: #{inspect(reason)}. Ensuring port is closed.")
        # Ensure the port is closed. Port.close is idempotent.
        Port.close(port)
        :ok
      end
    end
    

    How to Use It:

    # Example 1: Run a simple command that exits
    {:ok, pid1} = ExternalProcessAgent.start_link("echo", ["Hello, world!"], [], name: :my_echo_agent)
    # Output will be printed via the default IO.write callback
    
    # Wait a bit for it to finish (it's very fast)
    Process.sleep(100)
    # Check if the process is still alive
    IO.puts("Echo process alive? #{Process.alive?(pid1)}")
    
    # Example 2: Run a process that stays alive and produces output
    # (Requires `grep`, adjust command for Windows like `findstr`)
    {:ok, pid2} = ExternalProcessAgent.start_link("grep", ["--line-buffered", "keyword"], [],
      # Custom callback to process output - maybe log it
      on_output: fn data -> Logger.info("Grep output: #{inspect(data)}") end,
      name: :my_grep_agent
    )
    
    # Send some data to grep's STDIN (optional - this agent doesn't handle STDIN by default)
    # To send to STDIN, you'd add a handle_cast or handle_call to the GenServer
    # that uses Port.command(port, {:command, data}).
    
    # Let it run for a while
    Process.sleep(5000)
    
    # Stop the process
    IO.puts("Stopping grep process...")
    :ok = ExternalProcessAgent.stop(pid2)
    
    # Wait for it to terminate
    Process.sleep(100)
    IO.puts("Grep process alive? #{Process.alive?(pid2)}")
    
    # Example 3: Trying to start a non-existent command
    IO.puts("Trying to start invalid command...")
    {:error, reason} = ExternalProcessAgent.start_link("non_existent_command_12345", [], [])
    IO.puts("Start failed as expected: #{inspect(reason)}")
    

    Explanation of Key Features:

    • Port.open({:spawn_executable, command}, options): This is the core function to start the external process. Using {:spawn_executable, command} is generally safer than {:spawn, "command args"} as it avoids shell injection issues.
    • :args and :env options: Directly support passing command-line arguments and environment variables.
    • :binary option: Ensures output data is received as Elixir binaries, which is usually what you want.
    • handle_info({:data, {port, data}}, state): This callback receives the output data asynchronously as the external process writes to its standard output or standard error. You can define a custom function (on_output option) to process this data (e.g., parse it, log it, send it to another process).
    • handle_info({:exit, {port, reason}}, state): This callback is triggered when the external process terminates. The reason indicates how it exited (e.g., :normal, exit code). The GenServer then stops itself.
    • Port.close(port): This is the standard way to signal the external process to shut down. For many programs, closing their input/output pipes or receiving a specific signal (like SIGINT on Unix) causes them to exit cleanly, similar to hitting CTRL+C.
    • GenServer: Provides the necessary structure to hold the port state, manage the asynchronous messages, and handle the lifecycle gracefully (start, stop, termination on crash).

    Hex Packages?

    While there isn't a single standard Hex package specifically for this streaming, non-waiting pattern that completely replaces using Port and GenServer, many libraries that interact with external processes use Ports internally.

    • System.cmd/3: This is part of the standard library, but it's primarily for running a command synchronously and waiting for it to finish, collecting all output at the end. It does not stream output while running.
    • porcelain: A popular library for running shell commands. It can be used for asynchronous execution and capturing output, but it might focus more on waiting and capturing all output rather than streaming chunk-by-chunk data while the process is running without waiting. You would still likely need to manage its lifecycle if the process is long-running.

    For the specific requirements of streaming output while running and graceful stopping without necessarily waiting for the process to finish, the Port module wrapped in a GenServer as shown above is the most direct and idiomatic Elixir/Erlang solution. It's the building block that any higher-level library for this purpose would likely use anyway.

    So, yes, the capability exists within the standard library (Port, GenServer), and the example above provides a robust way to use it.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.